It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by Quetzalcoatl14
You know, it i hardly surprising that there is a hatred in the past of the ancient Israelis. You have to remember that, according to the very book from 700 B.C. you mentioned, God ordered the Hebrews to come in to the land of Israel and kill every man, woman, and child of the Caananites. These ancient people you put on a pedestal (and I do not hold modern Jewish people responsible for those actions) are guilty of genocide, pure and simple, no sugar coating. They also conquered a land that was not theirs absent a several thousand year old book legislating their taking of the land.
It is time that Jewish and Christian people look these things in the eye and call it for what it is. I showed my good Jewish friend Jeff the passages in the Bible talking about killing everybody because they were inpure, had the wrong beliefs, and would pollute the race of David. His response, "Sounds just like Hitler."
edit on 26-2-2013 by Quetzalcoatl14 because: I wanted to denote "ancient Israelis," not present. Big difference
Originally posted by Quetzalcoatl14
reply to post by EnochWasRight
With all due respect, did you even read my post. I specifically stated that modern day Jewish people are not responsible for what happened in the Old Testament. Just like, I am not responsible for the European genocide of Native Americans (which was also wrong and cloaked in quasi-religious terms). The Europeans too justified taking the Americas because the "savages" did not have the right beliefs (Christianity) and did not behave the same way. This story is as old as time.
What I am saying is, I can call it like it is with the Americas, Israel, Germany (i am German by the way and detest what happened during WWII), because I am not overly religious and seek truth and justice, even if my own people are in question. Fundamentalist Christians (and Orthodox Jews) have trouble "calling it like it is" with the atrocities in the Old Testament because if they did their "holy book" would be called into question. Admitting that 1) God ordered genocide 2) That it was wrong or mistakes as you say = realizing that the Bible is NOT without error. Unless you believe in a God that condones genocide. In that case, you are no better than Hitler. Hitler believed God was on his side.
What I am saying is, I can call it like it is with the Americas, Israel, Germany (i am German by the way and detest what happened during WWII), because I am not overly religious and seek truth and justice, even if my own people are in question. Fundamentalist Christians (and Orthodox Jews) have trouble "calling it like it is" with the atrocities in the Old Testament because if they did their "holy book" would be called into question. Admitting that 1) God ordered genocide 2) That it was wrong or mistakes as you say = realizing that the Bible is NOT without error. Unless you believe in a God that condones genocide. In that case, you are no better than Hitler. Hitler believed God was on his side.
Originally posted by Quetzalcoatl14
reply to post by EnochWasRight
Okay, well, it seems like we can talk then. So, I was raised a Christian, with the view that both the OT and NT are the unaltered, perfect representation of God's truth. In the example of ancient OT genocide, I do not blame God for this happening.
However, once I began to read the Old Testament, I came to the conclusion that:
1) I believe in God in general
2) I do not believe that the God of justice would order genocide for all men, women, and children.
3) Therefore, these passages represent the ignorance, tribalism, or even racism of this ancient tribe we now call the Hebrew or Israelites.
4) These passages do not represent what God really wanted.
5) Thus, the Bible is not without error and is NOT the perfect representation of God.
This is one example, among several. We have to educate ourselves on everything, and then, using our God-given minds, make judgements. Just like, many people pronounce judgements on Hinduism or atheism. Before you assert that I have no right to judge the Bible or God, or that God "confounds the wise," realize that anybody could make that argument from any other belief system religion, or lack thereof. Such a statement does not answer fundamental questions.edit on 26-2-2013 by Quetzalcoatl14 because: (no reason given)edit on 26-2-2013 by Quetzalcoatl14 because: (no reason given)