Hurricane Jeanne Tests the Faith of Jews in Florida, page
Pages:
ATS Members have flagged this thread 0 times
Topic started on 24-9-2004 @ 02:26 PM by worldwatcher
Beginning at sun down today, Jews all over the world will begin to celebrate their most holiest of holidays Yom Kippur. During this time, they do not use technology, ie. listen to radios, watch tv, make phone calls, drive cars, etc. Now normally this isn't a problem but with Hurricane Jeanne threatening Florida and critical monitoring of the storm's track being required by all, a dilemma has arisen for those of the Jewish faith.

The City of Miami is so concerned that Jewish residents may not be aware of impending danger that they contacted local rabbis and currently have them addressing the Jewish population in Florida to let them know that their safety and lives are more important than following the customs of the holiday. Rabbis are advising their followers to listen to the radio, watch tv and monitor the storm. They are suggesting that those of the Jewish faith complete all hurricane preparations by sun down today, but if unable to complete it and work must be done tomorrow that they "think" God would not be offended.

In all the craziness going on surrounding hurricane preps, I found this story to be rather interesting. I do hope that those faithful Jews will think of themselves and families first vs religious customs.

oops I forgot the link

If storm threatens during holiday, Jews are allowed to evacuate
Above all, life is sacred to Jews, so if a killer hurricane threatens during Yom Kippur, many rabbis in mandatory-evacuation zones will counsel their flocks to flee.

Short of a ''killer'' storm, however, services for the solemn Jewish holiday, which begins today at sundown, will go on as planned, calls to South Florida synagogues indicate.

''For Frances, there was a mandatory evacuation and all of Miami Beach was told to leave, but I know maybe one person who left,'' said Rabbi Neal Turk of the Orthodox Beth Israel Congregation.

''But if there is a serious hurricane that could hit us head-on, I'd tell people to get into their cars during Yom Kippur and drive off the beach, because any threat to life takes precedence'' over ritual.

Just as Jewish law not only permits but mandates eating on a fasting day such as Yom Kippur under doctor's orders, he said a serious storm also would be a ``clear-cut situation.''

At a press conference with Miami-Dade Mayor Alex Penelas on Thursday night, Rabbi Solomon Schiff, executive vice president of the Rabbinical Association of Greater Miami, said safety is paramount, despite religious obligations


[edit on 9-24-2004 by worldwatcher]


reply posted on 24-9-2004 @ 04:45 PM by Amadeus
Hi there Gazrok:

Apparently in cases of life and death (in extremis) post Exilic Judaeism allowed some leeway with Holy Days, Fast days and Sabbaths (cf: the story of Iesous and his starving band of disciples gleaning a stubblefield on the Sabbath i.e. takling the remants left on the stalks for the poor), although R. Shammai and R. Hillel had some differing opinions (oh, very well... screaming matches!) on what exactly constituted "in extremis".

Here is what the later Mediaeval Rebbes had to say on this subject (ref: Pashash Ki Sisa, On the Desecration of the Holy to Save a Life):

"The holiness of a Nefesh {soul of a} Yisroel is greater than the holiness of the Sabbath...The lesser (Sabbath) is pushed aside for the sake of the greater (a nefesh Yisroel)."

(cf: the words of R. Yehoshua bar Yosef the Gaililean ( "Iesous")

"And he said to the Pharisim: Were sons of men made for the Sabbath or was the Sabbath made for the sons of men? And they said to him, The sabbath was made for the sons of men. And he said to them, Cannot you see therefore that the sons of men are then made lords over the Sabbath?)

John's Gospel (John 7:23) contains an interesting Logion ref circumcision and healing of a sick body on the Sabbath which Moses apparently allowed, even though it meant the Mo'el using a knife to cut flesh (and therefore constituted "work").

= roughly: "If Moses allowed a man to remove a flap of skin on the Sabbath, how much more would he have allowed the restoring of an entire human body!"

In the Talmud, Ohr HaChaim discusses the problem of breaking a Holy Day Fast etc. in order "to save a life of an Israelite"

“{But} My Sabbaths”: when a person’s life is at stake, do what must be done to save that life, even if it will involve desecrating the Sabbath.

This applies to all days that are called “Sabbath”­all the Sabbaths: including Sabbath, Yom Kippur [the Day of Atonement] and all holidays.

According to the Ohr HaChaim, the "passuk" also contains two explanations as to why the Sabbath is pushed aside in order to save a life.

“[But] My Sabbaths . . . We must sometkimes desecrate a Sabbath in order to (by keeping this person alive) allow for the observance of many, many Sabbaths in the future. "

Thus it is not considered desecration but rather, in such a life-threatening situation, ‘breaking’ the Sabbath would be considered "proper observance"

"In the case of saving a life it’s not a sin but rather a Mitzvah [commandment]. This interpretation of the law, that the Sabbath may be broken in order to save a life, enables us “to know that I am Hashem and I have sanctified you.”

Clear as Mud?
Pages:     ^^TOP^^



The Truth About the Garden of Eden Story
  Posted 9 days ago with 49 member flags
The Mormon Church is a Cult
  Posted 12 days ago with 23 member flags
Google Earth proves Muhammad-Islam
  Posted 2 days ago with 23 member flags
Where is the gospel of jesus?
  Posted 3 days ago with 18 member flags
Who killed the prophet Muhammad? A 1400 year old murder mystery.
  Posted 17 days ago with 16 member flags
Quake Reveals Day of Jesus\' Crucifixion
  Posted 4 days ago with 12 member flags
Ancient Photographic Evidance of Angels. The Real Anunnaki
  Posted 0 days ago with 10 member flags