It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by phatpackage
reply to post by CX
Based off the Youtube clips you have shown your daughter has nothing special at this particular time. She sings in key but nothing special. Average at best. No "Mega" range that is going to get to her noticed. I'm sorry to be so hard but it is the truth. But the good news is she is only fourteen and time is on her side. Confidence does seem to be an issue as she never seems to hit that "big" note. In the videos it looks like a confidence issue not ability.
She needs to put more feeling into the music. Sing likes she means it. sing the song as though she "owns" it. She does not seem to be "feeling" it. Keep on meeting people and practising as often as time allows. You never know what can happen. 14 is such a young age to cast a lifetime judgement but at the minute she shows little potential. Hard work could change that in a very very short space of time. I hope she improves and does well but that is entirely up to her!
Geeze you are in a trolling/arsehole mood
Originally posted by phatpackage
reply to post by daaskapital
Geeze you are in a trolling/arsehole mood
Where do you get off? The OP was asking for opinion and I gave it to them using my 25 years experience as a musician. If you read the whole post it was not all bad news! If you don't like it you know what can do! When you have more than 25 years experience as a musician you can tell me!
The girl need encouragement. It's her dream. Not your discouragement
Keep on meeting people and practising as often as time allows. You never know what can happen. 14 is such a young age to cast a lifetime judgement but at the minute she shows little potential. Hard work could change that in a very very short space of time. I hope she improves and does well but that is entirely up to her!
with a strong and resonant mid-range. A great number of female vocalists have built very successful careers around songs that fall within the range your daughter can reasonably expect to sing.
Originally posted by swan001
reply to post by phatpackage
Please try and stay polite. ''moron'' and, above all, ''goose'', are some words and I almost lost my MIB-mood.
I think that saying she had ''nothing special'' and no Mega range and that she won't get noticed was not very encouraging. Saying ''keep working, maybe she'll improve'' looks like sugar-coat to me. If I were a singer I would have been pretty discouraged.
Please, no childish name calling... Phat.
Originally posted by swan001
reply to post by phatpackage
Please, calm down. I understand your point. I am in music too you know. The most important part is work.
You must be Irish.