posted on Dec, 11 2013 @ 09:12 AM
Before start arguing about shariah, the implementations etc, people should better what shariah is.
Some clue from me. There will never be one syariah among muslim. It will always be many kind of shariah, depends on understanding, imams, teacher,
mazhab, sektarian, even culture surrounding it.
No need to say forcing shariah to non muslim, saying there will be a shariah is already stated that one group of muslim will eradicate the rest of
muslim believe, to interpret and doing their believe.
Another clue. Quran, like other holly book, is not a set of law written like a law that we know in most country. It is a set of understanding of norm
in life, using literature that need to be interpret. It is like reading a story with poem style, read it first until finish, try to understand the
whole story and what value in it, rather cut it into pieces and present it like a lawyer in a court.
Another sample is when people believe that a resource is valid because it is shahih hadith. Hadith that classified as shahih doesnt meant it is
authentic or can be put in every context. It was come from some group that believe it is original. So it is still possible that it is not. Even if it
is, still we have to put it in the right context, along with other hadiths before and after that come in the same situation.
Last thing, religion mostly is about spiritual, and the same with islam. It is the people who want to explain everything according to logic, logic as
a limitation of the way we think. That is why the meaning become more and more far from it should. Plus generalization will make people hate each
other, thinking how bad they are without thinking how bad ourself.
We should start thinking like, if it is like this, why it has not become like that. If we willing to understand ourself and each other.