Originally posted by Misoir
1.End all free trade agreements with countries that are not developed and ones that are not under a democratically elected government with civil and
political freedoms.
I find this highly disgusting because of the term "free". The first key belief is about selling out moral values, for the right price. Sure you can
send over your child-labor produced items. But you'll have to pay our sin tax first. Sin tax one of the most offensive things in existence. Crime for
profit. All nations should be allowed to trade free of charge. Taking money without asking is stealing, and I don't support theft. The term "free"
really smears boogers on an otherwise reasonable proposition. If you want to consider cutting off trade entirely, you'd have my ear.
2.Never loan money to any nation, our government may generously give money to another nation but should never expect that money
returned.
Fine, so long as each donation is ultimately a voluntary one for each of the root donors. Otherwise, you are forcing majority opinion
about which governments should be donated to upon a minority who may disagree.
3.Government does not have the right to invade any person’s privacy without justifiable reasons and is approved by a jury court system.
Sounds good to me.
4.Government has several duties to always uphold; all people are guaranteed their supreme rights to religious beliefs, political beliefs,
speech, assembly and all constitutional freedoms.
Very good.
5.Government’s only duty is to protect its citizens from; poverty, hunger, oppression, slavery, inequality, injustice, terror, tyranny and
foreign occupiers.
Disagreed. I think that government should be doing whatever its citizens ask of it so long as it isn't clearly causing any form of harm to anybody,
and so long as it is not withholding anything from those who do not wish to participate (most notably the taxes required for the actions taken). Also,
in some cases many people want to be unequal. For example if everyone else wears an orange headband, they may want to wear a green headband or even no
headband at all. The word "inequality" is in a way to generic for me. Maybe "political inequality" would work, though even then I question its
full meaning.
6.All people should be willing to donate their free time to aid charities.
Agreed, but what is more important is that nobody should be forced to do such a thing, and to do so is slavery... a disgusting crime against humanity
entitling the attempted enslaver to a very long prison sentence. I'd also consider it false for those who only have a few minutes of free time
7.Neighbor should help neighbor, and friend help friend.
Very good point, and again, forcing someone to do such a thing is among the worst things someone can do because contaminates all good done by the
organization with an overtone of evil, because it turns what was best described as "help" into what would best be called slave labor. However, going
around helping people is about charity and possibly best left to things called "charities" rather than governments. But if it isn't harmful for
government to get involved I suppose I've got little objection. I'd just rather see more items in the top 10 like "disallow people from killing
each other" and other points that build on things like that.
8.Family should be considered an important part of all people’s lives and should be strengthened through community.
I strongly agree with the statement. I don't see however how government can get involved in that. I guess if you know of a way, I could agree with
that as a function of government so long as programs are not mandatory to either pay for or participate in.
9.Religion has no business in government, religion is personal and rejection of organized religion should be encouraged.
Blatantly
impossible as phrased... kind of offensive if you think about the ramifications. If someone is a Christian and they are also a member of government,
that is in some respect religion in government. And therefore you would ban that. So I disagree. I'll agree that preachers have no business ordering
politicians around and vice-versa.
10.Community and government should cooperate to assist the elderly, young, and disabled with their finances, health, and activities.
I
strongly agree because you have used the term "should" rather than "must"... meaning communities who raise moral objections to any form of
cooperation should fail to cooperate. Only where there is agreement on what is being cooperated on should they cooperate. The best role of government
would be therefore to recommend certain charities to people and make sure people are informed about the needs of their communities.
I don't have time for further review but hope you find my commentary valuable.
[edit on 16-1-2010 by truthquest]