Ok, have to: this is a good one!
From the IIPA (INternational Intellectual Property Alliance, basically tahts IRAA, MPAA and BSA) on indonesia:
www.iipa.com...
First for all those that said "If you want free stuff, go get the free stuff, if you want to give stuff away for free, do so"
The IPPA begs to differ:
While IIPA has no issue with one of the stated goals of the circular, namely, “reducing software copyright violation,” the Indonesian
government’s policy as indicated in the circular letter instead simply weakens the software industry and undermines its long-term competitiveness by
creating an artificial preference for companies offering open source software and related services, even as it denies many legitimate companies access
to the government market. Rather than fostering a system that will allow users to benefit from the best solution available in the market, irrespective
of the development model, it encourages a mindset that does not give due consideration to the value to intellectual creations. As such, it fails to
build respect for intellectual property rights and also limits the ability of government or public-sector customers (e.g., State-owned enterprise) to
choose the best solutions to meet the needs of their organizations and the Indonesian people. It also amounts to a significant market access barrier
for the software industry.
Buhuuuu... If you use free stuff we cant sell you stuff! (Indonesia wants to switch to free OS software to reduce costs. Cant let them do that, can
we???
And these two:
Camcording Piracy: Camcording piracy remains a problem in Indonesia, aggravated by the absence of anti-camcording legislation. Illegal camcording of
major U.S. movies occurs right off the screen by professional camcorder pirates, who use video cameras to illicitly copy a movie during exhibition in
a movie theatre.
Industry reports that a new Cyber Law was enacted (“Law of The Republic of Indonesia Concerning Electronic Information And Transactions”) which
could be helpful in combating unauthorized use of copyright materials in the online space. Article 25 of the Cyber Law provides protection for
copyrighted works in electronic formats. Unfortunately, the acts of communicating or making available copyright materials are not included in the
“Prohibited Acts” (Articles 27 through 37). These acts should be added as expressly prohibited. While generally, ISPs are cooperating with right
holders, the Ministry of Communication and Information needs to devise a strategy to deal with growing Internet piracy in 2010, including mechanisms
to ensure removal of infringing content and dealing with illegal P2P file sharing.
"unfortunately these two illegal activities aren't illegal." ...
wait, what???