Help ATS with a contribution via PayPal:
learn more

Martyn Stubbs and David Sereda?

page: 1
5

log in

join

posted on May, 16 2013 @ 05:39 PM
link   
Anyone have any information on these two?

I'll start with Stubbs. I've watched his 1 1/2 hour interview a few times now (which I'll put up at the end of this thread if you haven't seen it) and he always comes off as completely genuine. What I mean is I believe none of his footage was doctored and that he genuinely believes he's onto something, it's just a question as to what that something is/was, and he seems interested in nothing but the science of it. The fact I can barely find anything on the web about him is another good sign to me because as we've seen with all the other hoaxers/money hungry people out there, no matter how many times you're debunked or proven to be a hoaxer, there will always be people out there who will believe you and throw their money at you.

The only thing I've heard as explanations for his footage was ice crystals, and UFO Hunters showing how his most famous video with the tether could have been ice crystals. I felt they made a very compelling argument in that regard, but I would need to study it more to see if anything changes directions or makes movements not akin to floating crystals in space.

The reason I brought up Sereda is in the interview he said that Sereda was his partner of sorts in terms of researching this with him, but I know next to nothing about him. A quick Google search came up with nothing in terms of him being untrustworthy. About the only thing I remember him from was the Aykroyd interview.

Before anyone gets started, I did search but the topic(s) I found had nothing to do with these specific questions of mine and I didn't want them to get lost in all the speculation of the other thread(s). Here's the interview.






posted on May, 16 2013 @ 05:45 PM
link   
You might want to get a raincoat and rubber boots for the crap O'berg will be flinging any time now...



posted on May, 16 2013 @ 05:52 PM
link   
reply to post by Toxicsurf
 

Lol, you are right the "excuses and cover-up crew" will be here shortly.

I am guessing one of the following.

1. A weather balloon
2. Swamp gas
3. Temperature inversion
4. Lens flare



posted on May, 16 2013 @ 05:52 PM
link   
reply to post by MadhatterTheGreat
 





Anyone have any information on these two?


Don't know about David Sereda but I do know that the most knowledgeable member on Martyn Stubbs here is buzzEmiller ( Martyn Stubbs)
Maybe he'll stop by .

And yes I believe he has honest intentions too


edit on 16-5-2013 by gortex because: Edit to add



posted on May, 16 2013 @ 07:04 PM
link   
OP, if there's one thing I've learned from spending hundreds of hours now on UFO research and 10s of hundreds on 9-11, is that you're going to have to listen to everybody but make up your own mind. There's always plenty of knee-jerk debunkers with easy answers or ad-hominem complaints ready to diss the messenger without ever having any real evidence to show you for their opinion, and the truth is, very, very few people on this planet right now know what the truth is, and they're not talking. Your guess and opinion is as good as anyone's, in other words.

I also find Stubbs truthful and he certainly had an enviable situation, able to tape all the missions and then review them at his leisure. Sereda is a bit more dicey in my opinion; he's obviously brilliant but I also get a smell of 'huckster' about him. Trouble is, that shouldn't automatically negate the information. In the end, his IQ outflanks my own and so I'm not able to have a valid opinion about him.

In any event, the rabbit hole is fun but it can take you places you may rather not go. I've had to come to terms with some stuff I'm not at all comfortable with and there's no going back after you open Pandora's box. One thing I do know for sure; science and civilization could advance a lot farther if we didn't have to deal with the debunkers all the time and instead could have an honest discussion about the evidence.



posted on May, 16 2013 @ 08:14 PM
link   
reply to post by MadhatterTheGreat
 


Watched the interview a year or so ago and found it very enjoyable.

I also got on a David Sereda Kick about a year ago and watched a few of his interviews. He is, needless to say, very intelligent. He had a theory on FTL travel that had to do with the way we look at wavelengths and gravity or something of the such. Granted, I am no physicist but the interview was very interesting. Also, I found the Dan Akroyd interview pretty enjoyable as well.



posted on May, 27 2013 @ 10:43 AM
link   
reply to post by gortex
 
I have been blind not to have seen this! Sorry...my bad...I had been posting on the thread - "the abundance of NASA Mission footage is the most compelling evidence UFOs exist"...

I am a bit down reading posts & seeing the way ATS members back off when I have a go with Jim Oberg. I hate his ATS stalking of me, fellow ATS members & any thread re: my NASA video discoveries...please don't leave me alone with him!!!!

David & I have been debating him forever (it seems!) & the smoking gun is still smoking!

I am ready to post more NASA video on my you tube channel (user Martyn Stubbs) & I have been going through various mission masters.

David is a great person & as the next few days goes on, I will post on this thread, some David Sereda info on Space phen.#2..the super fastwalkers that I got, capturing single frames & single scans (1/60th of a second)

I have all the info on the CCDs & Oberg & co. have only cosmic rays as an excuse & that is debunked..(I have that evidence in writing)

I am also reviewing all the ATS threads I can handle (!) on the shuttle videos to see how this topic (NASA UFOs)
evolved...(has deteriorated) to a point that Oberg actually implies the videos are faked! AMAZING!

That's the kind of quick-sand time wasting that I have to put up with from this UFO denier. Still I love the ATS members posts..they are better posts each time...& they have all significantly contributed to the growing debate on these videos. Then Oberg goes gutter & the topic dies...strange people these skeptics. Like flies you have to continually swat away!

Watch them jump all over what I just said !



posted on May, 27 2013 @ 10:44 PM
link   
What I am hearing in this thread..is...you don't want facts interfering with your delusions.

No Jim, No Phage or anyone else that cans shut down your BS with facts.

The Nasa videos are a bunch of crap..I saw them and at first believed...but when you actually look into them..and do some research...you realize..debris, ice particles and camera artifacts/ blur/ distortion are the reasons.

But you don't wanna hear that..you would rather believe nonsense rather truth.



posted on May, 27 2013 @ 11:35 PM
link   
David Sereda is obviously okay with presenting Billy Meiers material as genuine which is apparent in his combined effort with Dan Akroyd in Unplugged on UFO's.

Which is laughable & says quite a bit about his position on the topic.



posted on May, 28 2013 @ 07:45 AM
link   
Some email exchanges I had with Mr. Sereda, and with Dr. Nuth -- whom Sereda quotes as supporting his theories -- are on my home page:


04/2000 - David Sereda calls all astronauts liars
www.jamesoberg.com...

02/2000 - David Sereda calls astronaut Franklin Chang a liar
www.jamesoberg.com...


www.jamesoberg.com...
03/2000 - Dr. Joe Nuth Rebuts David Sereda space UFO misinterpretations



posted on May, 28 2013 @ 12:40 PM
link   

Originally posted by MadhatterTheGreat

The reason I brought up Sereda is in the interview he said that Sereda was his partner of sorts in terms of researching this with him, but I know next to nothing about him. A quick Google search came up with nothing in terms of him being untrustworthy. About the only thing I remember him from was the Aykroyd interview.


I wouldn't waste too much time on Sereda. He's on the same level as Steven Greer - in this game for the money.

He sells galactic pendants for several hundred dollars and claims they make you telepathic (Greer sells flights in invisible flying saucers).

He wants to build a flying saucer (Greer wants to build free energy machines).

He claims to have met Jesus (Greer claims to have met ETs)

He also want to go into space to study flying saucers (most people want Sereda and Greer ejected into outer space)


I, David Sereda, would like to apply to become an astronaut for special reasons. I saw a UFO in Berkeley, CA in 1968 when I was 7 years old. It was saucer shaped, metalic and hovered silently not far from the Berkeley National Lab for over 20 minutes. There were fifty or so witnesses with me. After 20 minutes, the flying saucer went invisible: invisible to the naked eye that is.

Hello, My name is David Sereda. I am a well-known Space Science Researcher and UFOlogist. This year I will have spoken to over 100 million people through radio and TV appearances. Because of cetain research I have done into NASA Space Shuttle UFO phenomena, millions of Americans believe NASA is hiding evidence of UFOs appearing on such missions. There is now testimony that NASA has been retouching photographs with UFO in them (deleting UFOs). Gary McKinnon, the British Computer Hacker, testifies to this also.

NASA anticipated contact with Extraterestrials when it first set out to journey into space (See the Space Act and the Brooking study 1958). If contact has been made, and the American public has been deceived, NASA may have made the greatest mistake ever for a public agency.

I would like to go on the space shuttle and the ISS to conduct studies of UFO phenomenon using special cameras sensitive to visible, infrared and UV to search for UFO activity. I would like to report my findings to the American people.

I am now collecting a petition of signatures of citizens who want me to fly on the NASA space shuttle in space to search for ET craft.



posted on May, 28 2013 @ 01:02 PM
link   
reply to post by torsion
 


If your job was being a UFO hunter, would you need money to continue?

Would you want paid for actually working? Or are you that great person who is pro bono in everything you do?

To say someone is not any better than the next because of getting paid to actually do work is a joke.....IMO that is

OP, I started this thread a while back about a video from Sereda I found pretty cool..

www.abovetopsecret.com...
edit on 5/28/2013 by Chrisfishenstein because: (no reason given)



posted on May, 28 2013 @ 08:24 PM
link   

Originally posted by torsion

Originally posted by MadhatterTheGreat

The reason I brought up Sereda is in the interview he said that Sereda was his partner of sorts in terms of researching this with him, but I know next to nothing about him. A quick Google search came up with nothing in terms of him being untrustworthy. About the only thing I remember him from was the Aykroyd interview.


I wouldn't waste too much time on Sereda. He's on the same level as Steven Greer - in this game for the money.

He sells galactic pendants for several hundred dollars and claims they make you telepathic (Greer sells flights in invisible flying saucers).

He wants to build a flying saucer (Greer wants to build free energy machines).

He claims to have met Jesus (Greer claims to have met ETs)

He also want to go into space to study flying saucers (most people want Sereda and Greer ejected into outer space)


I, David Sereda, would like to apply to become an astronaut for special reasons. I saw a UFO in Berkeley, CA in 1968 when I was 7 years old. It was saucer shaped, metalic and hovered silently not far from the Berkeley National Lab for over 20 minutes. There were fifty or so witnesses with me. After 20 minutes, the flying saucer went invisible: invisible to the naked eye that is.

Hello, My name is David Sereda. I am a well-known Space Science Researcher and UFOlogist. This year I will have spoken to over 100 million people through radio and TV appearances. Because of cetain research I have done into NASA Space Shuttle UFO phenomena, millions of Americans believe NASA is hiding evidence of UFOs appearing on such missions. There is now testimony that NASA has been retouching photographs with UFO in them (deleting UFOs). Gary McKinnon, the British Computer Hacker, testifies to this also.

NASA anticipated contact with Extraterestrials when it first set out to journey into space (See the Space Act and the Brooking study 1958). If contact has been made, and the American public has been deceived, NASA may have made the greatest mistake ever for a public agency.

I would like to go on the space shuttle and the ISS to conduct studies of UFO phenomenon using special cameras sensitive to visible, infrared and UV to search for UFO activity. I would like to report my findings to the American people.

I am now collecting a petition of signatures of citizens who want me to fly on the NASA space shuttle in space to search for ET craft.


You bring up some valid points about the similarities of Greer & sereda.

The one issue I have is that he is obviously completely set on UFO'S not only being identified but belonging to ET'S specifically. This I have problems with, we don't know for sure the nature of this phenomenon, though many claim to know absolutely.



posted on May, 28 2013 @ 10:41 PM
link   
Ohhh. David Sereda. Yeah, I think the guy is totally BS.

Here he explains interdimensional UFOs
www.abovetopsecret.com...



posted on May, 28 2013 @ 11:03 PM
link   
reply to post by JimOberg
 



02/2000 - David Sereda calls astronaut Franklin Chang a liar
www.jamesoberg.com...


David Sereda said...

I can mathematically prove Gravity beyond light speed using a new theory in physics I have developed quite recently. I will present the theory soon.


Does he really believe what he is saying?





new topics

top topics



 
5

log in

join