It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
windword
reply to post by WarminIndy
Genocide isn't a crime in the eyes of the Biblical God.
Haven't the untouchables been told this for thousands of years? Don't they come back again and again to be untouchables because their caste had determined that they were not allowed compassion?
Do you have a choice regarding your reincarnation? Did you have the choice to come to this world born to the parents you chose before you came? Did you chose your parents?
And if you reincarnated, are you paying for your previous crimes now? Are you giving accountability now for your previous lives? And were you giving accountability before or after you believed in reincarnation?
Did reincarnation give you the escape from your parents? And if you were sent to this life to pay for your previous crimes, then why did you say your parents were cruel to you....
if in fact, you were sent to take accountability? And if you didn't choose your parents, then karma chose for you? And if karma chose for you to be sent back to be held accountable, then why did you say it was wrong for your parents to treat you like they did, if it was predetermined by fate and karma to teach you a lesson?
You parents could not have been wrong in any way if karma and fate dictated that you were to be born to them. So why do you say they were wrong? Karma chose them for you, that's Kismet.
You learned about reincarnation that you get to try over and over and over until you get it right, but karma has a funny sense of humor, to put you with your parents. Tell me, have you made accountability yet, or did you run away from the accountability?
windword
reply to post by WarminIndy
I don't believe in your God.
However, your God presented himself as a sovereign lord over the Hebrew people and dictated laws to them. Then he proceeded to order those same people to break some of those laws. You God is a "do as I say, not as I do" sort of fellow.
I don't condemn the spider for killing the fly. Heck, I don't even condemn my cats for killing birds and mice, while their bowl is full. An asteroid, an earth quake and a tornado are not evil or sinful, they just are.
This life is a temporary existence. Our bodies are just temporary vehicles. We knew that before we came in.
arpgme
Compassion IS natural order.
Evolution made compassiom to help the species to survive.
Survival of the fittest is true, look how humanity overcomes disease and bacteria with medicine...
So God presenting Himself at least means He is real?
You just don't agree with how He presented Himself? What would make Him more palatable for you?
How big is the spider? Tarantula sized or small? Would you allow the Black Widow to hide inside your shoes, and would you bless the Black Widow if it bites your toe?
And that's what I said, they are genocidal and kill indiscriminately. Nature makes no distinction. But you still can't charge God for a crime from the natural universe. If you say asteroids are is what it is, then by that principle, applied to God, then He is what He is, no matter the presentation. And if you are disapproving of His actions, then you still are applying a non-natural moralistic principle.
Show me from natural law, where it is a crime.
Perhaps He's karma as an instrument of torture against those who were reincarnated to receive punishment for previous crimes? But since the natural law is survival of the fittest, then karma is in opposition to the natural law.
If you are sent back to this life because you were cruel in a former life, and you are sent to receive punishment, who is the punisher?
Can you explain to us who is the justice giver and who is the punisher in karma?
Did you remember this event prior to you discovering reincarnation and reading about it? Or did you always know you were reincarnated?
I don't know, why did God put me in an abusive home?
I would never have chosen my parents.
So you can see how people fall so easily for things without investigation. I am skeptical of reincarnation the same as you are skeptical about God.
adjensen
I don't know, Christianity started with 12 guys, has outlasted every known political entity, has outlived everyone who ever tried to control or curtail it and currently claims 2.1 billion followers.
Sounds like it worked out fine.
You ever come up with that kind of success, let us know, m-kay?
You've offered a philosophy that is self-controlled, there are many people who would attach themselves to that.
Yes, we are all born in sin, because we are humans that suffer humanity. It's not that as a baby you did anything wrong, but as the child of humanity, you came into this world with the problem of humanity already in you. In this life you have never escaped the humanity of who you are.
AfterInfinity
reply to post by WarminIndy
Yes, we are all born in sin, because we are humans that suffer humanity. It's not that as a baby you did anything wrong, but as the child of humanity, you came into this world with the problem of humanity already in you. In this life you have never escaped the humanity of who you are.
What exactly is your problem with humanity? Seems like the real problems happen when we lose touch with humanity.edit on 26-10-2013 by AfterInfinity because: (no reason given)