posted on Jan, 28 2023 @ 06:46 PM
originally posted by: halfoldman
It's known that gender non-conformist kids are more likely to be gay as adults.
Now these kids are being told they must change their bodies (into something resembling the opposite gender).
So, how did we get here?
www.youtube.com...
First, some terminology: From what I've read, it is generally true that if someone is going to be gender-nonconforming as an adult, they usually show
those tendencies as a kid (I.e., before puberty). However, there are multiple different kinds of gender nonconformity. The classic biological male
attracted to biological male is what is usually referred to as "gay". The classic biological female attracted to biological female is what is usually
referred to as "lesbian". These are the classic categories in which the individuals don't feel any particular desire to change the physical nature of
their bodies. Then there are the "trans"individuals whose personalities feel that they have been born into bodies of the wrong gender. Those are the
ones who can end up seeking sex-change surgery and hormone treatment. And then there are the bisexual individuals who feel attracted to either or both
genders but don't necessarily feel any desire to undergo surgery or other treatment. And then there's the catchall term "queer" for people who don't
necessarily have a stable identity of any one particular kind, over time. That's why the the term LGBTQ was invented. All of those gender terms
would refer to gender nonconformity, but only one of them would be considered "gay".
Second, do you personally know of any kid who has been told they "must" change their body? I don't. There are approximately 9,000 gender
reassignment surgeries per year in the US. That's less than one person in more than 37,000. All of the professional medical organizations who deal
with this issue recommend against hormone treatment and gender reassignment surgery until well after puberty. The standard of treatment is that an
individual can get that treatment at age 18 at their own request and at age 16 with parent's permission. One reason for that is that even though some
kids show gender dysphoria before puberty, some of them grow out of it. No doctor wants to permanently alter someone's physical body for this purpose
unless the individual is as close to 100% certain as possible that they want it. For one thing, the doctor would be open to malpractice claims.
We got here because the large majority of traditional societies often brutally repressed non-conforming gender identities with punishments like
stoning to death, burning at the stake, castration, etc. Think about what the word "faggot" means. Naturally that created a massive disincentive for
individuals who were naturally nonconforming to be open and honest about it. Most modern societies are now simply saying it's OK for people to be
honest about their sexuality/gender. The first major systematic scientific study of sexuality in the US was the so-called Kinsey report in 1948. He
reported that about 10% of the men he interviewed were more or less exclusively homosexual. Today, the population of the US who self report as LGBTQ
hovers around 4%. A lot of people think Kinsey's numbers were an overestimate and that there's no particular reason to think that there's a higher
percentage of gender non-conforming people now than there has been historically. It's just OK to admit it now.