reply to post by virraszto
Rereading my post, I see I wasn't very clear.
What I wanted to say was that I think that having this disorder become more widely known may prevent actual assaults or rapes by making it easier for
people to get the diagnosis and to accept the diagnosis.
That benefit of publicity will outweigh the possible downside of having people try to claim it as a mitigating factor in criminal cases. For one
thing, I think it would be incredibly rare for such a case to involve someone outside the house and the burden of proving the disability was a factor
in a case like that could be set extremely high.
I'm sure the most common occurrence is the rape of a bedpartner, and I didn't mean to imply that that wouldn't be terrible and traumatic, just that
it would be unlikely to be prosecuted in criminal court if both parties were aware of the diagnosis.
I can't imagine being in that situation, and I guarantee that if I fell in love with someone who aggressively attacked me – ever, even if I knew he
wasn't aware or accountable – we would not be sharing a bedroom. But I also can't imagine pressing charges in a case like that.
The major concern, I think, would be in cases like the one you relate, where a family friend who is staying over is attacked. And these are exactly
the kind of cases that I think are most likely to be prevented by making the diagnosis more widely known.
I hope that's a little more clear
I admire your strength in living with this and your honesty in talking so openly about it.