It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
originally posted by: introvert
a reply to: Annee
I agree.
Again, I was only speaking on why the BLM movement was created. It was not simply some creation of the political Left. It was born of perceived systemic racism and disparity.
What they have become is no real concern of mine.
originally posted by: introvert
a reply to: Edumakated
Let's be specific... what exact racial disparity and systematic racism?
Incarceration rates being higher among blacks when compared to other people of color. Longer sentences, etc.
BLM largely grew out of the Mike Brown case which was proven to be a lie, much like all the other cases that cropped up afterwards. Hands up, Don't shoot never happened.
Ok, does that change the validity of their message?
While I don't deny that there is racism, even though I am a black guy, I've yet to see where it significantly held me back in my life.
Anecdotal. Logical fallacy.
I see a lack of personal responsibility and accountability in the black community and from our so called political class that seems to benefit from the continue social and cultural dysfunction.
That is true as well. These issues are not as black and white as people like to make them.
That political class you speak of goes beyond Left or Right. Both sides have skin in the game.
Today, the question on everyone’s mind is “Which Hillary?” The question refers to Hillary Clinton’s wavering stance on a number of current issues, varying statements about historical events, and conflicts between her positions on important matters and her campaign’s financial reality. Conflicting statements made by Clinton over the past few months have left many American voters viewing Hillary’s platform as anything but solid. As a result, many are quickly losing faith in Clinton’s ability to stand firm on important issues.
The most recent incident to raise the “Which Hillary?” question took place on Wednesday during a Clinton campaign rally in South Carolina. According to Huffington Post, the event’s interruption was caused by two activists representing the Black Lives Matter campaign. They asked Clinton to apologize for a statement she made in 1996 and for policies enacted during Bill Clinton’s presidency that led to increased mass incarceration of blacks. Their view of the candidate contradicts the image Hillary Clinton has tried to promote during her campaign through words of support for black justice. The activists apparently view Clinton’s words as nothing more than a ploy to win the African-American vote
agitator in chief @soit_goes 1h1 hour ago
16,000+ Sanders supporters have pledged they #WontVoteHillary if she is the nominee, take the pledge wontvotehillary.com... #WhichHillary
mo Bernie2016
@nana_mo_Amelika
#WhichHillary the one that's against firearms or the one that sells them?
Lee Fang Verified account
@lhfang
American-made F-15s are being used by Saudi Arabia to destroy Yemen, killing thousands, including children.
2) The fact BLM spring out of Mike Brown changes the validity of the message because it brings into question the accuracy of the claims.
“Hillary Clinton has a pattern of throwing the Black community under the bus when it serves her politically," Williams said in a statement before the event. "She called our boys ‘super-predators’ in ’96, then she race-baited when running against Obama in ‘08, now she’s a lifelong civil rights activist. I just want to know which Hillary is running for President, the one from ’96, ’08, or the new Hillary?”
The Clinton campaign didn't immediately return a request for comment.
1) You have not proven the higher incarceration rates are a result of systematic racism. The fact that blacks are disproportionately in the criminal justice system does not mean that statistic is a result of systematic racism. There are cultural and other issues at play.
2) The fact BLM spring out of Mike Brown changes the validity of the message because it brings into question the accuracy of the claims.
3) Agree, logical fallacy. Nevertheless, it is not on me to prove to the systematic racism exists as I am not the one making the claim that is a huge issue. If someone is going to claim that systematic racism is holding black people down in 2016, I need some concrete proof beyond specious claims like higher incarceration rates.
Blacks also dominate the NBA, can we claim the NBA is engaged in reverse racism? It is racist when there are hardly any black golfers, but everything is all great when blacks dominate the NBA?
4) The political class I am referring to is almost entirely on the left side of the political spectrum when it comes to blacks. Last time I checked, Jesse Jackson, Al Sharpton and the other zoot suit wearing preachers weren't voting Republican.
Most of the cities where all this alleged systematic racism is occurring are almost entirely run by Democrats and blacks. So somewhere, BLM is not connecting dots to the current situation that they are protesting.
originally posted by: AlaskanDad
a reply to: Annee
Why talk about 20 yrs ago, which Hillary?
HRC recently took money from private prison lobbyists - then says she is against private prisons
HRC recently pushed the TPP as the gold standard : now claims to be against it