It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by kat2684
reply to post by Prezbo369
That was just one small detail of many, including clothing and surroundings. I'm not trying to be special, or some exception to the rule ( I caught your condescending tone), I just think it was a odd detail. The same scenario played out in my dreams until I was 10, its specifically the only part I remember.
I wasn't even trying to go deep into this topic, but someone claimed I denied any other possibility, which I never claimed too. I had one belief, and all the debunkers want to pounce, the bottom line is, its what I think, and not what I know.
Originally posted by kat2684
I talked with my mother in law one afternoon, she said my husbands grandfather was in WWI he lost both his legs on a explosion over a bridge. She claimed when he was alive, he would never cross this same bridge, without crying hysterically. Now this bridge has changed since the 60's when he passed, but the similarities are odd.
Another funny coincidence, his grandfather knew my family he lived the house behind my grandmother and aunt. My grandmother knew this man too, she said people would bring him food and that everyone knew what happened to his legs, and that he was scared of the bridge
Originally posted by Theophorus
reply to post by rival
To answer your question the word " where" denotes space. Only physical things can exist in space. Question should have been, were you a physical thing before you were born? The answer could only be no. Material things can never cease to exist. They just change form. The smiple truth is that there is no where you could be before you were born unless you were reincarnated,which I dont subscribe to,or incarnated.regardless we all must have existed in a spiritual state without any knowledge.
Originally posted by g2v12
What about the existence of the conscious mind prior to birth in a physical body?
I believe this happens when we as humans take our first breath.
What about the birth of the conscious mind?
thought is more so related to 'mind' 'spirit' than to 'physical' 'material' man lives in a material world and unless we can develop tools to measure spiritual things we will never prove these things.
We haven't identified the energy or subatomic character of thought.
this is where it gets tricky.I believe that when spirit and body merge into one it is held together by the soul,which animates a body.
Whose to say that it doesn't exist within its own sphere and is expressed through animate flesh, bone and neurons?
Originally posted by Theophorus
Originally posted by g2v12
What about the existence of the conscious mind prior to birth in a physical body?
to be conscious of something is to have knowledge of that which we are conscious to.I believe that before birth we have no conscious mind.All knowledge that the mnd aquires is after birth.I believe this happens when we as humans take our first breath.
What about the birth of the conscious mind?thought is more so related to 'mind' 'spirit' than to 'physical' 'material' man lives in a material world and unless we can develop tools to measure spiritual things we will never prove these things.
We haven't identified the energy or subatomic character of thought.this is where it gets tricky.I believe that when spirit and body merge into one it is held together by the soul,which animates a body.
Whose to say that it doesn't exist within its own sphere and is expressed through animate flesh, bone and neurons?
edit on 20-6-2012 by Theophorus because: (no reason given)edit on 20-6-2012 by Theophorus because: (no reason given)
did you, and your consciousness simply coalesce at this particular time, in this particular place, on
this particular little blue ball...in the middle of nowhere?