The most likely scenario considering the three failed appearances is that it wont appear again

Originally posted by OzWeatherman
Originally posted by star in a jar
I've come to realize that we might not be able to see it at all, since it is a brown dwarf companion to our sun that only emanates heat, and little light.
Well thats where the Nibiru'ers contradict themselves. They say its a brwon dwarf and will be visible in the sky soon? The only way to identify brown dwarfs is by infrared, measuring their radiation output
If it arrives in 2012 I will humbly accept I was wrong....if it doesnt arrive, what date will the Nibiru'ers come up with next? Because we know they wont admit it doesnt exist
The problem with dates on this one is because of the Expansion Theory. Our universe supposedly expands and contracts. This would have more of an effect on an elliptical orbit than a regular one.
On that note, here is a reprint of April 2007 in today's NGM headlines. news.nationalgeographic.com...
Enjoy!
[edit on 20-10-2009 by DaWhiz]
Originally posted by fallenearth
Snoopy im with you on this. I think someone is posting or bumping tons of Planet X stuff on this forum. Of course they are not putting a direct link to their book or video BUT they are getting the interest up for people to go google it and there websites come up. Just use a little brain power. Some of these are undercover advertising id bet my life on it.