posted on Mar, 1 2012 @ 07:31 PM
You're generalising by calling anyone who likes the film a "meathead". Makes you a meathead. I agree there are flaws, the script is by the weakest
element of the film. By that I mean the dialogue, there are some ropey lines in there. I think the shakey camera is overdone and it takes away some of
the focus from the action and also the aliens. I think Staff Sergeant Nantz's character is by far the most interesting and certainly the strongest. I
thought the Nigerian born Corpsman Aduku was interesting and they could've done more with him. I think with the film, you either accept it or you
don't. There's no middle-ground. For me, it's an unadulterated love letter to the USMC more than anything. And in doing so, it tries to portray a
certain reality. I.e the young marines ribbing the virgin for instance. It was more of an initiation ritual more than anything. There's also the
"marines don't quit" thing, they're obviously trying to establish the character of the USMC more than anything. It gets up some people's noses because
they think it's a recruiting ad or they feel it's clichéd. I just see it as an entertaining film that finally shows an alien invasion from the
perspective of the serviceman/woman. Even though it plays like a war film it does enough to stand out as an alien invasion film as well. It's also
about how war has changed them. If you look at the final slew of young marines, namely Imlay, Harris and Lockett (you don't care I know but they're
reference points). Then you see how the conflict has changed them, how it's etched on their faces. Plus when you think about the young boy Hector
losing his Dad like that. And what the other two young girls experienced. There is an underlying theme about the loss of innocence. It doesn't centre
on that strongly, nonetheless it's present. I don't really see how you can explore the characters too much without making the whole thing overlong.
Even with Black Hawk Down, you don't get a lot of character development for all the soldiers. But since it's based on an actual event, it lends itself
gravitas. Although that film has a much different focus to it.
edit on 1/3/12 by Retro~Burn because: (no reason given). Out of all the clichés
they could've gone for, they didn't do the 'kill the token black guy' thing, which I'll give kudos to it for!
edit on 1/3/12 by Retro~Burn
because: late edit