It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by esteay812
reply to post by mikefortson
I imagine it would be quite a task for a recreation to be made by the private sector. The government should be able to reproduce the results, if they are responsible.
If nothing else, we should see many different videos of excess flares being deployed by military aircraft in exercise over heavily populated cities. Surely this wouldn't be the only time they were required to deploy their remaining load before completing the exercise.
I believe there are videos of flares being deployed, but firing them over a large, heavily populated area, doesn't seem like something that would be within the confines of public safety protocols. This makes me even more suspicious that the flares were intentionally dropped over Phoenix, a few hours after initial reports, to form the foundation of their official cover story.
Even if they can recreate the flare drop, it still doesn't explain why they were dropped so close to a large city or what was being seen a few hours earlier.
It seems, if everything were to be explained as flares, there would be records of several other flare drops, in several other locations, preceding the flares captured in the video - and there would probably be video of those flare drops too...
Originally posted by esteay812
reply to post by mikefortson
I don't mean to seem as if I am disputing the flare video at all, I am just suspicious of why the flares were dropped at that time. I mentioned the idea that the flares were deployed after sighting reports began a few hours prior. I tend to think those flares were dropped as a diversion and foundation for the 'Official Story'
Then again, I am no expert and have only learned most of the details from talking to you guys here. It just seems to make the most sense to me, given what I have learned so far.
Originally posted by ItDepends
Originally posted by esteay812
reply to post by mikefortson
I don't mean to seem as if I am disputing the flare video at all, I am just suspicious of why the flares were dropped at that time. I mentioned the idea that the flares were deployed after sighting reports began a few hours prior. I tend to think those flares were dropped as a diversion and foundation for the 'Official Story'
Then again, I am no expert and have only learned most of the details from talking to you guys here. It just seems to make the most sense to me, given what I have learned so far.
reply to post by mikefortson
Originally posted by charlyv
Does anyone know if the photo on the right is an actual photograph, or an artistic conception of the real object that was observed that night in Phoenix ?
According to most of the documentation on the incident, a picture of the actual huge , triangular object was never taken, however this picture shows up in many sites that describe the incident, and also in the research that Dr Lynne Kitel did, along with her book on the subject.
The image on the left is really the flares picture , taken later that night and is not the display that most people that witnessed the event saw.earlier in the evening, after dusk. That picture shows up in every site that discusses Phoenix, and is really not the subject of interest.
The image on the right, clearly shows an angled object, and illustrates more of what people saw and reported. I wonder if it is a real picture. Does anyone have more info here? Thanks
Originally posted by sbjazzman
Originally posted by charlyv
Does anyone know if the photo on the right is an actual photograph, or an artistic conception of the real object that was observed that night in Phoenix ?
According to most of the documentation on the incident, a picture of the actual huge , triangular object was never taken, however this picture shows up in many sites that describe the incident, and also in the research that Dr Lynne Kitel did, along with her book on the subject.
The image on the left is really the flares picture , taken later that night and is not the display that most people that witnessed the event saw.earlier in the evening, after dusk. That picture shows up in every site that discusses Phoenix, and is really not the subject of interest.
The image on the right, clearly shows an angled object, and illustrates more of what people saw and reported. I wonder if it is a real picture. Does anyone have more info here? Thanks
I'm Steve Blonder who Mike has referred to as the closest witness on March 13, 1997. I'd been witnessing the lights since March 10th and has MUFON at my home to record the event on film that evening. I also say earlier lights that were chased by helicopters as the new witness attests to. I have film of that as well. The photos referred to only reflect the Mike Kryzston sighting (the left one). The right one seems to be some kind of composite since Lynne Kitei only was able to capture 3 lights that evening. You can view my rebuttal to the flare theory, my witness account and the video we captured at www.oracleofthephoenix.com... there are files that can be downloaded that contain all the video sighting coordinates as well as composite day/night imaging that researchers can explore in detail.
Originally posted by OperaPhantom
I have reason to believe the Phoenix lights are a military event. Let me explain. 6 months before the Phoenix lights event, I stumbled upon a chat room at www.cyberzine.com. This sight had numerous, easy to use chat rooms for those on the net. Being new, I frequented several of these chat rooms. After several months of chatting and becoming a "regular"I got to know a gentleman that used the name Longhorn to chat. He said he flew some sort of aircraft or planes for a branch of the military. I thought he was bragging, like most on the Internet do so I paid almost no attention to what he actually said he flew. I want to say he said he was from Maryland or Virginia but again it has been years so I can not be sure. The night before the Phoenix lights is something I remember very clearly. We were talking and he said "oh that's right your in Arizona, I will be over by you tomorrow night." Assuming he was talking bull I said "oh yeah and how will I really know its you". All he said was "well I can't talk about it but you will know I was there trust me"
I had strange work hours so I did not see this on the news until maybe two nights later. And after I saw it I did not know what to do. Was this military? Who do I tell. Can I get in trouble. Can he get in trouble for having told me. Would someone come after me for telling?
I never saw him in the chat room again. I often wonder if someone found out he was telling people.
Maybe one of ours, flying one of theirs?
Originally posted by sbjazzman