Originally posted by XPLodER
i have read many theories about magnetic reconnection and field lines snapping ect,
this picture looks like how i imagine it would look
But for the fact there is no such MATERIAL object as a 'field line,' I'd have to agree. This is largely what I'd thought the plasma process might look
like.
This research appears to bring us full circle back to Hannes Alfvén's "exploding circuits" and/or "exploding double layers."
plasmafrontier.blogspot.com...
Can we please dispense with the poor metaphysics of 'field line reconnection' and call it what it is? An exploding electric circuit in plasma... About
time someone hammered the last nail into 'reconnection.'
Field lines do not EXIST. They are a draftsman's artifice on paper denoting surfaces of 'equal properties,' generally magnetic field strength and
direction. That is the direction and magnitude of a force felt by a particle dropped at a given point in the continuous vector field.
Electric currents are the sole source of magnetic fields in the universe. Yes, even at the atomic / "permanent magnet" level.
plasmafrontier.blogspot.com...
So, it seems what Bellan & Moser have 'discovered' was already suggested by Hannes Alfvén c. 1970's / 1980's. That is to say that electric circuit
are explosive in that when you try to disrupt them, they can explode at the point of the break with the inductive energy of the circuit being released
at the point of the break.
It sounds like that's exactly what Bellan / Moser have discovered and recounted in terms of so-called 'reconnection.'
1) Current is established.
2) Magnetic field self-interacts with the current causing a kink instability.
3) Rayleigh-Taylor instability develops on a much smaller scale at some point in the circuit.
4) In the region where R-T instability develops, the current 'pinches' and 'necks off' (much like the 'sausage instability').
5) Circuit is disrupted.
6) Impulsive event. They identify it as a 'reconnection' event.' Alfvén would describe it as an exploding circuit. That is an electrical explosion
(an impulsive event, itself). Large quantities of energy are released at the point of the circuit rupture.
As the underlying current system changes, the associated magnetic field lines MUST be redrawn. Hence the changes in the magnetic 'field lines' /
magnetic field topology at the time of the impulsive event ('reconnection' / circuit explosion).
'Field lines' DO NOTHING. Circuits exist. Current drive magnetic field (a force felt between currents). Magnetic field lines merely denote properties
of that field and change only as the magnetic fields change, which themselves only change as the underlying currents change. The 'field line' changes
are merely an after-effect. 'Reconnection confuses cause & effect.
We don't say that 'elevation line' fluctuations during an earthquake cause the earthquake by releasing 'tectonic energy.' Any geologist who said that
would probably get laughed out of geology college. Same goes for isobars on weather maps and storms...
Let's stop reversing cause and effect and simply recognize that these are impulsive electric events.
The same should be applied to solar flares as well, since 'MR' (no, not mental retardation! 'magnetic reconnection'...) has been implicated there
too...
And, gosh, Hannes Alfvén already dealt with that electrically too!
www.electric-cosmos.org...
www.electric-cosmos.org...
Electrical engineer Don Scott summarizes it nicely:
"Energy, Wm, stored in any magnetic field, is given by the expression Wm = 1/2 Li ^2. If the current, i, is interrupted, the field collapses and its
energy must be delivered somewhere. The magnetic field of the Sun sometimes, and in some places on its surface, forms an "omega" shaped loop. This
loop extends out through the double sheath layer (DL) of the chromosphere. One of the primary properties of Birkeland currents is that they generally
follow magnetic field lines. A strong looping current will produce a secondary toroidal magnetic field that will surround and try to expand the loop.
If the current following the loop becomes too strong, the DL will be destroyed. This interrupts the current (like opening a switch in an inductive
circuit) and the energy stored in the primary magnetic field is explosively released into space."
"...when magnetic fields collapse due to the interruption of the currents that produce them, they do not "break" or "merge" and "recombine" as some
uninformed astronomers have claimed ... The field simply collapses (very quickly!). On the Sun this collapse releases a tremendous amount of energy,
and matter is thrown out away from the surface - as with any explosively rapid reaction."
Time to play catch up, astronomers, astrophysicists, et al. The revelations of the 1980's are calling your name!
~MG
edit on 21-2-2012 by mgmirkin because: (no reason given)
edit on 21-2-2012 by mgmirkin because: (no reason given)