It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by Erbal
To insist Masonry is not a religion because it does not promise salvation is a weak and petty argument. By that logic, nothing is a religion because no religion I know of promises salvation. A promise is a strong word. Virtually all religions (not all of them) offer salvation but to promise salvation is something entirely different that no religion is guilty of.
I walk away from this conversation sadden by the fact I simply cannot have a forthright conversation with a Mason when I seek no harm, only more understanding.
I'm not sure I could make it past through the blue lodge... how can I, and why would I or should I, swear to so many uninformed oaths? Would you sign a binding contract without reading it, without knowing the full terms and conditions, all on someones word you won't regret it? If so, stop by my house later, I have some paperwork I'd like you to sign.
Originally posted by network dude
reply to post by Erbal
I am sorry you feel that way. We don't intentionally hold back information, but there are some things we are obligated not to tell. You can read it all in Duncan's ritual. But as I said before, if you ever have any thoughts of going through the degrees, it's best if you do it with little to no understanding of them. it's how we learn.
but like I said, if you have no thoughts of joining, read the books that spill all the secrets.
Originally posted by Erbal
Thanks for the reply but understand as of right now I literally have no idea what YOU mean when YOU say salvation.
Originally posted by rainbowbear
thats because in Freemasonry you hele...
I disagree with the accuracy of your post. The accuracy of details are critical to the conversation, change the details and you no longer have the same conversation.
Originally posted by JoshNorton
reply to post by Erbal
You're getting hung up on the word "promise." When first asked, NetworkDude said it doesn't offer salvation. When you pressed him on his own interpretation of salvation, he used the word promise, and you took that and ran.
Originally posted by rainbowbear
have you heard this in the craft before or not?
What happens when one does not stick to their integrity and fidelity, in regards to their life in the same exact context of which you are speaking?
I walk away from this conversation sadden by the fact I simply cannot have a forthright conversation with a Mason when I seek no harm, only more understanding.
Originally posted by Erbal
I am asking straightforward questions...
Originally posted by AugustusMasonicus
And I gave you two straight forward answers, the second of which you opted to ignore.
I'm not trying to be rude or disrespectful but I need you to clarify your intended message to make sure we are on the same exact page. Wordplay and obfuscation are a subtle craft, I've seen enough already to know asking for clarity instead of making assumptions is invaluable to an outsider conversing with an esoteric insider.
Originally posted by AugustusMasonicusThe act, the state or the source of being protected from risk or harm and the deliverance from the penalty of sin.
Does that about cover it?