The Lasting Effects of Slavery, page 1


Pages: <<  1    2    3    4  >>
ATS Members have flagged this thread 4 times
Topic started on 29-3-2007 @ 06:53 AM by CSIfan
Part 1

I'm new to ATS, and Social Issues, but I see that a lot of members wonder why we African Americans continue to refer to slavery as a kind of historical touchstone. It happened ages ago-- why should anyone care now?

Why do descendants of American slaves ask for reparations?

I just need to say a few things...maybe that will help others, of all races, understand the feelings, not of all, but just one African American (descended from slaves) and born and raised here in America.

The pain and shame is something that you can never understand. Although my ancestors suffered the pain/shame long time ago, I am heartsick about it.

No, I am not crazy, just haunted by images...of what was allowed to happen to someone because they look like me. Here in America.

At 5 yrs old, in NYC, I was getting ready to visit Southern relatives...my Mother warned me not to say anything that would make a White Person angry, what could happen to me down south! You see, when you mentally & physically abuse an entire Nation of people, that abuse is handed down through each generation...gestures, speech, forced humility, inferiority ("don't look them in the eye, look down to the ground)". Yes, it becomes the fabric of that Nation.

Did you know that when you apply to adopt a child, you are disqualified if you have been an abused child? Well, try to parallel that concept with an entire Nation of abused people? Try to imagine the parenting skills of people who were reluctant to love their own children because they could be sold "away" at any moment? Try to wonder why some women murdered their own children after birth, just so they would never know slavery or, if a daughter, rape? Try to see how a woman could love a man who was set up by a master to be her mate? So, was that, or wasn't that something like destroying the fiber of the African family? This was INSANITY, and on American Soil!

How about the rapes? Beatings? Auction block? The total humiliation of a human being? And now someone wants to know why the children and grandchildren of these people want compensation?

The children and grandchildren of America's slaves live with the pain, I lived with the pain. Sometimes I feel that I am better, and some days it comes back, the horror of it all. I see it all around me. Families so totally insane, acting out the horror of Slavery, today in 2007.

I like to use this example to describe the after effects of the mass torture of African Slaves: Take 1000 people, have them line up, and hit each one on their head with a baseball bat as hard as you possibly can...okay, now, this is what you might get:

10 per cent may die immediately

40 per cent may not ever be “quite right” again

40 per cent may have pain for a while, and be okay later

10 percent may not show that they are even hurt, and may go on to appear fine and live good lives

What I see today is that most descendants of American Slaves continue to suffer from slavery one way or another. Lynchings, mental and physical, continue...

But here's where it gets hairy: during my 'healing process", I began to realize that I need to keep up my guard. And to be vigilant...

The "other children", the children of the Master...this is scary...The generations who were descended from "The Master", they were raised by him, and all his hatred, torture, rapes...the sickness of the Master...a man who could buy and sell human beings...kill at will…








[edit on 29-3-2007 by CSIfan]


reply posted on 29-3-2007 @ 07:19 AM by DDay
Very very well said and for it you have my way above vote.

Although I have never myself been subjected to this type of behaviour I have to take some responsibility for the actions of "my" people.
It shouldn't be this way, it never should have been but it did happen and the generations of people after are having to bear those scars.

It's the quiet kind of hurt that you carry that gets lost on most. People only hear the "squeaky wheels" of the African American. Those that cry injustice and look for hand outs. I hope you understand what I am trying to say.

I see too that it continues to be passed down. You will always look to the ground and never someone directly in the eye because it's what has been taught and it's ingrained.

I was actually just thinking about this the other day. I was walking down the hall at my work and there was the janitor cleaning the floor. A black man. We have many African American janitors in our bldg and Latina's cleaning our bathrooms. Why is that?
How often do you see a white person doing those types of jobs?

Is this the same reduction of equality only now they earn a salary albeit a small one? Or it is because this is all they know? Because the hopes and dreams of the African American people have been forever reduced to what's left over in our country?

I don't know the answer. I can only say that regardless that slavery was long ago abolished there will always however wrong be a line that divides our nation.

For that I am so very sorry.



reply posted on 29-3-2007 @ 12:46 PM by Benevolent Heretic
CSI, I understand (as well as I can) your points about how painful slavery was for your ancestors. I'm afraid where I don't (or perhaps can't?) understand is why you carry pain and shame for something you didn't experience yourself. But I will take your word for it that you feel these things. I'm sorry you feel so bad.

But take hope. Being a child molestation, rape and cancer survivor myself, and no longer carrying the pain and shame of any of that, please know that you don't have to carry pain and shame around with you.

Originally posted by CSIfan
At 5 yrs old, in NYC, I was getting ready to visit Southern relatives...my Mother warned me not to say anything that would make a White Person angry, what could happen to me down south!


My mother told me that black people were dirty. She told me not to trust them and not to touch them or I'd get dirty. I guess the difference is that at some point, I decided she was wrong. And I cast aside the lies she told me and learned to make judgments about people, not for the color of their skin, but by who they are.

It sounds like your formative ideas about white people came, not from white people, but from your mother.


Try to see how a woman could love a man who was set up by a master to be her mate?


Arranged marriages are still practiced in many cultures.


Lynchings, mental and physical, continue...


Physical lynchings continue? Where?


The "other children", the children of the Master...this is scary...The generations who were descended from "The Master", they were raised by him, and all his hatred, torture, rapes...the sickness of the Master...a man who could buy and sell human beings...kill at will…


Who are you talking about here? Who are these "children of the Master"? Who specifically?

Originally posted by CSIfan
So, this is why I think we are owed reparations, which will certainly be mostly spent on much needed therapy (at least in my case).


I hope you can get some therapy if you feel you need it. Do you have insurance? Because many insuurance plans pay for therapy.


Can a Country like America allow policies that drive people insane?


Absolutely! America still allows policies that drive people insane. I'm sure if you 'travel' around ATS a while, you'll come across many American policies that drive all sorts of people nutso.

Originally posted by CSIfan
Anything that happened in Africa or Rome, for that matter, is not relevant here.


One thing that I notice in race discussions is that we aren't "permitted" to bring up other instances of the subject matter to add perspective to the discussion.

Whatever we're talking about, it helps to see the big picture and add perspective to bring in other comparative and relevant points of view. But in these race threads, I notice a stringent lack of willingness to expand the discussion to see the larger picture. It is desired that we focus on a specific subject as if it's closed off from the rest of the world and doesn't have its place in a larger picture.

We're told not to bring class into race discussions, even though it's relevant. We're told not to bring minority privilege into discussions about white privilege and not to talk about how Africans enslaved their own people when we're talking about how Americans enslaved people. Why not? It gives a discussion perspective.

I don't think a subject can be accurately explored without looking at the "other side" or the "bigger picture".

Think of it this way. If you're standing in a small circle with some other people and all of a sudden, an elephant is popped right into the center, filling up the space, and all you can see is it's butt crack and its tail. Now, someone is going to ask you to accurately describe what you see...

Your description is going to be very different than the person's who was standing right in front of the eye.

However, if you all took a step back to get perspective, and walked around the beast and explored the thing from all angles, you'd have a much better and more accurate description of the thing. Then you'd all be on the same page and could talk more interactively about it.

But if one person insists that an elephant looks like a big vertical crack with a tail swishing back and forth across it, and that's ALL an elephant is... then we can't discuss the whole thing or what the other people saw.


reply posted on 29-3-2007 @ 01:07 PM by CSIfan
Originally posted by semperfortis
My sister suffered abuse from the time she was 4 until leaving home at 18... She has just adopted her grandchildren and though it was a lond drawn out process, the fact she was abused never entered into the equation...


So sorry, I should have written that when a formerly abused person attempts to adopt, children's services agencies are very cautious and the result is a "long drawn out process" because of the fear of the recurring cycle, as referred to by Goldman, Salus, Wolcott, Kennedy in "A Coordinated Response to Child Abuse and Neglect: The Foundation for Practice
User Manual Series (2003)"


Parental Histories and the Cycle of Abuse

A parent's childhood history plays a large part in how he or she may behave as a parent. Individuals with poor parental role models or those who did not have their own needs met may find it very difficult to meet the needs of their children.

While the estimated number varies, child maltreatment literature commonly supports the finding that some maltreating parents or caregivers were victims of abuse and neglect themselves as children.23 One review of the relevant research suggested that about one-third of all individuals who were maltreated will subject their children to maltreatment.24 Children who either experienced maltreatment or witnessed violence between their parents or caregivers may learn violent behavior and may also learn to justify violent behavior as appropriate.25

An incorrect conclusion from this finding, however, is that a maltreated child will always grow up to become a maltreating parent. There are individuals who have not been abused as children who become abusive, as well as individuals who have been abused as children and do not subsequently abuse their own children. In the research review noted above, approximately two-thirds of all individuals who were maltreated did not subject their children to abuse or neglect.26

It is not known why some parents or caregivers who were maltreated as children abuse or neglect their own children and others with a similar history do not.27 While every individual is responsible for his or her actions, research suggests the presence of emotionally supportive relationships may help lessen the risk of the intergenerational cycle of abuse.28"

A Coordinated Response to Child Abuse and Neglect: The Foundation for Practice- Chapter Five: What Factors Contribute to Child Abuse and Neglect?



reply posted on 29-3-2007 @ 01:40 PM by Mr No One
Originally posted by CSIfan
Okay, we need to agree on the most important thing about this discussion:

Anything that happened in Africa or Rome, for that matter, is not relevant here.

As I explained in the original post, I was raised in NYC so this is about America only.

This is about what was allowed to happen on American soil.

Lets stay on track!


Why is that the most important thing about this discussion? Why is that the track that we need to stay on?

Wouldn't the most important part of this discussion and the appropriate track to stay on be "The Lasting Effects of Slavery?"

Why is it irrelevant to speak of what happend in other parts of the world? Without the existing slave trade in Africa, there never would have been African slaves in America in the first place.

What did the US government allow to happen on American soil?
History of Slavery in North America
You can see in this link (and others if you do a google or yahoo search) that slavery in North America dates back to 1619. 1619! Over 100 years before there was a US government. The tradition of slavery was imported to North America. It was the US government that DISallowed slavery on American Soil.

And since it is relevant, though not very supportive of your arguement, the tradition of slavery dates back THOUSANDS of years AND even in (OMG) Africa. Hmmm. Let me ponder this. Weren't the Hebrew people held as slaves in Egypt? Does that mean ALL black people owe a debt of reparation and/or apology to ALL Jewish people? No, no it doesn't.

Edit to add:
PS - I'm white and proud of it. And my friends are proud of me too - the whites, blacks, hispanics, asians, indians, muslims - all of them. Sick isn't it? How all these races can be proud of a white person????

[edit on 29-3-2007 by Mr No One]
Pages: <<  1    2    3    4  >>    ^^TOP^^