It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
originally posted by: Jungian
I dont think theres been a solid WW2 movie since Das Boot and A Bridge too Far.
originally posted by: Macenroe82
a reply to: Jungian
I've watched 3 docs on Des Doss after watching Hacksaw Ridge.
From what I've heard Mr Doss say in these docs. this movie seems to be a fairly accurate representation of the events that took place on Hacksaw Ridge.
Of course Hollywood has to add some flash and what not.
But I felt the movie praised Mr Doss for his extreme courage and selflessness that took place during his time served in WW2.
I disagree completely. I am not a fan of gore, violence, or action for the sake of gore, violence, and action, i.e., no war-porn for me; however, I am a fan of literature, story-telling, and romantic tales. The battle scenes were intense and brutal, and they went a long way to romanticise bravery, courage, and faith. This film lived up to its purpose.
originally posted by: eirgud
a reply to: Jungian
... and the action scenes where an incoherent mess that made no sense. It was just mindless slaughter and war-porn.
I know war is messy and probably a whole lot more chaotic than I can imagine, but as a movie, it failed to capture the deeper horror. "Fury" and "Saving Private Ryan" did it way better. Hacksaw Ridge felt more like it was catering to action-hungry 12 year olds.
originally posted by: AbdulAlhazred
a reply to: Jungian
I'd agree to some extent. It was watchable, but not what I was expecting.
It took me a while to get used to Vince Vaughn as a serious actor in True Detective Season 2, but ultimately I think he played that part well.
As the drill instructor/Gunney in Hacksaw Ridge, I just couldn't take him seriously, though to be fair, in my mind any movie gunney is always compared to R. Lee Emery in Full Metal Jacket, or Clint Eastwood as Gunney Highway in Heartbreak ridge, and that's a tall order to meet!
originally posted by: Discotech
a reply to: eirgud
Oh please.... Fury was a joke
First the battle with the Tiger was in no way believable
And then the "last stand" against the Axis zombie horde (may as well have been a zombie horde), all those wermacht armed with panzerfausts and they couldn't kill a single, tracked sherman ? Give me a break
I thought Hacksaw Ridge had believable battle scenes
Although nowhere near as good Saving Private Ryan or The Thin Red Line