It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Now, to explain the question and answer it: "Did God give us free will...or did the fruit?"
It's clear that our poor choices come from our free will, as do our good choices. But the mere act of choosing implies there's more than one option, some more desirable than other options. But how do you know it's more desirable? Because you know where the other option will lead. You know, and you don't like it. This means that the ability to recognize a good option comes from the freedom to make bad choices.
Now, in the story, before Eve and Adam partook of the fruit of knowledge, they were obviously pious or gracious or pure or whatever enough to stay in the Garden of Eden, right? But when the opportunity came to disobey the one command they were given, they broke the rule. Why? Because they didn't have the experience to say no. They'd never made that mistake before, so how were they to know what lay down that path?
When you don't have the freedom to make mistakes, you don't have free will. "God" prevented them from having the opportunity to stumble, until the fruit became involved. And according to Christian faith, he punished them by throwing them from the garden. Because the fruit showed them both positive and negative, and with that knowledge came free will. The freedom to make mistakes.
"God" didn't give us free will. The fruit did.
Originally posted by swan001
reply to post by maes2
Correction: I call SOME atheist antichristians. SOME atheist I know run around ATS trying to insult christians. I know, I am still arguing with some of them, saying: Stop visiting christians's threads if you don't like them.
Originally posted by detachedindividual
When Christians stop meddling in law and state, and they stop trying to be dictators of their nations, then there will be no problem.
It is very bizarre to listen to people tell you what their gods think, or mean to say. I always relate it to the 1950 movie "Harvey", where Jimmy Stewart walks around town with a six-foot invisible rabbit.
Originally posted by The Old American
reply to post by acmpnsfal
That's interesting, because I see plenty of atheist trolls on ATS, and they're just as full of hatred and bile as the religious trolls you magically only see.
/TOA
Attacks from both sides. That's a war.
Originally posted by swan001
reply to post by Krazysh0t
Exactly. You are presenting it very accurately. Some christians are just donkeys, I saw them myself doing exactly what you described. But there are also antichristians who actually are sick of any christians and become trolls. If only the right balance between religion and atheism would be found, no conflict would arise. Like yourself, sir. You are an atheist (agnostic) who tries to see what's true.
Originally posted by swan001
reply to post by detachedindividual
I see. "you enjoy it". That's all I needed to hear. Thanks for admitting it. You need to find another hobby than using ATS to attack christians just "for fun". This site's T&C clearly defines and disapprove this kind of behaviour. I happen to agree with this T&C.
Originally posted by autowrench
Originally posted by The Old American
reply to post by acmpnsfal
That's interesting, because I see plenty of atheist trolls on ATS, and they're just as full of hatred and bile as the religious trolls you magically only see.
/TOA
Start a thread on Aliens, Ghosts, Channeling, or Spirits and watch how fast the Christian trolls come to it, like flies to honey. One group is as bad as the other.
By the way, I have been told by the Christians of ATS that all of the above are in fact, Demons. And they work at fooling people. Are you fooled? I studied Demonology for two years. Why have I never once spotted a Demon, and yet good Christians are plagued by them?