It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by samerulesapply
Originally posted by OccamsRazor04
reply to post by samerulesapply
I didn't ask for conclusive proof. His story should at least stand a very simple logic test. It was a fabrication, I can appreciate that, the problem is that he did not think it out very clearly.
If I told you I recently talked to an Elite and he told me that they have been preventing all births for 20 years, and you have a child born just last year, you know what I am saying is crap. Make your story beleivable if you are going to lie. His wasn't.
There you go...he's a liar, you said it. And stop avoiding the obvious facts here...you commented about "logical thought" or some such nonsense...so here's the point - if you or anyone I know came and told me you'd met someone who told you that they'd been preventing all births for 20 years, I would not think it was crap, that you were a liar. I'd think either you made it up...or, wait for it - you actually did meet someone who did tell you these things. Stop avoiding the truth.
You outwardly called the guy a liar, you said he had "nothing to back it up" yet claim you want no conclusive proof?
Is this your idea of logical thinking? You can argue all you want, you founf someone you thought you could use to make yourself appear smarter and superior to...I don't think you thought this out logically any more than you think the OP did...deny iignorance,but don't deny having been ignorant. Calling him a liar, uncreative, etc...yeah - you're right.
To clarfiy,,,since you seem to have trouble understanding...I once had a friend who told me he got chased home by a huge monkey...in Edinburgh city centre. Now I was pretty sure this was a lie, we were kida still at school. Now do you assume that I'm a liar because I'm telling you this? No, I'm simply telling you what someone told me...people tell other people crazy things all the time, you can't just brand the guy a liar because me told us someone told him some outlandish stuff. Prove he's a liar, since you're so certain and have employed such impeccable logic in reaching your conclusions.edit on 19-10-2012 by samerulesapply because: Additionaledit on 19-10-2012 by samerulesapply because: (no reason given)