It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by maria_stardust
The bottom line, a woman who is raising a child is already carrying the burden of financial responsibility. A man shouldn't be allowed to weasel his way out of supporting a child he sired. Period.
The bottom line is that when men and women split, the child is used to make men pay huge amounts of money that sometimes is never even used to support the child.
In a recent case, a man had donated his sperm while he was married. The couple subsequently divorced. The woman then had a bright idea.. she went to the fertility clinic, got herself pregnant with her ex-husband's sperm, then went after the ex for child support.
When a man fathers a child, whether intentionally or not, a child exists and requires support. If we are pro-choice on the abortion issue, that includes a woman's right to choose NOT to have an abortion and instead to have the child. If she does, then an obligation exists to support the child. To share the burden between the parents is reasonable and fair.
Originally posted by ZeddicusZulZorander
Women have the choices...have the baby or not, but a man has no choice. That is not a fair system. That is a system that punishes men.
Originally posted by maria_stardust
If a person is sexually active, then that person assumes the risk AND the responsibility if a child is conceived.
To share the burden between both parents is reasonable and fair.
Originally posted by IAF101
What if the Man doesn’t want to and the woman goes and has a child any way? He is still forced to pay childcare and he is still forced to support a child that he knew he couldn’t support or for numerous other reasons.
Plus not to mention the emotional trauma of having an illegitimate kid.
9 months of gestation doesn’t entitle you to inflict 18 years of financial and a lifetime of emotional responsibility.
Originally posted by IAF101
Isn’t it more equitable if the Man choice to say, "No I don’t want to have a child with you" is also given as much weightage as the woman’s choice to have a child?
What if the Man doesn’t want to and the woman goes and has a child any way? He is still forced to pay childcare and he is still forced to support a child that he knew he couldn’t support or for numerous other reasons.
Plus not to mention the emotional trauma of having an illegitimate kid.
Just because a person is of a particular sex and has a particular natural ability doesn’t entitle them to throttle others just to satisfy their own wants and desires of womanhood does it?
9 months of gestation doesn’t entitle you to inflict 18 years of financial and a lifetime of emotional responsibility.
Originally posted by riley
Unless he had is sperm stolen he'd be well aware of the potential consequences.
Plus not to mention the emotional trauma of having an illegitimate kid.
Opposed to her doing what she's told and aborting? Great trade off to protect him from trauma.
He can always ask for custody to ensure he's is not taken advantage of.
Originally posted by IAF101
Well it could be considered that because, his sperm would be used without his consent to have a baby
Sure you could argue that abortion is a traumatic experience but 9 months of gestation and birth is equal to if not more of a trauma.
Originally posted by IAF101
Well it could be considered that because, his sperm would be used without his consent to have a baby and over that he would have to pay for it. A double whammy of sorts.
Abortion would only be case if the woman doesnt take contraceptives in the first place and they have ample opportunity to do so before and after. But if the woman were to still choose to ignore this and continue towards pregnancy then an abortion would be unavoidable.
Sure you could argue that abortion is a traumatic experience but 9 months of gestation and birth is equal to if not more of a trauma.
Even if he were to be given custody, it would be an imposition, something that was thrust upon him by a woman wanting to revile in her womanhood.
If the responsibility of raising a child is 50-50 between the parents then so to should be the right of having a child in the first place.
Originally posted by Benevolent Heretic
If he's not willing to support a child, and doesn't want a child and isn't prepared to have and support a child, then he's not prepared or qualified to have responsible sex. A possible outcome of sex is a baby and if someone isn't prepared to handle that, in whatever way is available to them, then they should refrain.
A man has no recourse after the pregnancy occurs. It's not fair, I agree, but there are no claims that it's fair.
Well, I certainly wouldn't use the word throttle. But the man exercises his wants and desires along the line as well.
Then you need to ask yourself if 15 minutes of pleasure is worth it.
If there was a chance she had AIDS, would you be cavalier? No, because your life is on the line. Well, there's a life at stake anytime people have sex. It's just responsible sex.
Originally posted by Benevolent Heretic
What do you mean, used without his consent? Unless he was raped, he consented! He gave it to her! He may have persuaded her to take it, in fact.
That argument is like saying that death of a loved one and birth of a loved one are both traumatic experiences, therefore equal? One is usually desired, and the other is not. There's a HUGE difference.
You talk as if the man is a victim here and it's just not the case. He knows the stakes. He knows the rules. If he plays the game, then he bears the consequences.
Originally posted by riley
I am indeed pro-choice but pro-choice in that it's inside a woman's body and she has the final word.. unless you think men should have the right to force her to undergo an invasive operation against her will?
How dare she have a repoductive organ! I can't believe I am reading this. She cannot help being fertile... motherhood is a fact of life and sex causes pregnancy. If men want to have sex purely for pleasure with no repecussions.. buy a blow up doll.
Fine. I demand that if I ever get pregnant.. the father should carry it 9 months and give birth instead.
Originally posted by IAF101
I was under the impression that sex is mutually agreeable and not one sided and if it were to be one sided then wouldn’t it be considered as rape ?
Essentially when a man has sex with a woman it would mean that the woman was also has sex with the man and they share the responsibility of that intercourse. So you're saying that every time a woman has sex she wants a baby with you ?
If it isnt fair in the first place then what claims of injustice can be made by the woman?
As for the child, the woman has 24 months to abort or at lest 12 months to do so with minimal trauma and by still dithering she would impose a burden on those who dont want it just to satisfy her womanhood.
Being a woman you wouldn’t understand the male perspective of such an issue;
As for a man exercising his wants and desires, how can he?
Originally posted by IAF101
talk of the fact that a woman could take/receive the mans sperm in good faith with an assurance of her taking contraceptive measures against pregnancy and then deceive the man intentionaly to have his baby and sponge on him for her and the childs upkeep.
This has happened and continues to happen.
From what I have head from women they usually fing the 9 month gestation to be similar to a nightmare;
All I am saying is if a man is supposed to bear the responsibilites, which I strongly feel he should, shouldnt he be allowed to have rights as well ?
Originally posted by Benevolent Heretic
And no, I'm not saying a woman always wants a baby.
I don't see a woman claiming injustice (unless you're a woman). You're the one claiming injustice here.
Dude, I think you mean 'weeks' and this isn't about 'satisfying womanhood'.
If your argument is that women lie to get men to do what they want, you should probably think about what men say to get women in bed, too. They're not always truthful, if you know what I mean. But yes, there are deceitful women out there and I hate them.
But if I were a man getting ready to have sex with a woman,............. If I were a man, I would insist on spermacide and a condom or else forget it.
He does have rights. Just not the right to choose abortion. That's the woman's choice. He has the right to discuss it ahead of time,
We have periods most of our lives! Every month! Once a month, I had cramps that laid me out! It's not fair! We have menopause for 10 years, and LET ME TELL YOU! It's unfair! We are weak compared to you! It's unfair!