Was Saddam a brutal dictator for a reason?, page 2
Pages: <<  1    2    3  >>
ATS Members have flagged this thread 0 times


reply posted on 10-5-2004 @ 10:15 PM by Hoppinmad1
Originally posted by Agent47
Originally posted by Hoppinmad1
He was but is it any better to replace a murdering dictator by killing thousands more people. 10,000 innocent civilians killed there that is insane.

I can't stand these people who think war in this situation is justified when there was no just cause yet given.


Whats insane are your figures. Where did you generate 10,000? Is that how high you can count, or is that the population of your home town? If you can give an unbiased tally that is above or at 10,000 then I retract my statements.

There are reasons we went to war, them being Saddam has killed millions and possessed the capability to kill millions more.


Unbiased tally
www.infoshout.com...
www.iraqbodycount.net...
conspiracy-history-news.joeuser.com...

Just think every one of those x's on the first page had a mother a father, son's and daughters. Is killing justified. Also be sure to look at the wounded numbers. Those with legs blown off and such.

There is an old saying from the vietnam war that says fighting for peace is like F@(*ing for chastitiy. Makes sense. Now think if someone dropped a bomb on your house by accident. Woops sorry its all for a good cause. I don't think so. Whos the real culprit. Troops doing their jobs or the leaders who force them to.

There are peaceful ways to solve things and don't say there aren't. Many of you say oh in 20 years or so Iraq will be a blooming democracy if we keep up the fight. Well given 20 years do you think trying a peacfull solution would work?

Saddam had his bad poing but going to war and killing thousands more than he did and permanatly wounding countless others. Is that justified.


reply posted on 11-5-2004 @ 03:21 PM by Agent47
Originally posted by Hoppinmad1
Unbiased tally
www.infoshout.com...
www.iraqbodycount.net...
conspiracy-history-news.joeuser.com...


For the record this enlightened poster sent me this as a U2U and I am suprised to see he would publicly post such crap.

Two sites are made by foreign peace activists and the third is a very shady conspiracy site.

Anything else I would want to add Mr. EXone has already touched on.

[Edited on 11-5-2004 by Agent47]


reply posted on 12-5-2004 @ 12:03 AM by Hoppinmad1
Originally posted by Agent47
Originally posted by Hoppinmad1
Unbiased tally
www.infoshout.com...
www.iraqbodycount.net...
conspiracy-history-news.joeuser.com...


For the record this enlightened poster sent me this as a U2U and I am suprised to see he would publicly post such crap.

Two sites are made by foreign peace activists and the third is a very shady conspiracy site.

Anything else I would want to add Mr. EXone has already touched on.

[Edited on 11-5-2004 by Agent47]


And what do you call this site if those are shady. I have read some super ridiculous stuff here. And does the fact that a database of those killed in the war is run by peace activists make it any less authentic. I don' t think so.

If you don't belive almost 17,000 iraqis have been killed think of this. How many times in the last year have you seen on the news about a few american soldiers being killed then them saying 30 or 40 or more iraqi fighters were killed also. Too many to number. With almost 800 american soldiers dead it's not hard to do the math. And think how many deaths havent been reported.

Blah Blah saddam was evil. But who made the u.s. the untilmate deciding authority on morality. The pro war activists like to ramble on about how good saddam is out of power. Sure take out one leader who does harm and incite millions of others to hate us. Makes lots of sense doesn't it. As many have said we made him who he was. Those weapons he made were made with american chemicals and other countrys also. Kuwait was cross drilling into his country also.

Like I said he was bad. But being brainwashed by the media into beliving that killing is ok for the sake of morality is just rediculous.


reply posted on 12-5-2004 @ 12:14 AM by AceOfBase
Originally posted by Agent47Whats insane are your figures. Where did you generate 10,000? Is that how high you can count, or is that the population of your home town? If you can give an unbiased tally that is above or at 10,000 then I retract my statements.

There are reasons we went to war, them being Saddam has killed millions and possessed the capability to kill millions more.


Here are some figures from Amnesty International:
Amnesty International
A year after the war began Iraqi civilians are still being killed every day. Over 10,000 Iraqi civilians are estimated to have been killed since 18 March 2003 as a direct result of the military intervention in Iraq, either during the war or during the subsequent occupation. The figure is an estimate as the authorities are unwilling or unable to catalogue killings. "We don't have the capacity to track all civilian casualties," US Brigadier General Mark Kimmitt told Reuters in February.


I don't find that 10,000 figure hard to believe, there were over 600 Iraqis killed just in one week in Fallujah in April.
USA Today
Asked about the report of 600 dead, Marine Lt. Col. Brennan Byrne said: "What I think you will find is 95% of those were military age males that were killed in the fighting."

"The Marines are trained to be precise in their firepower .... The fact that there are 600 goes back to the fact that the Marines are very good at what they do," he said.


Can you now post some reliable links to back up your claim that Saddam killed millions?

[Edited on 12-5-2004 by AceOfBase]


reply posted on 12-5-2004 @ 12:41 AM by Seekerof
as quoted by AceOfBase
Can you now post some reliable links to back up your claim that Saddam killed millions?


Here you go AceOfBase:
Saddam and the Kurds

From within it:
Saddam Hussein & Human Rights Abuses

Since the regime fell in April 2003, U.S. and international forensics teams have searched for evidence of the scale and scope of the Baathist regime's human rights abuses. As of this date, there are more than 200 mass gravesites in Iraq. Some estimates place the number of victims of the regime at 300,000 to one million. Most gravesites are believed to contain the bodies of Shiite Muslims, as well as Kurds killed in the post-1991 war uprisings against Saddam Hussein.


And this:
More on Saddam's Human Rights Violations

And this:
Can Iraqi People Get Rid of Saddam on Their Own?
Since Saddam’s Baath Party seized power after a military coup in 1968, the regime has slaughtered nearly 2 million Iraqis, this is not an exaggeration, it is real, but the irony is that facts in Iraq are stranger than fictions.



More if needed.



seekerof

[Edited on 12-5-2004 by Seekerof]


reply posted on 13-5-2004 @ 02:49 AM by Hoppinmad1
I want to start this out with a nice picture check out the video too. www.gwu.edu...
HMM whos that mystery man. Thats 1983 you said saddams been murdering since 1967 hmmm...

Thank you ace of bass and special asian x. Amnesty international is kinda hard to argue against huh. What happened to and I quote agent 47 "If you can give an unbiased tally that is above or at 10,000 then I retract my statements." Hmm wheres that retraction? Remember these arent soldiers this is just the civlian toll. Not counting wounded.

Now you like to say that the baath party slaughtered millions. These people have been fighting basically a private civil war for decades. Its a power struggle and some are gonna lose. Armed religious groups have been trying to take control for decades. Whos responsible for their deaths. Them I think. You fight against your government and you might get killed.

Like asianx says when you have as many people in iraq as there are armed to the teeth struggling for power there are going to be consequences.

What do you think would happen if a large group of people armed themselves and tried to take over our government? Think it would be bloody. I think so. Our government keeps us in control with the fear of imprisonment(mental torture), Execution, Monetary Fines, and Physical Labor. I've said saddam did many terrible things. But at least he kept the country in control. He took it farther than he should many times I'm sure. But if you live in a society with strict laws with strict punishment I think I would be good don't you?

Heres links to executions since 1976 when the death penalty was reinstated.
www.clarkprosecutor.org... That is 907 people.

Also the u.s. has averged 373 police killings a year since 1976 which is around 10,000 people. Theres is no database on this as shown by a former ny times article shown here.
www.commondreams.org...

As of the end of 2002 there were over 2,033,331 prisoners that were held in Federal or State prisons or in local jails. www.ojp.usdoj.gov...
I can't find any info on deaths in prisons and abuse and such cuz the iraqi prison thing has clogged the search engines but I am sure it's signifigant.

Now is it clear that to keep a society in check a certain amount of evil is required. When a society has super radical islamic extremists fighting for any control they can muster. It's these extremist religion that calls for many deaths in the first place.

Heres an article about u.s. and other companies providing iraq with chemicals.
www.cnn.com...
So now lets think if saddams bathist regime has been slaughtering millions since 1967 don't you feel the u.s. is responsible for allowing the export of these chemicals. Hmmm....

Are we responsible for putting saddam in power? Heres a Congressional record written by a senator. Congressional Record: September 20, 2002 (Senate)
Page S8987-S8998
www.fas.org...

Are our former leaders and some present responsible also. Yes. I'm sure of it. Who's the real bad guy here. I think if you allow such wrongdoing go on and help someone do so much wrong a peacefull soltuion is a must. Like many have said let them make their own government. They don't want us there.

[Edited on 14-5-2004 by Hoppinmad1]

[Edited on 14-5-2004 by Hoppinmad1]

Pages: <<  1    2    3  >>    ^^TOP^^



DEA is Investigating Montana State Legislators Over State Laws
  Posted 12 days ago with 59 member flags
The CIA in Australia: America\'s Foreign Watergate
  Posted 2 days ago with 19 member flags
Who is really behind the birthers and what is their real motive?
  Posted 12 days ago with 11 member flags
ESF and Black op funding.
  Posted 10 days ago with 11 member flags
There is NO Media Bias in America
  Posted 11 days ago with 10 member flags