At the end of last years's college FB season, there was much talk on this site, including from me, about what a thug and criminal punk Marcus Vick had
turned himself into, and how much money it was apt to cost him. Well, none of us deserves a medal for genius, but we were right. Here's a story from
Updated: April 17, 2006, 1:17 PM ET
Teams more diligent in assessing players' characterBy Greg Garber
Marcus Vick throws a better ball than his older brother Michael, the Atlanta Falcons' star. He isn't quite as quick -- but, then again, very few
humans are. They played the same position at the same school, quarterback at Virginia Tech, and left college at precisely the same size: 6 feet, 215
But, while Michael was the first overall pick in the 2001 NFL draft, there is a good chance Marcus won't be taken on the first day.
A series of brushes with the law and poor decisions -- from the alleged possession of marijuana to charges of sex with a minor (later acquitted), the
alleged brandishing of a gun and the memorable (and intentional) stomping on the leg of Louisville defensive end Elvis Dumervil during the 2006 Gator
Bowl -- led to Marcus' dismissal from Virginia Tech in January.
As a result, NFL personnel experts project him to fall at least to the fourth round and, more likely, beyond. A significant number of teams say they
have removed him from their draft board entirely.
Rick Spielman, former general manager of the Miami Dolphins, who also evaluated college talent for Chicago Bears and Detroit Lions, saw Vick play this
season against West Virginia.
Matt Stroshane/Getty Images
Marcus Vick is undoubtedly talented, but brings a lot of baggage to the table.
"He has a lot of talent," said Spielman, now an ESPN Insider. "But at that position, the player is the leader of your football team and has to set the
tone, an example. If he's not doing things the right way off the field, how can you expect the team to follow him? He flipped off the fans at West
Virginia -- that's not how you lead."
Emotion can be a positive factor on the playing field, but the opposite is also true.
"I'm trying to show the kind of person I am, you know, show the world that I'm not the person some people make me out to be," Vick said in his defense
at the scouting combine in February. "[It's like I'm] some kind of bad guy, like the villain."
If Vick had made fewer off-field headlines and spent more time on the gridiron, he might well have been a late first-round draft choice. As such, he
would have been in line for a five-year contract worth as much as $15 million, including a $3 million to $4 million signing bonus. Now, he's looking
at something like a $200,000 signing bonus and an annual contract in the same neighborhood.
The difference between Marcus and Michael Vick? In a word, character.
Defined loosely as moral or ethical strength, character has never mattered more to those who assess college football players. It is a complicated
element that encompasses not only a player's body of work on the field, but his police record (if applicable), work ethic, sense of team and passion
for the game.
This year's NFL draft, April 29-30 at Radio City Music Hall in New York City, will feature some difficult but compelling character decisions. In the
past, some NFL teams have paid lip service to the importance of character, but with the annual salary cap now past $100 million, successful teams go
out of their way to do their due diligence.
The New England Patriots won three of four Super Bowls by seeking athletes who were willing to subjugate themselves for the good of the team; the
selflessness of two-way player Troy Brown is a good example. The Pittsburgh Steelers, who place a similar premium on character, captured this year's
Super Bowl title in Detroit.
"It's always important to get good people as well as good players," Steelers director of football operations Kevin Colbert said. "From the Steelers'
point of view, from top to bottom, ownership demands that character is a big factor in this organization."
"You can't lose sight of a guy's physical skills on tape, but even good organizations have been hurt by drafting people whose character is
questionable," said Scot McCloughan, the 49ers' vice president of player personnel. "Ninety percent of the time, it will bite you in the ass.
"If we have two guys pretty close, we'll take the guy with less talent that weighs in with more character. Half the grade going into this is: How's
the kid wired?"
Judging character is a wildly subjective proposition. Sometimes, teams get it wrong.
When rumors circulated that University of Pittsburgh quarterback Dan Marino had allegedly abused drugs, he slid to the end of the first round in 1983.
Seventeen seasons later, when Marino retired as the game's most prolific passer, no one was questioning his character.
In other instances, though, there is fire where smoke is perceived. The Denver Broncos, defying conventional wisdom, drafted Ohio State running back
Maurice Clarett in the third round of last year's draft after he had been out of football for two seasons. He was good-sized (5-11, 230 pounds) and
fairly fast (4.55 in the 40-yard dash), but he was dismissed from Ohio State in 2003 after a series of incidents.
Broncos coach Mike Shanahan, who had experienced spectacular success by drafting lightly regarded running backs Terrell Davis, Olandis Gary and Mike
Anderson, felt it was worth the risk. Admitting he made a mistake, Shanahan cut Clarett in training camp.
Shanahan served as the Raiders' head coach in 1988-89 and learned a willingness to gamble from owner Al Davis, a self-styled outsider in the elite
men's club that is the NFL. The Raiders have long prized talent over character in building teams. First-round choices Todd Marinovich (1991), Darrell
Russell (1997) and Sebastian Janikowski (2000) at the very least raised some questions before their respective drafts and encountered brushes with the
law as pros. Russell, whose NFL career was plagued with a string of incidents, including rape charges in 2002, died in a high-speed car crash in
When a team is uncomfortable with a potential character issue, it becomes real easy to pass on that player. When you see a player starting to fall
unexpectedly, most times there are question marks that have not necessarily become public.
There are countless instances of situations that raise questions regarding a player's character. I think back to a Senior Bowl experience during my
scouting years when I was on an airplane leaving Mobile, Ala. in which the majority of the plane was filled with players and scouts. One of the
players was extremely rude to a flight attendant and his overall conduct was embarrassing. Not only did it leave a negative impression on the
individuals on that flight, but the word spread like wild fire regarding his behavior throughout scouting circles. Within a week, everyone in the
league had placed a red flag on this player's card and ultimately it wound up costing this player dramatically on draft day.
Sometimes character issues can be false. In the days leading up to the draft, there are always countless rumors of late-breaking issues that could
entail character, medical, etc. At this point in the process, everyone is paranoid.
I remember a specific case in which a highly-rated player was expected to go in the top five of the draft. One day prior to the draft, a team picking
in the six-to-nine range made some specific calls to teams drafting ahead of them and simply asked, "Have you received the newest report regarding
serious character issues" about the prospect? When the team that was asked responded by saying, "No, we haven't heard anything," the caller simply
hung up the phone. On draft day, the player in question slipped to the bottom of the first round and to this day many people, including myself, are
convinced that many teams passed on him because they simply could not confirm the suspicious call that some teams had received one day earlier.
As this year's draft approaches, former USC quarterback Matt Leinart has suddenly raised a red flag. Nobody has ever accused Leinhart of being a
character problem but the recent firing of his agent Leigh Steinberg raises a lot of potential questions.
Whether you like Steinberg or not, the fact is that he is a reputable agent with a great history with quarterbacks. When he is fired two weeks before
the draft, even after a successful draft preparation process in which his client looks like a sure top-four draft pick, something does not make sense.
Is Leinart going "Hollywood" and paying more attention to off-the-field opportunities rather than football? Is he listening to other agents, who
always are trying to steal players? It would seem that at the very least there are some question marks about Leinart's loyalty and integrity and even
the teams at the top of the draft will want to be comfortable with this situation.
Gary Horton, Scouts Inc.
It was Davis who traded for wide receiver Randy Moss -- passed over by several teams in the 1998 draft because of character concerns -- last year
after seven turbulent, albeit statistically successful, seasons in Minnesota.
The Cincinnati Bengals, who have one of the smallest scouting staffs in the league, also have routinely ignored character as a measuring stick. It has
hurt them over the years, particularly in the case of some of their high-profile first-round choices -- defensive tackle Dan Wilkinson and wide
receiver Peter Warrick, to mention two.
With the stakes so high in the draft -- if one in seven draft choices is a failure, it can have a profound effect on the roster -- teams spend an
extraordinary amount of time and money in pursuit of character references.
"When I was with Miami, we had a director of security that did background checks," Spielman said. "It's a pain to go through different courthouses
where players grew up, but it's worth the effort. You can learn about potential rape charges or if a guy got three tickets for fishing without a
Teams with a large veteran contingent or a strong-willed head coach seem more willing to take chances with questionable character. That was definitely
the case when the Broncos took Clarett and Minnesota chose Moss.
Yet, it's not just the teams that find themselves concerned with the character issues throughout the draft process.
Long before he began representing some of the marquee players in the league, including Eli Manning and seven other starting quarterbacks, agent Tom
Condon was less than selective when seeking clients.
"Early on, we were just taking whatever players we could get," said Condon, who played guard for the Kansas City Chiefs for 11 seasons. "The two
characteristics that determine success are intelligence and character. Now, it's a big factor for us.
"As I look through our last few classes of players, you could take virtually any of those guys home and be proud. It makes life so much easier.
They're attractive to people in terms of marketing dollars, and later they can move more easily into the broadcast booth."
For the Steelers' Colbert, character will remain a draft key.
"The best-case scenario," he said, "is a good player with impeccable character. That means you have no concerns. Next level, you have one incident or
a personality trait that raises concern. The guys with a couple of incidents that suggest a pattern are the ones you stay away from."
This year's draft has players who fit all those descriptions. Here are a few burdened by the baggage of off-field issues that will create some tension
during draft weekend:
• Oklahoma offensive tackle Dusty Dvoracek
An interesting case study.
Dvoracek was stripped of his captaincy and missed 10 games in 2004 after he got into a fight in a bar in Norman, Okla. He was reinstated for 2005
after undergoing anger-management and alcohol-related counseling. In Dvoracek's request for a medical waiver, he admitted he was an alcoholic.
Scouts say Dvoracek -- an academic achiever who produced one of the very highest scores on the Wonderlic test at the combine -- has second-round
talent but will probably drop into the third round.
That said, the fact that Dvoracek has shown signs of maturity by staying out of trouble once reinstated to the team should keep him from sliding too
• USC offensive tackle Winston Justice
A 6-6, 311-pound specimen, Justice was suspended for the 2004 season after he and some friends pulled a fake but real-looking gun on a USC student.
"I'm always going to be sorry about it," Justice said. "But it's in the past. I'm trying to live day by day to show people that I am a good-character
Justice, who protected Matt Leinart's blind side, is projected to be the second tackle taken -- behind D'Brickashaw Ferguson of Virginia -- going as
high as the No. 8 pick, but no lower than the Eagles' No. 14 overall choice.
“ It's always important to get good people as well as good players. From the Steelers' point of view, from top to bottom, ownership demands that
character is a big factor in this organization.”
—Kevin Colbert, the Steelers' director of football operations
• Florida State outside linebacker A.J. Nicholson
Nicholson was sent home prior to this year's Orange Bowl for violating team rules after a woman claimed she was sexually assaulted by the linebacker.
However, while questioned by police, he never was charged. Seven weeks later, Nicholson answered many character questions at the scouting combine.
"If they're paying money to have you on their team, [teams] should want to ask and should want to know, and are obligated to know," Nicholson said in
Indianapolis. "It hurt me because it kind of damaged my character and put me in a light I don't want to be put in. They know I'm a good player."
Indeed, Nicholson was soaring up the draft board before the incident. He has first-round talent, but will any team be willing to risk taking him that
Finding the Fire
In the biggest college football game of the season, LenDale White outran the player who will undoubtedly be drafted first overall, USC teammate Reggie
White carried 20 times for 124 yards and scored three touchdowns against Texas in the Rose Bowl. While USC lost the national championship game, White
saw his draft stock rise sharply.
But something funny happened on the way to the draft -- actually, nothing happened. White, whose playing weight is about 235, weighed in at the
combine at 236 and managed only 15 reps of 225 pounds in the bench press, 10 fewer than the 200-pound Bush. At USC's pro day, White checked in at 244
pounds. There have been rumors that he's hit the mid-250s. Probably not helping matters, it was revealed on Thursday that White has a torn hamstring.
"A big-time red flag," one NFL scout said. "The guy has issues. He never worked out. When he takes his shirt off, a 21-year-old kid shouldn't have a
But that same scout added, "He should have been a high first-round pick, but he could be there in the second round. Then, you're debating value of the
pick versus downside. You'd have to think about it."
As it stands, ESPN draft expert Mel Kiper has White going to the Carolina Panthers at No. 27.
Then you have the opposite of cases like White. Instances in which a well-rounded individual -- whether he's very strong academically or has a variety
of interests -- might draw a red flag because teams question whether he's dedicated to football.
D'Brickashaw Ferguson, the top offensive tackle prospect in this year's draft, has drawn a curious eye from some scouts because he plays the
saxophone, according to ESPN the Magazine.
"Work ethic versus too laid-back -- it's tough to assess," Condon said. "There [are] guys with laid-back personalities that will work like mules.
Still, there are some guys who don't love football. It's almost cliché to bring up the name of Ryan Leaf, but when you're looking at that big,
strong, athletic guy, you're wondering why he didn't succeed."
Ryan Leaf had few answers during his tenure in the NFL.
Leaf was the second pick in the 1998 NFL draft, behind Peyton Manning, but he never made the Pro Bowl and was out of the league after just five
seasons. Why? He didn't have the fire for the game.
"Work ethic, passion for the game equals character," the 49ers' McCloughan said. "My job is to explain to Coach [Mike] Nolan what [a prospect] brings
to the table. Is his work ethic going to cause offseason [workout] problems?"
Jeremy Green, who worked for the Browns in player personnel from 2000-05, places a great emphasis on this facet of character.
"Is the guy doing the extra things he needs to do, or is he the first one out of the building at the end of the day?" said Green, director of scouting
for ESPN.com's Scouts Inc. "Does the guy like football? I would rather take a player with a little bit of baggage over a player with no heart or [who]
doesn't like football.
"In Buffalo, it's obvious [former offensive tackle] Mike Williams doesn't like football. And they made him a top-five pick. Heart is a big part of the
And so is professionalism.
"The combine is like a job interview," Spielman said. "It's like wearing flip-flops and a T-shirt instead of a jacket and tie. It raises all kinds of
Virginia Tech cornerback Jimmy Williams has been the subject of those kind of questions. He is the second-rated defensive back in the draft, behind
Texas safety Michael Huff. Williams has size (6-3, 213 pounds) and speed (4.48), and as a junior he was terrific, making five interceptions. In 2005?
"One interception," said Todd McShay, Scouts Inc.'s director of college football and the NFL draft. "He was lazy and took a lot of unnecessary risks.
He comes off as very arrogant."
McShay said Williams has top-10 talent -- Arizona still could take him with the No. 10 pick -- but he could fall into slots 20-25.
In a world where speed, strength and toughness usually prevail, is character overrated?
"No," Spielman said. "A tiger doesn't change its stripes. Eventually, you'll have issues with a player with a history. He may be an angel for a year,
but it will circle around. If you're comfortable dealing with those issues on your team, that's fine. But beware."
Caveat emptor: Let the buyer beware.
"Our experience has always been to take the best combination of person and player," the Steelers' Colbert explained. "On the other hand, you don't
want to give someone too much credit for being a good person and not a good enough football player.
"You can't ignore accusations, but you have to be careful to separate rumors from the truth. You just don't know. Nobody's perfect. Players on our
team certainly aren't perfect. We just try to get as many good guys as we can.
"You just hope you're getting what you think you're getting."
It will be interesting, assuming he stays out of prison until draft day, and gets to sign an NFL contract, to see an expert's estimate of just how
much money he cost himself. All these decades later, I still remember all too well about being young, dumb, violent, a "tough guy," etc., but it
never cost me any serious money, much less an eight-digit sum. Of course, even at my absolute drunken worst, I never did the kind of stuff this