a reply to:
worldstarcountry
It has dated a lot, special effects are not as good as todays science fiction but it is still a great show, in some ways the new show did thing a
little better and was more realistic but over all the old show was the better, it's a point that has been argued about.
Like many science fiction franchise both versions have there fan's and there detractors.
But if the new show had been made in the spirit of the original but with all the bell's and whistles of new screen technology it would have actually
be far better than it was.
To make it more realistic they made the new BSG weaker than the old one but it did look better, the same with the Cylon's (though many argue the old
Cylon base stars were far better the new raiders were definitely better but I kind of miss the fact that the old Raiders had three Cylons and could
land disgorging there crew to fight on foot and as to that thank's to CGI the new Cylon Centurions are far better - as well as far more deadly).
Both version had some really cool idea's, some great writing and some brilliant episodes and it just comes down to a matter of taste - and which you
saw first (and if you liked it then).
Space battles are done far better in the new series, the old series did the characters more likable and less gritty and it was not PC or feminist by
todays standards, at least at first, the shortage of pilots as they fled the remains of the colony's led to them training female pilots but before
that in the show the role of colonial viper pilot was a male role, given that they are kind of based on Ancient Greece in some way's as well as Egypt
that is actually perfectly in line with it's story arc.
The Original Starbuck was a likable but not saintly rogue, he had a really good streak that came out and became a hero of the show, the new Starbuck
is not as good a character, not because she is a woman that was never the problem for me but the character depiction is too grim in the new show,
almost every scene someone is hitting the bottle and getting sozzled in there quarters and the show paint's a grim and miserable world, the old series
had a bit of that too but no where near as much and painted a far more optimistic view of there life on board and in the fleet though social
inequality and other issues were covered in the original series very well indeed, some of the best pilot's and characters are black such as Lieutenant
Boomer and Colonel Tigh among other's.
The problem many have with the original series is that it incorporated a lot of ideas from the Mormon church and Glen A Larson was a member of the
Mormon Church etc so he snuck in a lot of his beliefs which though did not ruin the story one bit (not a Mormon myself and you would have to be one
most likely to see and recognize those particular things).
The original Two series ended on a bit of a whimper with the last episode and a the cancelled third series and many find the character Doctor Zee
very off putting but back then as now merchandising was a thing, a huge number of toy sales were spun from the original series but due to the more
adult nature of the new series that was something that was less prevalent if at all.
Sorry I go on a bit too much but what I am saying is many of look at the old show through rose tinted spectacles a bit but it is still a great old
science fiction show, think about the contrast as a little like Picard vs Kirk.