Company researching turning air into fuel..., page


Pages:
ATS Members have flagged this thread 2 times


reply posted on 11-12-2012 @ 01:54 PM by SirMike
reply to post by cookiemonster32



Two thoughts .. TANSTAAFL and the First law of thermodynamics is more than a suggestion. Whatever "fuel" produced by this process will contain less energy than what it took to transform the CO2 and Hydrogen into that fuel.


reply posted on 11-12-2012 @ 02:05 PM by cookiemonster32
reply to post by SirMike



I have no idea how the process works but they did want to use renewable energy to convert the co2 and hydrogen so they are not burning fossil fuels to create this which is good.



reply posted on 11-12-2012 @ 02:11 PM by Arbitrageur
Cookiemonster,

Did you forget to post a link for your quote?

Originally posted by SirMike
reply to
post by cookiemonster32



Two thoughts .. TANSTAAFL and the First law of thermodynamics is more than a suggestion. Whatever "fuel" produced by this process will contain less energy than what it took to transform the CO2 and Hydrogen into that fuel.
I don't see any suggestion otherwise. The quote refers to using wind, tidal or solar power to process the fuel.

This could still be useful even if the efficiency is low, because if solar power during the day can be turned into fuel, you can put the fuel in your car and drive at night from that solar energy...which is nice. You can sort of do that now with hydrogen, except that is pretty inefficient, so it will be interesting to see how efficient they can make this technology.


reply posted on 11-12-2012 @ 03:14 PM by SirMike
reply to post by Arbitrageur



The economics of this process just wont work.

The Rosco Wind Complex in Texas, is the world’s largest at 781 MW. At a 25%capacity factor, it will generate about 1.7 billion KWH’s in a year. If a gallon of gasoline has 125,000 BTU’s and this process is 40% efficient (on the very high side for an estimate), the entire output of the world’s largest wind farm will produce 19 million gallons of gasoline per year. To put this in comparison, the US consumes on average 367 million gallons per day so the entire yearly output of this process when powered by the world’s largest wind farm produces just 5% of our daily gasoline consumption.

The math (and by extension the economics) just don’t cut it.


reply posted on 11-12-2012 @ 03:21 PM by asciikewl
reply to post by SirMike


]

On the other hand, plants do this all the time with a bit of sunlight and water.

Maybe they found some breakthrough catalyst you can lower the energy barrier for swapping the oxygen for hydrogen and then separate and burn the oxygen again (you'd need something to oxidize though) to get a lot of your energy back?


reply posted on 11-12-2012 @ 03:26 PM by SirMike
reply to post by asciikewl



Catalysts dont reduce the amount of energy a reaction takes, it just speeds up the rate at which it occurs.


reply posted on 11-12-2012 @ 07:25 PM by snapperski
Here the story and link the OP left out.

British company claims biggest engine advance since the jet


The heat exchanger technology could also be incorporated into a new jet engine design that could cut 5 to 10 percent - or $10 (6.25 pounds)-20 billion - off airline fuel bills.

That would be significant in an industry where incremental efficiency gains of one percent or so, from improvements in wing design for instance, are big news.


This technology is still a few years from production.


reply posted on 11-12-2012 @ 11:35 PM by cookiemonster32
Hi sorry sorry my bad I made this thread and then went to bed forgot to post the link
www.airfuelsynthesis.com...
And to the people that are posting that its not profitable and that it won't work because of the first law of thermodynamics...I don't care that its not profitable it's only going to hurt the oil barons in their pocket excuse me while I shed a tear and as far as I am concerned rules and laws were made to be broken and they were written by hide bound fossilized scientists 100 yrs ago things have changed since then... My post concerns the fact that they have created fuel out of thin air which is magic as far as I am concerned.


reply posted on 12-12-2012 @ 05:39 AM by boncho
Originally posted by SirMike
reply to
post by asciikewl



Catalysts dont reduce the amount of energy a reaction takes, it just speeds up the rate at which it occurs.


Catalysts can increase overall yield leading to more energy or less wasted energy in a reaction. Although there is energy used/expended from the catalysts in most cases. However, I don't think this really matters in this scenario.

Just pointing out silly semantics.



reply posted on 12-12-2012 @ 05:42 AM by boncho
Originally posted by cookiemonster32
Hi sorry sorry my bad I made this thread and then went to bed forgot to post the link
www.airfuelsynthesis.com...
And to the people that are posting that its not profitable and that it won't work because of the first law of thermodynamics...I don't care that its not profitable it's only going to hurt the oil barons in their pocket excuse me while I shed a tear and as far as I am concerned rules and laws were made to be broken and they were written by hide bound fossilized scientists 100 yrs ago things have changed since then... My post concerns the fact that they have created fuel out of thin air which is magic as far as I am concerned.


It's only magic if you don't understand the process. And if it's not economically viable than it's not only pointless, but will fail at "hurting the oil barons".

When it does become economically viable, we have far more to worry about than "the barons" as it is a clear indicator our lust for energy is hitting or encroaching on a very thick brick wall. To note, when oil becomes scarce, not just energy is need for worry, but all the plastics and chemicals also produced from the oil industry.

The day people are praising to come, may be bittersweet indeed.


reply posted on 12-12-2012 @ 05:49 AM by boncho
Originally posted by MrDarkPhoenix
sounds to me it just another method of creating hho gas ? kinda like how people make hydrogen generators i think correct me if im wrong, but i dont see the point of mixing pure hydrogen with carbon ?? hydrogen alone could be used as a fuel ?


"HHO Gas" is just an ignorant take on hydrolysis, which has been around for over a century. The idea of this has multiple benefits. 1 being that solar energy collection is sometimes much more efficient in places that are not accessible or scarcely populated. If there is a solar array in the desert, the transportation of electrical load over long distances makes it nearly infeasible. Although, there are operations in the emirates that are using HVDC to get around this, typical AC infrastructure cannot handle load transfer over long distance without losing a major amount of energy in the form of heat. The normal grid will see a 4-12% loss getting to consumers homes. (Based off recollection) So by being able to store it in a easily handled form of fuel, such as this, it has many benefits. Especially if the energy loss in hydrolysis and the subsequent reaction, is made up by the added energy collection of a solar array in places normally considered unfeasible (due to load transfer).

2, would be that hydrogen is horrible to store, transfer, and in most cases use. Although, 2 is kind of eliminated by the simple fact that hydrogen has no economically sustainable method of synthesis right now. It's simply used in pet projects by people who think it somehow is going to usher in a 'green' economy, while making little practical sense.
Pages:     ^^TOP^^



Pokemon discovered in Venezuela
  Posted 14 days ago with 47 member flags
89-Year-Old Man Develops Bladeless Bird-Friendly Wind Turbine
  Posted 11 days ago with 45 member flags
Amazing snowflake images that you have never seen before.
  Posted 14 days ago with 44 member flags
Energy Solutions THEY don\'t want you to know about
  Posted 14 days ago with 35 member flags
Does this video show a working self propelled magnetic engine?
  Posted 7 days ago with 31 member flags
Viruses: alive or not?
  Posted 11 days ago with 30 member flags
NASA reveals secrets it has hidden on the Curiosity rover.
  Posted 17 days ago with 29 member flags