Originally posted by masqua
Originally posted by LDragonFire
In a nutshell, my belief is that religions, All of them, are false.
There is a difference between organized religion and religion.
I disagree here, one person believing in God and living by what he thinks his god wants, to me is faith. A group of people living by this very same
mindset becomes religion, and once it involve multiple people, the manipulation naturally starts, the agendas inter into the equation. All religions
are corrupt, because lets face it, humans are corrupt, they will use whatever means to justify their actions or to fulfill a agenda they believe in.
If religions where truly inspired by God, their would be a divine influence to counter this corruption in us all, to this point in history there is no
evidence of this occurring, what we get instead is the need or requirement to attend church on a regular basis to reaffirm the faith, kinda like
having to return to the gas station in order to keep your car going.
It could be stated that ALL organized religions are conspiracies to control the masses and that they originated in prehistoric times, before
monarchies, governments and countries as a way to keep things quiet among a group of people who had to live together.
I believe God was born from mans fear of the unknown. They way man explained things that were unexplainable was to put a God face on it, hence the
first religions worshiped the Sun, Moon, and nature in general.
All true... but it was established so long ago that there is no record or individual conspirators we can point to. It is a truly ancient
form of control.
I 100% agree with you here, the only clues we have are of human nature, primitive human nature at that.
The thing is, though, that society would never have begun in the first place had it not been for this idea.
This I completely disagree with, humans are social creatures, it is in our nature. Human society began as hunter gatherer groups, rules for society
developed out of necessity, groups that were successful developed the necessary rules for society or they did not survive.
Monkeys as well as all other social creatures have developed complex societies without religion, we are the same as them, just smarter.
But there is another part of the puzzle that isn't a conspiracy at all.
What initially started religion? Was it not the realization that there was something more to life than just nature? Instincts were fine for
hunting/gathering, but mankind rose beyond that and began to 'contemplate' on the best methods to hunt and gather. This abnormal behaviour known as
'navel gazing' bore fruit in that it bettered the lives of the people. Hunters would join together to perfect the method of the hunt and others
would transplant edible crops in community plots in order to best serve the needs of the tribe.
The people who 'thought' of these ideas were called shaman and these unique men and women became tribal leaders; the first politicians to rise to
the occasion of 'organizing things'.
These shaman would pass knowledge down from one generation to the next verbally before written language, if a tribes shaman would die prematurely, the
entire tribe could parish. Once writing was introduced this changed everything, the tribes were not completely dependent on the shaman anymore, they
became dependent on the writings.
Power corrupts even with a title of shaman did not mean these were good people, they just had more knowledge than the average joe. Writing changed
this, so the ones with the power of reading and writing now had the power over everything, the corruption continues. The written word is very powerful
and can effect people generations even a millinia after the words have been penned.
To me the shaman used a form of religion to aid in controlling the tribe, good or bad.
The written religion has and is used to control the world.
There is a part of the brain which is the fountain of invention and that is where religion 'really' got established from. It is our ability
to seemingly pick ideas out of the darkness of our unconsciousness and put them to use for the betterment of everyone else.
Lets say a early human tribe crops failed, the people go to the shaman and ask why, the shaman replies it's the will of the Gods and we must make a
sacrifice to please the Gods, so they make a human sacrifice and in a short time they have a good hunt or they fight another tribe and take there
food, this reaffirms that there God has saved them. Good or bad will happen and it's a win win situation for the shaman, if bad happens then the
scrafice wasn't good enough to please their God, if good happens then their God listened to them and blessed them. I say religion evolved out of
necessity a tool if you will, most humans must believe in something
The Golden Rule of all religion is the idea of doing for others what you'd like them to do for you. Living by that standard forces one
to reflect on their own conscience and apply the rule to everything they do. It's the beginning of civil society. All the failings of mankind which
thwart the giolden rule are reflected in more rules like the Ten Commandments. Greed breeds trouble, for instance.
I believe most of these rules were in effect long before the ten commandments, and were a natural evolution of human society that was incorporated
into religious law, but truthfully we can speculate all day on this. There is really no way of knowing.
So, religion HAS a purpose and it IS a positive influence.
The problems with it lie within all the human tendencies to ignore or subvert that initial Golden Rule.
If you give credit to religion this is a true statement, but we really don't know where to give this credit. Religion has impeded science and
advancement in humans {see dark ages} religion has destroyed more human cultures on Earth than anything else {north and South American Indians and
countless others with a convert or die mentality that continues in some religions today} religion is responsible for more deaths or murder of humans
than any other belief process {inquisition, witch trials, war based on religious differences, crusades, ect} religion has directly controlled more
humans than any other belief process, look at how many early humans scientists especially in old Europe had to watch what they wrote or said publicly,
religion dominated All of Europe along with old world monarchies for centuries.
It explains why so many wanted to come to America, So they could have religious freedom.
But really from my point of view, I see little Good about religion.
Awesome topic and a great discussion.