It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Source: www.olympic.org...
Nothing in these Regulations is intended to make any determination of sex. Instead, these Regulations are designed to identify circumstances in which a particular athlete will not be eligible (by reason of hormonal characteristics) to participate
Source: www.olympic.org...
Androgenic hormones have performance enhancing
effects, particularly on strength, power and speed, which may provide a
competitive advantage in sports.
Where do intersexed people belong in sports? I struggle to accept that being an exceptional intersex athlete means no respect at all, or that being a woman with unique hormones instantly means you cannot compete. Can you suggest something that isn't a special seperate event?
What would your advice be to an intersexed athlete or person when faced with the male/female check box on a form?
Is a person being intersexed something to discuss in public? Or is it private business? Is it something to be embarrassed about?
I know there will be some ATS'rs that think that intersexed people don't exist/are modern creatures caused by pollution, are inventions by radical left wing people to destroy the family unit etc ... By all means have an opinion in that area, but I probably won't be addressing that side of it too muchly if I can avoid it. Feel free to respond via U2U as well I guess if you feel you have an interesting response or question I've not thought about but don't want to do the whole public post thingo.
galadofwarthethird
reply to post by Pinke
A far out thread, but I think your not going to get many fans or people who will support intersex athletes
I see were it can give you an advantage at the least if you had high testosterone and were competing in a women field. It could be in effect tantamount to using steroids as that is what the majority of steroids do anyways.
Lets just say in sports and everywhere I do not think it is an issue that is going to be touched much less solved anything soon
ultimately I think all sports should be about, competition regardless, and not all this other meaningless junk.
curiosity has got me by the tail and probably whoever else read your thread. I mean your going on about this thing.
But whats with the pinki/pinke thing?
How is it that you relate to this sort of thing? I mean no offense, and believe you me I sometimes have a hard time figuring out what insults people. But what gives? Is this whole thing a personal topic/interest?
Don't disagree that gender changes sports performance, but I like to think some of the behaviour you talk about isn't completely due to nature and conditioning. It's probably more than am comfortable with either way, but I think at least some of it comes from a couple of thousand years of believing in a perfect creator and blaming abnormalities on witches and demons.
I'm not sure who watches beauty shows either, but I do notice that people who barely pay attention to them suddenly develop opinions when a #gender person is involved. Same thing happens whenever Oprah or someone discusses it. Instead of looking at it as a learning experience everyday people call it attention grabbing even when the next guest is coming on with a book and a speaking tour to sell!
This is true, but some intersex conditions confer no useful benefit and aren't even detectable without testing. The outcome is often the same though.
I found your comment about butch lesbians funny ... Women say crass things a lot, but being a lesbian lowers the chance for misunderstandings so it comes much more freely. I think sometimes there is this misconception that only lesbian women make crass jokes haha
I thInk the reverse is my question. Why doesn't it bother other people? Why is it even relevant to the discussion why I talk about it? Very few people ask me about my interests in politics, UFOs, Roman history, forensics, security, or religion ... yet this is a question that needs asking?
Steroid cheats and people caught with contraband get more rope than an intersex person. That injustice enough I suppose makes it seem like a relevant topic no? Just my feeling.
Tusks
Should be DNA testing if any questions. Presence of a Y-chromosome would exclude any individual from participating in contests intended for females only. They're intentionally clouding an issue that should be straight forward.
defuntion
reply to post by Pinke
Despite what people have removed or added.
Despite what hormones people have injected.
The reason why you don't hear about intersexed persons competing in men's events is because no one cares to check. There is no limit on men's achievements as a gender, so no one generally cares if an intersex person identifies as male and wins an event.
galadofwarthethird
reply to post by Pinke
In which case I personally dont even see why they would have a gender split in such a sport. I think both male and females could cross train and compete with each other if anyone was so inclined to do so in that and many sports.
But anyways there. Your another one who does not seem to want to answer questions, or at least certain questions.
Which is cool, but if you dont want to answer the gender question.
Ok! How about the whole pinki thing? I mean you said its a and I quote "Pinke is an unrelated German word"
I could probably find out what it all means
ketsuko
Maybe we need to discover what normal hormonal parameters are for male and female (because it's the hormones that make the physical differences) and test the intersexed for those levels to determine where they should be competing? But even then, you would likely have to establish a record of testing those levels.
galadofwarthethird
reply to post by Pinke
OK I clicked your link and the majority of sites that came up were that Pinke means Pink, or sometimes Red or Red wine, or pink rose, and a bunch of such things. And also on some of those links there are a bunch of homosexual references attached to it in the German language. I take it that is what you meant.
crankyoldman
I have an answer to this no one is going to like. Sometimes there is just no answer. There is no law, no right, no divine providence that says people must be able to run, swim or ski in the Olympics if the want to.
galadofwarthethird
reply to post by Pinke
I just assumed you were some wierdo dude who had some interest in this issue, possibly even one of these intersexed people.
But hey all of that and this misunderstanding or whatever it is you trying to get at, could have been solved in about a minute if you would have just answered a simple question instead of trying to be a smart ass about it.
There hasn't been any particular misunderstanding, I got what you were driving at straight away! The above quote just confirms it. One isn't weird for taking stock of injustice.