The Battle of Shingle Street!! 1940, page
Pages:
ATS Members have flagged this thread 0 times


reply posted on 5-10-2004 @ 09:18 AM by Smudge
If you want you can listen to the programme again here
Battle of Shingle Street

They are quite dissmisive as an overall tone. However having read a few sites this morning, there is definitely something not quite right.

Why would the events be so secretive just about everything horrors and all has been made public.

The only things I can think of that would be this bad would be if we were killing our own people by mistake perhaps. The German invasion could be the cover story for something along the lines of opening up on British or alied troops coming ashore after a recce or some such.


reply posted on 17-5-2011 @ 11:59 AM by ignorant_ape
i am very skeptical about the entire " shingle street claims "

1 - IF a german raid had been repulsed - it would have been outstanding propoganda , at the time there were many fears of invasions - and GOOD news that a raid had been repulsed would have been a moral boost to the publuic

2 - german silence , if the germans had lost a covert operations force - where are the records of it - why would they suppress it too ? they OBVIOUSLY would at the time - for the same reason that the british SHOULD hace shouted it out - ie the allegedly " invincible " germsan war machine fails - but why continued suppression ?

if the brittish had allegedly committed warcrimes to repulse the raid - why not use that " fact " as a defence at neuremberg ? several defendants made other claims of illegal brittish action

3 - the operational logistics - and the logistics of mounting a defence - at the time - i am highly skeptical that the bittish defences could have contsained a german raid entirely " on the beach " at shingle street

look at the raids by the brittish - breuneval , loften islands etc etc

however determined you are - its impossible to secure an entire coastline against any incursion 24/7

you have to maintain a picketr line - to detect and engage the enemy - and slow his advance while counterattack forces rally

lastly - bodies on the shore - were distressingly common - aviators , MTB crew , naval personel etc were regularly lost at sea - and floated up on both sides of the channel / north sea
Pages:     ^^TOP^^



Eglin Air Force Base hangar Foam Party!
  Posted 13 days ago with 4 member flags
Space weapons / Anonymous / Afghan War plan
  Posted 6 days ago with 4 member flags
What were those sounds in the sky? - Explained
  Posted 0 days ago with 4 member flags
Reports of Rumbling in the Sky: Pulsejet Technology?
  Posted 16 days ago with 3 member flags
Let anon hack drones!
  Posted 11 days ago with 3 member flags