It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
originally posted by: rokkuman
originally posted by: Elton
a reply to: rokkuman
Why wouldn't they?
Because it simply doesn't add up. Its like the Chinese naming their towns "Birmingham" or "London".
Islam was completely irrelevant to American society in the 1800's so why would Americans name places after Islamic names?
(as noun a Mecca) A place which attracts people of a particular group or with a particular interest: Holland is a Mecca for jazz enthusiasts
originally posted by: rokkuman
of course I did my research but the question remains why were Americans in the 1800's naming places "Mecca", "Medina" and "Mahomet"?? It makes no sense to me.
originally posted by: rokkuman
Islam was completely irrelevant to American society in the 1800's so why would Americans name places after Islamic names?
The next significant wave of Muslim immigrants began in the mid-19th century. During the late 19th century until the 1920s, large numbers of Arabs, mostly from Lebanon and Greater Syria, arrived in the United States. Although the majority of these immigrants (almost 90%) were Arab Christians, there were sizable clusters of Muslims, most of whom settled in the Midwest.
originally posted by: rokkuman
originally posted by: Elton
a reply to: xuenchen
Knowledge does not always equal fear.
and fine, Mahomet was named after Mason Lodge.
Medina is common name Spanish used to name lots of things.
IDK about Mecca, probably named after Mecca.
So we can probably all relax now, thread level plaid.
no lets not relax.
"Mahomet" is not mason lodge, its Latin or French for Mohammad. What are you trying to pull here?
And for "Medina", its not Spanish...the place was going to be named "Mecca", proving those who were naming that place wanted it to sound Islamic.
originally posted by: peter vlar
originally posted by: rokkuman
originally posted by: Elton
a reply to: xuenchen
Knowledge does not always equal fear.
and fine, Mahomet was named after Mason Lodge.
Medina is common name Spanish used to name lots of things.
IDK about Mecca, probably named after Mecca.
So we can probably all relax now, thread level plaid.
no lets not relax.
"Mahomet" is not mason lodge, its Latin or French for Mohammad. What are you trying to pull here?
And for "Medina", its not Spanish...the place was going to be named "Mecca", proving those who were naming that place wanted it to sound Islamic.
Yes... Mahomet IS the local Masonic Lodge. Do you have a citation showing showing that Medina was originally going to be called Mecca? This whole thread reeks of illogical and ignorance based fear mongering.
The Illinois town's name derives from the "Mahomet Lodge," the local Masonic Lodge at the time the town was searching for a new name. Its use as the name of the lodge was a manifestation of the Freemasons' liberal use of religious names and stonemason tools and symbols. An alternative theory states that the name Mahomet was arbitrarily assigned when the conflicting names were noted by the US Postal Service.
Although the unusual spelling, which is French for Mohammed, sometimes confuses newcomers, the pronunciation of Mahomet is muh-HOMM-it.
en.wikipedia.org...
Do you have a citation showing showing that Medina was originally going to be called Mecca?
Medina is the county seat of Medina County, Ohio. Founded as the county seat in 1816, the community was originally named Mecca, after the birthplace of the prophet Mohammed.
www.ohiohistorycentral.org...