a reply to:
FinallyAwake
I've watched all 5 seasons, I saw no indication of Miller coming back, and they killed off Alex rather unceremoniously at the end there. Wasn't too
happy with that. I preferred the earlier seasons, more going on and less family drama or skipping larger battles in favor of showing the many annoying
facial expressions of Naomi, who is quickly becoming as annoying a character as Michael Burnham in Star Trek Discovery. I still very much prefer the
Expanse over shows like Discovery, the Orville, the new BSG and Lost in Space though. The Expanse is fairly decent as far as modern shows go. But hey,
nowadays you get 2 seasons worth of entertainment divided over 5 seasons, so the show is still a bit short for high entertainment value for me (a bit
like Firefly and Space: Above and Beyond, taken together, which is where I ranked it in my personal list).
My entertainment value list (i.e. how I rate my level or amount of enjoyment of these shows, including a consideration regarding runtime and number of
episodes):
Stargate SG-1 and Atlantis (me: 9 and 8.8; IMDB: 8.4 and 8.1 respectively)
Babylon 5 (8.5; IMDB: 8.3)
DS9 (8, has more filler episodes compared to B5; IMDB: 7.9)
Stargate Universe (6.4; IMDB: 7.6)
TNG (6.3; IMDB: 8.6!!! so overrated compared to DS9)
The Expanse (6.2, if it weren't for a couple of things that bug me I would rate it higher (6.5 at least), among which is my inability to understand
Avasarala, the Indian actress, her angry or swearing scenes are also cringeworthy. I can also do without Naomi, she reminds me too much of Discovery's
Michael; IMDB: 8.5)
Picard (6.1; IMDB: 7.5)
Space: Above and Beyond (6, a bit too short for much higher ratings; IMDB: 7.7)
The Mandalorian (6, I'm not sure I like the setting of a lone wolf with little potential for interstellar politics, war and massive space battles akin
to Stargate, B5 and DS9. Production quality is top notch though, very stylish; IMDB: 8.8)
Firefly (5.9, a bit too short for much higher ratings; IMDB: 9, so overrated because of the cultfans)
Voyager and Enterprise (5.8; IMDB: 7.8 and 7.5 respectively. Enterprise has a nice story arc in the latter seasons, Voyager has some cool episodes
with the Borg and species 8472)
Farscape (5.6; IMDB: 8.3)
The old BSG (5.5, better than the new one; IMDB: 7.1)
The shows listed below are for comparison but are not my favorites, I have watched them though:
ST Discovery and the Orville (4; IMDB: 7.3 and 8.0)
Dark Matter (3, it's a bit cheap in comparison with the new BSG, if only they had had the same budget though, who knows; IMDB: 7.5)
Andromeda (2)
The new BSG (1, I could barely stomach this lazily written, convoluted and forcefitted soap/drama/nonsense show on which way too much money was spent
for HQ effects; IMDB: 8.7, hereby nominated as the most overrated Sci-Fi show ever and biggest waste of money for a show that could have been done so
much better)
Non-Sci-Fi shows that I've watched:
Game of Thrones (6.5)
The Witcher
His Dark Materials
The Dark Crystal
The Last Kingdom
Blackadder (7.9)
Hornblower (7)
Deadwood
There are more, but none that are particularly noteworthy. I hated The Walking Dead and Fear the Walking Dead, sort of skimmed through it because it
was listed so high on IMDB (in number of votes, can't see the attraction, and you're getting ripped off with cheap drama and excessively violent shock
value thrills. It truly is cheaply produced utter garbage). Lost in Space was better than I expected, but still sad they replaced Dr. Smith for a
female character for the usual reasons. But my expectations were exceedingly low because of just struggling my way through TWD and FTWD (with some The
Boys in between, also a typical modern show that I usually don't like but with a few redeeming qualities though; the whole marketing superheroes
angle).
I gave up on the new Dr. Who show, not my type of show (watched a couple of seasons, until it got too incoherent for me, and too 'modern', not sure
how to sum up every issue I have with modern shows; there was something with a beach and someone in a spacesuit, and perhaps a wedding or something, I
lost the plot there, and my interest. Watched a couple more episodes after that but I think that's when GoT or the Expanse started or something, so I
switched).
edit on 18-2-2021 by whereislogic because: (no reason given)