It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
She was the green-eyed 'Afghan Girl' who shot to global fame when a haunting picture of her appeared on the cover of a 1985 issue of National Geographic magazine.
Now a picture of Sharbat Gula is in the news again - but it's a very different image.
A recent picture of Gula, looking less striking, is washing around in a row about corruption in Pakistan.
The haunting image of the then 12-year-old Gula, taken in a refugee camp by photographer Steve McCurry, became the most famous cover image in National Geographic's history.
After a 17-year search, McCurry tracked Gula down to a remote Afghan village in 2002 where she was living married to a baker and the mother of three daughters.
However, she's being investigated because Pakistani officials discovered she was living in the country on fraudulent identity papers.
This week the picture from her computerised national identity card surfaced in national media. It's an ID card that as an Afghan national, she's not allowed to have.
Pakistani officials say that Gula applied for a Pakistani identity card in the northwestern city of Peshawar in April 2014, using the name Sharbat Bibi.
She was one of thousands of Afghan refugees who managed to dodge Pakistan's computerised system and to get an identity card last year.
Faik Ali Chachar, a spokesman for the National Database and Registration Authority (NADRA), told AFP the Federal Investigation Agency was probing Gula's case.
'This is one of the thousands of cases which was detected last year and sent to the FIA. We are waiting for the findings of the inquiry,' Chachar said.
'Our vigilance department detected (the) Sharbat Bibi case in August 2014 and sent it to FIA for further investigation the same month.'
Many Afghan refugees try to get Pakistani ID cards every day using fake documents, Chachar said.
He said all the documents she used to get the card, which only Pakistani citizens are entitled to, were fake and her 'sons' were likely also not related to her.
originally posted by: phinubian
a reply to: Anyafaj
I can remember this issue and I actually still have the copy believe it or not after my grandmother passed I got my hands on my old collection of NAT Geos and I was surprised this one was in the collection, but at any length I saw this recent photo a couple of years ago, thanks for the post!
originally posted by: Anyafaj
originally posted by: phinubian
a reply to: Anyafaj
I can remember this issue and I actually still have the copy believe it or not after my grandmother passed I got my hands on my old collection of NAT Geos and I was surprised this one was in the collection, but at any length I saw this recent photo a couple of years ago, thanks for the post!
Anytime. I saw the article and was interested to see what had happened to her in years. It seems they have not been kind to her.
originally posted by: Edumakated
If that girl didn't live in the world's armpit, she probably could have been groomed to be a super model.
originally posted by: Night Star
originally posted by: Edumakated
If that girl didn't live in the world's armpit, she probably could have been groomed to be a super model.
Not if she married that baker. LOL
I too remember seeing that child's pic when it came out. Beautiful! But yes, we all age, every one of us and we aren't all beauty queens. It's what's on the inside that counts the most anyway.
originally posted by: Rocker2013
originally posted by: Anyafaj
originally posted by: phinubian
a reply to: Anyafaj
I can remember this issue and I actually still have the copy believe it or not after my grandmother passed I got my hands on my old collection of NAT Geos and I was surprised this one was in the collection, but at any length I saw this recent photo a couple of years ago, thanks for the post!
Anytime. I saw the article and was interested to see what had happened to her in years. It seems they have not been kind to her.
I hate to be the one to break this terrible news to you, but we all age.
This is actually natural aging, as opposed to the fakeness we seem to propagate in our societies with people in their 50's trying to foolishly look 20.
It's a stunning mark of our societies when this story seems to be being commented on more because people are SHOCKED and STUNNED that a 12 year old became a woman, than being talked about because of the interesting journey she's had.
I'm sure the photographer must feel quite sick seeing people fixating on how this woman looks compared to how she was as a CHILD.
originally posted by: Edumakated
If that girl didn't live in the world's armpit, she probably could have been groomed to be a super model.
originally posted by: Edumakated
originally posted by: Night Star
originally posted by: Edumakated
If that girl didn't live in the world's armpit, she probably could have been groomed to be a super model.
Not if she married that baker. LOL
I too remember seeing that child's pic when it came out. Beautiful! But yes, we all age, every one of us and we aren't all beauty queens. It's what's on the inside that counts the most anyway.
No doubt. I just think if she grew up in first world country, I'm sure she would have aged differently. I remember seeing that cover as well. It is a shame that next to Mona Lisa, that girl is probably one of the most recognized faces ever but she grew up in a life of squalor.
originally posted by: Night Star
originally posted by: Edumakated
If that girl didn't live in the world's armpit, she probably could have been groomed to be a super model.
Not if she married that baker. LOL
I too remember seeing that child's pic when it came out. Beautiful! But yes, we all age, every one of us and we aren't all beauty queens. It's what's on the inside that counts the most anyway.
originally posted by: aboutface
a reply to: Anyafaj
Who could ever forget that photo? I'm sorry to read about Gula's current problems. A life in a war zone is bad enough, and for some it follows them. I am sending good thoughts and prayers her way.
originally posted by: Tangerine
originally posted by: aboutface
a reply to: Anyafaj
Who could ever forget that photo? I'm sorry to read about Gula's current problems. A life in a war zone is bad enough, and for some it follows them. I am sending good thoughts and prayers her way.
Yeah, that's helped so much to end war and oppression.
originally posted by: Anyafaj
originally posted by: Tangerine
originally posted by: aboutface
a reply to: Anyafaj
Who could ever forget that photo? I'm sorry to read about Gula's current problems. A life in a war zone is bad enough, and for some it follows them. I am sending good thoughts and prayers her way.
Yeah, that's helped so much to end war and oppression.
No need to be sarcastic. If she wishes to send her good thoughts and prayers, what harm can it do? No need to be snippy about it.
No harm. Probably no good, either. It was just that the notion that someone living in a war torn country where prayers and good wishes didn't do crap to prevent war and oppression would benefit from prayers and good wishes struck me as being absurd. I should have realized that the prayers and good thoughts are really intended to make the one "sending" them feel good. That probably does work.