It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by Dreamz
Originally posted by Amethyst
Originally posted by Dreamz
I guess I will never understand these anti-american , anti-Bush threads.
Bush is not America. Being anti-Bush is not being anti-American. I don't like the way the Republicrats are shredding the Constitution and running this country into the ground.
I'm a Constitution Party member btw.
Republicans are trashing the Constitution?? Last time I checked there is a thing called check and balances and ANY law can be stopped or changed. Republicans alone cant pass laws, maybe you should do a little history on how the American Government works. What exactly is trashing the constitution anyways? My life hasnt changed at all.
Originally posted by Dreamz
slaughter. Do people not realize what a war really is? People die, mistakes are made, crimes will happen.
Originally posted by Seekerof
Hey everyone, you reckon' that during the Vietnam War, that the very sentiments and comments made within this very thread were also echoed in America then?
America divided: Our Iraqi Nightmare=America divided: Our Vietnam Nightmare= deja vu'?
If so, whats are all of you saying that wasn't said and predicted, etc. then?
seekerof
[edit on 19-11-2004 by Seekerof]
Originally posted by EastCoastKid
Originally posted by Dreamz
I guess I will never understand these anti-american , anti-Bush threads.
Dissent is AMERICAN. NOT anti-American. It is covered by the 1st Ammendment to the U.S. Constitution. Read it. Then you will understand that.
We must not confuse dissent with disloyalty. When the loyal opposition dies, I think the soul of America dies with it. - Edward R. Murrow
Naturally the common people don't want war; neither in Russia, nor in England, nor in America, nor in Germany. That is understood. But after all, it is the leaders of the country who determine policy, and it is always a simple matter to drag the people along, whether it is a democracy, or a fascist dictatorship, or a parliament, or a communist dictatorship. Voice or no voice, the people can always be brought to the bidding of the leaders. That is easy. All you have to do is to tell them they are being attacked, and denounce the pacifists for lack of patriotism and exposing the country to danger. It works the same in any country. - Hermann Goering
To announce that there must be no criticism of the president, or that we are to stand by the president, right or wrong, is not only unpatriotic and servile, but is morally treasonable to the American public. (1918) - Theodore Roosevelt
I never said it wasnt your right, I just think its partisan politics and beliefs. Criticize the president all you want and America for that matter, but when you do it on blind hatred and false beliefs then im sorry its misguided. IMO its lack of understanding about the American government or maybe having to much of a belief in conspiracy, everything isnt a conspiracy.
Do you know that throughout history we have heard the same crap over and over again. If we had CNN at the beaches of Normandy do you think we couldve dealt with all the dead at that slaughter. Falluja is hardly a slaughter. Do people not realize what a war really is?
I have seen war. Have you? Generally, statements like these come from those who have never witnessed it themself. And it's thoroughly offensive. To say that Fallujah is not a slaughter is naive in the extreme. And as for the battles of WW2, as Marg pointed out, WW2 was a very different war. There's simply no comparison. The invasion of Iraq was/is an illegal war of aggression. What we've done is no different than what Hitler did. I feel sorry for you folks who are too blinde or stubborn to see and acknowledge that. That is exactly what I meant when I said God will never bless or protect a nation that uses such wanton aggression. Woe to us, for our sins will be counted and answered with equal measure.
Yes I have seen war up close, does it make any difference that we have and other people havent, should the people who havent not be able to express their opinions because they havent seen it. Dissent is American remember. Comparing the cleansing of complete human races to what we are doing in Iraq is just another misguided belief. If thats what you want to believe so be-it, if that were the case we would be tossing every muslim we see in America and abroad into concentration camps, this is a weak line for someone opposed to the war. WWII may be a different period in history but by no means is it different in terms of what we are fighting. If you think Nazi Germany vs current day terrorist threats are that different, Ill give you one difference...We could see Nazi Germany.
these people never mention anything about the beheading's of international citizens by the very people the Americans are fighting. Its really funny that America can be criticized over and over again by everyone, yet I dont see anyone else trying to make a difference.
Beheadings.. you should really look into U.S. and Israeli covert operations in Iraq and elsewhere. There you will find the responsible parties for many of these gruesome acts. It's called PSYCHOLOGICAL WARFARE. Something else you may want to consistantly ask first and foremost is.. who stands to gain? Things become much more clear when you approach it from that angle.
This is typical spin to someone with no answer. Lets pass the ball to someone else and put the blame on them. Instead of looking hard at blaming America or Israel for everything wrong, why dont they have a look at themselves. We didnt tell those governments to keep their people living in 13th century worlds.
A good example..
Margaret Hassan execution: Anatomy of a CIA-DIA-Mossad Counterinsurgency operation?
.
November 17, 2004
�It is with profound sadness that we have learnt of the existence of a video in which it appears that our colleague Margaret Hassan has been killed. We are shocked and appalled that this has been the apparent outcome of her abduction,� CARE International said in a statement released yesterday. �Through her courage, tenacity and commitment, she assisted more than seventeen million Iraqis living in the most difficult of circumstances.�
More than 200 college professors since April 30, 2003, according to the Iraqi Union of University Lecturers, have been the targets of assassination. In addition, many intellectuals have disappeared. (See Andrew Rubin�s Bloodbath.)
In December, 2003, Julian Borger of the Guardian reported, �Israeli advisers are helping train US special forces in aggressive counter-insurgency operations in Iraq, including the use of assassination squads against guerrilla leaders. � US forces in Iraq�s Sunni triangle have already begun to use tactics that echo Israeli operations in the occupied territories.�
�A new Special Forces group, designated Task Force 121, has been assembled from Army Delta Force members, Navy seals, and C.I.A. paramilitary operatives, with many additional personnel,� according to Seymour Hersh.
Israel funded Hamas, as the UPI�s Richard Sale reported in 2002.
The Palestinian Authority arrested a group of collaborators who confessed they were working for Israel, posing as al-Qaeda operatives in the Palestinian territories, in December, 2002. A PA official said the collaborators sought to �discredit the Palestinian people, justify every Israeli crime and provide reasons to carry out a new (military) aggression in the Gaza Strip.�
Israel currently runs covert ops in the Kurdish area of Iraq (see Seymour Hersh�s Plan B)
A CIA instruction manual entitled Psychological Operations in Guerrilla Warfare, written in the 1980s, states the following: �Bring about uprisings or shootings, which will cause the death of one or more persons � in order to create greater conflicts.�
US military (and CIA operative) officer Major Edward Geary Lansdale�s �psy-war tactics� used in the Philippines against the Huk. Lansdale�s methods �centered on measures of deception similar to those employed in the British and French colonial campaigns in Kenya and Indochina,� including the creation of bogus guerilla units used to discredit the enemy. (See Michael McClintock�s Instruments of Statecraft: U.S. Guerilla Warfare, Counterinsurgency, and Counterterrorism, 1940-1990.)
mparent7777.blog-city.com...
From another post: As far as us Allowing the Iraqis to have an election, I say this: If Allawi actually was in charge we couldn't LET them do anything. He is nothing but a NeoCon puppet.
You just posted something from a blog with not one credible source in it. It quotes the Palestenian Authority on a remark against Israel, that just reeks credible.Yeah I think ill be like you and believe everything it says, hold on ill be right back, im gonna add to my blog that pigs can fly. Will you believe that too?
The fact of the matter is that Allawi really has no choice but to go along with the Americans and no one is saying he isnt a puppet, of course he is. That wont change until the people are allowed to vote for themselves.
as mentioned by ECK
...are your interests simply vested with the war profiteers?
Originally posted by Seekerof
as mentioned by ECK
You didn't answer the question ECK. Despite the obvious name changes and playa's, what and has been said now that wasn't transcripted and yelled in and during the Vietnam Era?
As to the quote above, war profiteers have been around about as long as warfare has been around. Your problem with them is what?
I do dabble in stocks, you?
Regardless, my vested interest is in curtailing some of this BS rhetoric that continually makes it appearance in times like these....
They tell me that the best way to fight fire is with fire, is that true? If it is, does that also involve someone that makes a profit from fighting fire? Thought so....
So your "vested interest" is what exactly? To continue to throw out half-truths twisted into nice little bow-tied applets to spread your self-believed propaganda?
Originally posted by Seekerof
as mentioned by ECK
...are your interests simply vested with the war profiteers?
You didn't answer the question ECK. Despite the obvious name changes and playa's, what and has been said now that wasn't transcripted and yelled in and during the Vietnam Era?
As to the quote above, war profiteers have been around about as long as warfare has been around. Your problem with them is what? That they make a living off of death?
As to me having a "vested interest," I do dabble in stocks, you? Regardless, my vested interest is in curtailing some of this BS rhetoric that continually makes it appearance in times like these....like they did when the Vietnam War was happening.
They tell me that the best way to fight fire is with fire, is that true? If it is, does that also involve someone that makes a profit from fighting fire? Thought so....
So your "vested interest" is what exactly? To continue to throw out half-truths twisted into nice little bow-tied applets to spread your self-believed propaganda?
seekerof
[edit on 19-11-2004 by Seekerof]
ECK: Dissent is AMERICAN. NOT anti-American. It is covered by the 1st Ammendment to the U.S. Constitution. Read it. Then you will understand that.
DREAMZ: Criticize the president all you want and America for that matter, but when you do it on blind hatred and false beliefs then im sorry its misguided. IMO its lack of understanding about the American government or maybe having to much of a belief in conspiracy, everything isnt a conspiracy.
ECK: I have seen war. Have you? Generally, statements like these come from those who have never witnessed it themself. And it's thoroughly offensive. To say that Fallujah is not a slaughter is naive in the extreme. And as for the battles of WW2, as Marg pointed out, WW2 was a very different war. There's simply no comparison. The invasion of Iraq was/is an illegal war of aggression. What we've done is no different than what Hitler did. I feel sorry for you folks who are too blinde or stubborn to see and acknowledge that. That is exactly what I meant when I said God will never bless or protect a nation that uses such wanton aggression. Woe to us, for our sins will be counted and answered with equal measure.
DREAMZ: Yes I have seen war up close, does it make any difference that we have and other people havent, should the people who havent not be able to express their opinions because they havent seen it. Dissent is American remember. Comparing the cleansing of complete human races to what we are doing in Iraq is just another misguided belief. If thats what you want to believe so be-it, if that were the case we would be tossing every muslim we see in America and abroad into concentration camps, this is a weak line for someone opposed to the war. WWII may be a different period in history but by no means is it different in terms of what we are fighting. If you think Nazi Germany vs current day terrorist threats are that different, Ill give you one difference...We could see Nazi Germany.
ECK: Beheadings.. you should really look into U.S. and Israeli covert operations in Iraq and elsewhere. There you will find the responsible parties for many of these gruesome acts. It's called PSYCHOLOGICAL WARFARE. Something else you may want to consistantly ask first and foremost is.. who stands to gain? Things become much more clear when you approach it from that angle.
DREAMZ: This is typical spin to someone with no answer. Lets pass the ball to someone else and put the blame on them.
ECK:From another post: As far as us Allowing the Iraqis to have an election, I say this: If Allawi actually was in charge we couldn't LET them do anything. He is nothing but a NeoCon puppet.
DREAMZ: You just posted something from a blog with not one credible source in it. It quotes the Palestenian Authority on a remark against Israel, that just reeks credible.
DREAMZ: The fact of the matter is that Allawi really has no choice but to go along with the Americans and no one is saying he isnt a puppet, of course he is. That wont change until the people are allowed to vote for themselves.
Originally posted by Seekerof
Must of hit home pretty hard, huh, Thorfinn?
Since you were unable to read between the lines on my intial quote, perhaps you can read between the lines of the above?
seekerof