Well since it was the University's idea to this because I guess they have a large Muslim student population that were often using sinks to wash their feet, I'd say I have to agree it's more of a health and safety issue than anything else. Now if they opened up special rooms with arrows pointing in the direction of Mecca, that'd probably be a different thing.

oh the Drama, i mean how could they, its a digrace
a univerity building a footbath of the agnony, this issue should be sent to the higest courts to be blocked at once.

serious now

so a unverity wants to build a footbath and now its the fault of muslims?
whats your problem, i would understand if it was muslims lobying to get this built but its not close to that. this whole this thing is just a joke

If there was just a handful of Muslims there who sued to get these installed, I'd agree it shouldn't be done. But it seems that there is a significant Muslim population there and they're going to wash their feet one way or another, so some type of accommodation that makes it better for everyone (I'm sure the non-Muslims don't like using the sinks after some Muslim has washed his feet in it) doesn't seem to be extraordinary to me.

If I went to a school where people were washing their feet in the sink several times a day, I would pay for the footbaths myself. I don't see this as being strictly for the benefit of Muslims, I think this is a benefit for everyone that has to use the sinks.

It seems like a rather practical solution.

i will tell you this from experience
and this has happend in my place of education we never asked for religous rooms or anything, they were offerd.

services were also offerd to jews,hindus, and so on

Its all PR and comapnies wanting to keep their employees happy.
and this isnt confined to muslims who are getting these so called bennifits

Originally posted by djohnsto77
If there was just a handful of Muslims there who sued to get these installed,

What real difference does it make?

It started with a handful at Northwestern and now it is spreading. They certainly all did not get overtly religious over night you know, they have been here for years without one peep now all of a sudden The Kansas city airport needs them Northwestern needs them and now Dearborn so it is just the start and I do not think it is right for non Muslims to pay for them. If they want them fine they can pay for them, with that I would have no problem.

If you or I wanted to wash our feet they would tell us to use the school gym or school dorm and if we did not they would probably fine us for breaking a health ordinance as should the Muslims.

Originally posted by shots
What real difference does it make?

a big diffrence none of those muslim went up in arms or petitioned for one,
they got one offerd to them. learn the diffrence will do you a world of good.

Originally posted by shots
It started with a handful at Northwestern and now it is spreading. They certainly all did not get overtly religious over night you know, they have been here for years without one peep now all of a sudden The Kansas city airport needs them Northwestern needs them and now Dearborn so it is just the start and I do not think it is right for non Muslims to pay for them. If they want them fine they can pay for them, with that I would have no problem.

so? they are putting things up for all faiths not just muslims.
all the sudden they do some things to accomidate a muslims need and its high crime.
and another thing they PAY their TAX aswell not just you and most likely there are muslims in your country that contribute more then you aswell.

Originally posted by shots
If you or I wanted to wash our feet they would tell us to use the school gym or school dorm and if we did not they would probably fine us for breaking a health ordinance as should the Muslims.

what a joker
like its religous item, footbath for cleaning feat. anyone can use it
yes that right None Muslims can use them aswell (its a big supprise but its true, its just another facility)

shots I totally understand your point of view.

I don't think they should be able to get these installed mandatorily through the courts; however, it might very well be illegal to keep them from using the sinks to wash their feet.

There is no direct comparison to this in Christianity, there is nothing like this mandated by our religion.

My basic opinion is if there are just a few Muslims, let them use the sink, but if there are so many that it's becoming a problem, facilities should install the foot baths. It would be better than having hordes of people using the sinks, spreading germs, and spilling soapy water everywhere. What if someone (either Muslim or non-Muslim) slips and cracks their head open? That would probably be much more costly than installing the foot baths in the first place.

Originally posted by bodrul
now was there any reason to make a big deal out of it? :

But you are missig the point here if you give them an inch they are going to demand a mile, then two, then ten, you get the drift and that scares me.



[edit on 6/18/2007 by shots]

Originally posted by shots
No not really I used that as an example of how they are pushing for various religous reasons all of a sudden.

a request for something and all the sudden they want to change your way of life, great

Originally posted by shots
Another example that could be used perhaps you are familar with was the demands made in a UK and Belgium prision systems to have the toilets turned because they faced the wrong direction.


See it sounds funny yet it is true they are pushing more and more each day to get the world to change to their ways and that scares me.

this is funny
if you go to some muslim homes its very likely that they have toilets facing the wrong way.

its only those very religous people that will go to the length of ensuring that they dont face mecca but then again if you commited a crime then i dont see them being that religous.

i wont argue on this as i find it hilerious but the rest of your examples and thoughts , you should have an idea of my views on them.

Originally posted by shots

Originally posted by intrepid
Isn't that a totally different issue?

No not really I used that as an example of how they are pushing for various religous reasons all of a sudden.

Sorry shots, calling the BS card here. From your OP:

Kary Moss, director of the Detroit branch of the ACLU, said its review concluded the plan is a "reasonable accommodation" to resolve "safety and cleanliness issues" that arose when Muslims used public sinks for foot cleaning before prayers, which often spilled water on bathroom floors.

"We view it as an attempt to deal with a problem, not an attempt to make it easier for Muslims to pray," said Moss, who likened the plan to paying for added police during religious events with huge turnouts.

"There's no intent to promote religion."

Different altogether. No Muslim asked for these footbaths. NOW you're introducing other things in here to demonize Muslims. I'm surprised that you can't see that. Well, not really.