It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
An effort to require students in Florida public schools to watch a controversial documentary by conservative pundit Dinesh D'Souza gained ground this week with the support of a state House member.
Rep. Neil Combee, a Lakeland Republican, filed a bill seeking to mandate that all eighth- and 11th-grade students view the film America: Imagine the World Without Her. His legislation is identical to a measure filed by Sen. Alan Hays in November.
Hays, a Umatilla Republican, received heavy criticism that he was foisting propaganda on children when he announced his plan. But legislation in just one chamber doesn't go far.
Its appearance in the House could give it wings, although some key lawmakers have suggested the proposal overreaches by being too prescriptive.
"Not to say the Legislature shouldn't create objectives" for schools, Senate Education Committee Chairman John Legg said. "But how to get there and what to teach to get there is not something the Legislature needs to engage in."
Hays made similar arguments last year when attempting to end the state's role in adopting school textbooks. But in this case, he argued, parents would have control by having the ability to opt out of the showing if they're opposed to the film.
When he first began watching the film, Hays said he was flabbergasted: The narrator "was interviewing those who were espousing what I consider anti-American views."
By the time the documentary ended 105 minutes later, he had a completely different thought.
"I looked at my wife and I said, 'Every student in America needs to see this movie.' " Hays praised its message of American exceptionalism.
In Florida, pieces of legislation — no matter how weighty or trivial — have little chance of adoption without a companion in the opposite chamber. So even while critics vilified Hays' bill, they knew it wouldn't stand on its own.
Combee's bill changes that.
www.tampabay.com...
originally posted by: Blackmarketeer
So if Rep. Neil Combee and Sen. Alan Hays have their way, students will be forced - by law - to watch this propaganda? How can you force students to watch a film, by passing a law? That is straight-up Nazism.
Democracy is America is dead.
originally posted by: DAVID64
Government needs to stay out of education. Common Core is bad enough, but straight out propaganda films, by either side, are over the top. I keep a close eye on what my kids are taught and this would have me in the Principals office demanding some explanations. Patriotism is fine. Support the people who make our country great, not the over bearing Big Brother who makes "American" a curse word for the rest of the world.
But in this case, he argued, parents would have control by having the ability to opt out of the showing if they're opposed to the film.
originally posted by: ScientificRailgun
If this does manage to pass congress, expect NObama to be ready with his trusty veto pen. He did say he would not hesitate to veto bad bills.
originally posted by: Spider879
originally posted by: DAVID64
Government needs to stay out of education. Common Core is bad enough, but straight out propaganda films, by either side, are over the top. I keep a close eye on what my kids are taught and this would have me in the Principals office demanding some explanations. Patriotism is fine. Support the people who make our country great, not the over bearing Big Brother who makes "American" a curse word for the rest of the world.
Whatever happened to so-called small government a Rep rallying cry.
originally posted by: IShotMyLastMuse
I watched the documentary a while back, it's bad and boring and i remember hearing more than a few one sided arguments, and i kinda hated the historical reenactments, but i always hate those.
To make it mandatory viewing? well unless you counter it with for example the movies you pointed out, then yes, it is brainwashing, it is propaganda. If you make ANY viewpoint mandatory, then you have to make the opposite viewpoint mandatory as well so children are aware of a spectrum of ideas.
On a personal note, i admit to have always made fun of people that decide to home school.
Now, i am starting to think they have just been ahead of the curve.