Zecharia Sitchin sumerian literature translations are probably greatly embellished, page 1


Pages:
ATS Members have flagged this thread 7 times
Topic started on 22-11-2012 @ 10:19 PM by nOraKat
Those familiar with Zecharia Sitchin's books know his story - that humans were genetically engineered by a race of people from another planet that settled on the Earth - the Annunaki or, that is, the Sumerians.

His information was supposedly derived directly from translations of Sumerian cuneiform tablets. He has his own version of the tablets, that is, his own translations. He called a set of these scriptures "The lost books of Enki".

I ran across a website that posted Sitchin's translations in some videos. (link below)

truthisscary.com...

---

After viewing these, I wanted to find out for myself if the cuneiform tablets did indeed tell the story as explicitly as he had.

Later, I found a project online by the University of Oxford which translated several Sumerian cuneiform tablets.

I believe I have found the one that Sitchin used to determine that humans were genetically engineered.

Here it is below:
etcsl.orinst.ox.ac.uk...#

If you read the actual translation, and his version.. you can see how he created a great embellishment and really jumped sky high to conclusions to derive his own translations.

---

From reading and viewing the actual direct translations, and also having actually seen real Sumerian artifacts from Ur, I suspect it is possible that Sitchin is really stretching his conclusions to satisfy a really great story that would sell a lot of books.

I think that it is likely that the Sumerian stories are a creation mythology to satisfy the absence of the real knowledge of their origins, and are not to be taken as real/actual events (That is, a god did not form these beings from clay). And while the Sumerians built impressive buildings and monuments like the temple in Ur, they may just have been a earthly and somewhat primitive culture. I would have to choose this as the actuality if I had to bet on it. However, it would be an uncertain bet, as the one cylinder he presented - which may have represented the sun with the planets orbiting it, here: (www.thelivingmoon.com...).. is impressive and is possibly presents unearthly knowledge.

Whatever the case, I thought it would be nice for anyone interested to have this library from Oxford available for their perusal.

etcsl.orinst.ox.ac.uk...#
etcsl.orinst.ox.ac.uk...

enjoy..
edit on 22-11-2012 by nOraKat because: (no reason given)



reply posted on 22-11-2012 @ 10:39 PM by OccamsRazor04
reply to post by nOraKat



This is common knowledge and is easily verifiable, as you verified it yourself. Those who wish to believe wis to believe, facts are not as important.



reply posted on 22-11-2012 @ 11:08 PM by newcovenant
reply to post by nOraKat



I've read other translations and they are still similar. I think he weaves a tale but the characters are there and even if embellished they are still telling an incredible tale that predates biblical stories and yet are the same stories somehow. The Sumerians are fascinating no matter who is translating.


reply posted on 23-11-2012 @ 01:16 AM by nOraKat
I thought I should point out why this Sumerian tablet is clearly, without question the tablet that Zecharia Sitchin used to support the theory that the Sumerian 'Gods' created man to substitute in for, and do the work for the 'minor gods' who were complaining about their toil (mining gold on the Earth).

I will highlight the correlating passages in asterisks.

---

From the Sumerian Tablet: Enki and Ninmaḫ (ETCSLtranslation : t.1.1.2)

1-11. In those days, in the days when heaven and earth were created; in those nights, in the nights when heaven and earth were created; in those years, in the years when the fates were determined; when the Anuna gods were born; when the goddesses were taken in marriage; when the goddesses were distributed in heaven and earth; when the goddesses …… became pregnant and gave birth; when the gods were obliged (?) …… their food …… dining halls;

* ...the senior gods oversaw the work, while the minor gods were bearing the toil. The gods were digging the canals and piling up the silt in Ḫarali. The gods, crushing the clay, began complaining about this life. *

12-23. At that time, the one of great wisdom, the creator of all the senior gods, Enki lay on his bed, not waking up from his sleep, in the deep engur, in the subterranean water, the place the inside of which no other god knows. The gods said, weeping: "He is the cause of the lamenting!" Namma, the primeval mother who gave birth to the senior gods, took the tears of the gods to the one who lay sleeping, to the one who did not wake up from his bed, to her son: "Are you really lying there asleep, and …… not awake? The gods, your creatures, are smashing their …….

* My son, wake up from your bed! Please apply the skill deriving from your wisdom and create a substitute (?) for the gods so that they can be freed from their toil!" *

24-37. At the word of his mother Namma, Enki rose up from his bed. In Ḫal-an-kug, his room for pondering, he slapped his thigh in annoyance. The wise and intelligent one, the prudent, …… of skills, the fashioner of the design of everything brought to life birth-goddesses (?). Enki reached out his arm over them and turned his attention to them.

* And after Enki, the fashioner of designs by himself, had pondered the matter, he said to his mother Namma: "My mother, the creature you planned will really come into existence. Impose on him the work of carrying baskets. You should knead clay from the top of the abzu; the birth-goddesses (?) will nip off the clay and you shall bring the form into existence. *

Let Ninmaḫ act as your assistant; and let Ninimma, Šu-zi-ana, Ninmada, Ninbarag, Ninmug, …… and Ninguna stand by as you give birth. My mother, after you have decreed his fate, let Ninmaḫ impose on him the work of carrying baskets." ...

Ninmaḫ took clay from the top of the abzu in her hand and she fashioned from it first a man who could not bend his outstretched weak hands.

etcsl.orinst.ox.ac.uk...#

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

(My comments:

Below I present Sitchin's version of the above correlating story with his embellishments. To be fair he does not state anywhere in his book that his book is translations of actual Sumerian tablets (like the one above), however he does present them as so, misleading others as if these are actual translations of tablets that he discovered himself. Indeed, many people believe this is the case. He titles the sections with numbered tablets, like - "THE SIXTH TABLET" (below).

In his own words: " Sumerian and Akkadian clay tablets; Babylonian and Assyrian temple libraries; ... and the biblical narratives are the main body of written-down memories of the affairs of gods and men. For the first time ever, this dispersed and fragmented material has been assembled and used by Zecharia Sitchin to re-create the eyewitness account of Enki the autobiographical memoirs and insightful prophecies of an extraterrestrial god.

Presented as a text dictated by Enki to a chosen scribe, a Book of Witnessing to be unsealed at
an appropriate time, ..."

..oooooh )

From The Lost Book of Enki by Zecharia Sitchin:

THE SIXTH TABLET

"To create a Primitive Worker, by the mark of our essence to fashion him!
So was Enki to the leaders saying.
The Being that we need, it already exists!
Thus did Enki to them a secret of the Abzu reveal.
With astonishment did the other leaders Enki's words hear; by the words they were fascinated.
Creatures in the Abzu there are, Enki was saying, that walk erect on two legs,
Their forelegs they use as arms, with hands they are provided.
Among the animals of the steppe they live. They know not dressing in garments,
They eat plants with their mouths, they drink water from lake and ditch.
Shaggy with hair is their whole body, their head hair is like a lion's;..."

cont...


reply posted on 23-11-2012 @ 06:26 AM by iterationzero
reply to post by newcovenant


I think that's really the point -- the Sumerians are fascinating without the embellishments and fabrications added by Sitchin.


reply posted on 27-11-2012 @ 08:36 AM by Logarock
reply to post by Ozymandias121



Not many like a randomly meandering book about nothing.

Pages:     ^^TOP^^



Bill Nye: Creationism is not appropriate for children.
  Posted 15 days ago with 20 member flags
Satan hid the fossils to trick everyone!
  Posted 18 days ago with 11 member flags
Just ONE question on evolution
  Posted 15 days ago with 5 member flags
M U T A T I O N - Friend or Foe of Evolution?
  Posted 8 days ago with 5 member flags
When a Child is Born...the Evolution begins
  Posted 5 days ago with 5 member flags
Denisovans
  Posted 15 days ago with 3 member flags
Are Humans the result of Hybridization?
  Posted 14 days ago with 3 member flags