It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by The Shrike
Originally posted by Pimander
And you have proven nothing. Therefore I can only conclude that your claim that that abductions are ALL a mental construction is nothing but an assertion and hearsay. Why don't you gather some evidence, as I have, then come back with your proof?
(snip)
You haven't really gathered any evidence, what you have gathered are reports which is another word for hearsay. Besides, I'm not making claims that I have to support. I'm questioning such claims therefore the onus is on the claimant to support such claims with real evidence. And enough scholars have reported that like it was said in "YELLOW SUBMARINE", "It's all in the mind".
Future of UFOlogy?
UFOlogy's future lies in the extent of its ability to evaluate and capitalize upon its past and current achievements; to pose the right questions on pressing issues; and to organize its eternally limited resources logically and efficiently toward arriving at timely, comprehensive answers.The CUFON Interview
Originally posted by Pimander
Originally posted by The Shrike
Originally posted by Pimander
And you have proven nothing. Therefore I can only conclude that your claim that that abductions are ALL a mental construction is nothing but an assertion and hearsay. Why don't you gather some evidence, as I have, then come back with your proof?
(snip)
You haven't really gathered any evidence, what you have gathered are reports which is another word for hearsay. Besides, I'm not making claims that I have to support. I'm questioning such claims therefore the onus is on the claimant to support such claims with real evidence. And enough scholars have reported that like it was said in "YELLOW SUBMARINE", "It's all in the mind".
What the hell are you on about? Witness reports are evidence (though obviously not conclusive on their own).
(snip)
Originally posted by The Shrike
So far, all that exists are reports by people making claims that are not supported by evidence. So, anyone can say anything but acceptance of reports is not the same as supported by evidence. (snip)
It's all in the mind!
Originally posted by Ghost of America
I've recently read Graham Hancock's Supernatural and a lot of that fit with what was/is going on with me. Maybe a surplus of '___'? I do feel now that there is a force out there that we can't begin to imagine. It's trying to say hello...or something.
Originally posted by Pimander
Originally posted by The Shrike
So far, all that exists are reports by people making claims that are not supported by evidence. So, anyone can say anything but acceptance of reports is not the same as supported by evidence. (snip)
It's all in the mind!
Really my thread was about the possibility of the exploitation of a physiological mechanism for abduction type scenarios. I really don't want to go over the ground of evidence of how 'real' it is. If it is physical evidence you want, there isn't a lot as I said in the OP. My point to you is that you claim the double standard of only who you try to debunk has to produce evidence - not you. NOT a scientific approach as it happens. Counter claims also require evidence unless they are to be seen as weak...
All I will say for now is that I don't believe what really happens is how modern abductees generally perceive it. However, it is possible that many of the modern cases are not "all in the mind."
Originally posted by The Shrike
Aliens have never abducted skeptics, only believers. How do "they" know who is a skeptic and who is a believer and why do they choose believers?
Originally posted by The Shrike
I've been dealing with reality for 72 years. Reality humors fantasy but the separation is solid. Of course, I'm talking about alien abductions of which I do not accept a single case as being as real as the sun "rising" every day. I question all claims and, so far, alleged alien abductions are that: alleged.
•An allegation (also called adduction) is a claim of a fact by a party in a pleading, which the party claims to be able to prove. Allegations remain assertions without proof, until they can be proved.
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Allege
Where's the proof? All you can supply is hearsay.edit on 15-1-2011 by The Shrike because: (no reason given)
Originally posted by devildogUSMC
reply to post by getreadyalready
My never knew when it was happening and could wake me up also. I try to move and scream as hard as i can and I can't do it. I have to ride it out never time. How do you get out of it?
Originally posted by The GUT
And back to this subject somewhat: So you don't believe in abductions & such...does that mean you have no belief in a non-human consciousness existing in a dimension normally unseen by 'us' in this one?