NH - 1st State In The Country To Strip Parents The Right To Counsel, page
Pages:
ATS Members have flagged this thread 3 times
Topic started on 5-2-2012 @ 11:13 AM by JibbyJedi
This information is approx. 7 months old, but it is new to me and my fellow New Hampshire citizens who apparently didn't receive the memo. We just learned of this from an 8 hour training to be a volunteer court appointed child advocate in the state of New Hampshire.





Attorneys for needy parents cut
Accused must defend themselves

Parents who cannot afford an attorney to defend themselves against accusations of abusing or neglecting their children are no longer entitled to have one appointed. The change in state law, which went into effect July 1, was prompted by budget cuts. It has child advocates as well as attorneys who represent parents in abuse and neglect cases worried that more children will be permanently removed from their homes.

Concordmonitor.com


Opinion: Representation of Accused Parents is Fundamental Right
Few rights can be argued to be more fundamental then the right to raise and care for one’s children. In recognition of that right, New Hampshire has long appointed counsel to represent indigent parents in abuse and neglect proceedings who face the removal of their children from their care by the State. The NH Supreme Court recognized in Shelby R. that "abuse and neglect proceedings can harm, and in some cases irreparably damage, family and marital relationships."

Despite the constitutional protections afforded to parents, recent passage of HB2 [the budget "trailer bill"] and the issuance of Circuit Court Administrative Order 2011-01 deprives indigent parents accused of abuse and neglect of the statutory right to be represented by an attorney at all stages of the proceedings. The Administrative Order prohibits any new appointments of counsel after July 1, 2011, and orders the automatic withdrawal of counsel after the issuance of dispositional orders for attorneys appointed prior to July 1, 2011. However, legislative enactments cannot override a constitutional protection and the Courts have an affirmative duty to invalidate a statute that violates a person’s constitutional rights.

NHbar.org


Coming Changes and Challenges to New Hampshire Parents' Right to Counsel in Abuse and Neglect Proceedings
Until June 30, 2011, attorneys shall continue to be appointed to represent an indigent parent only where mandated by RSA169-C:10, II(a), i.e. in cases where an indigent parent is alleged to have neglected or abused his or her child.

Effective July 1, 2011, counsel shall not be appointed for indigent parents in abuse and neglect cases under RSA chapter 169-C.

Effective July 1, 2011, all appointments of counsel, including existing appointments, to represent indigent parents in abuse and neglect cases shall terminate upon the issuance of the dispositional order pursuant to RSA 169-C:19.

NHfamilylawblog.com


AMICUS CURIAE BRIEF OF THE NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF COUNSEL FOR
CHILDREN

ARGUMENT
On July 1, 2011, the New Hampshire legislature eliminated funding for court appointed lawyers to represent indigent parents in child welfare cases. In doing so, New Hampshire became the first state in the country to strip parents of the right to counsel – an important procedural safeguard aimed at ensuring that courts reach accurate decisions involving the temporary or permanent placement of a child into foster care.

nh_amicus_brief.pdf

So if you can afford an attorney, this doesn't concern you. However, if you are the 99 out of 100 families who can't afford an attorney, you are on your own.

Q: Who are the families usually targeted for neglect and abuse?
A: The poor. The majority are families who can't afford their own attorney.

They cut 1.2 million out of their budget by doing this. Do you know how much waste spending there is in just my local area alone? There is a war going on right here at home against the family, and the attacks are coming from all directions.


reply posted on 5-2-2012 @ 11:41 AM by JibbyJedi
reply to post by intrepid



They said it best here...
...the Supreme Court will be called upon to recognize a parent's constitutional right to counsel in abuse and neglect proceedings. Until then, parents will have to navigate the abuse and neglect system without advice or counsel and try their best to advocate for themselves and their children.

nhfamilylawblog...

"Until then"... in the meantime, sucks to be poor and "accused" of alleged abuse. Going to be hard to prove your case when your nerves a mess and your head is spinning around in space from the dump truck load of legal speak paperwork one has to deal with.


edit on 5-2-2012 by JibbyJedi because: (no reason given)



reply posted on 5-2-2012 @ 11:47 AM by intrepid
reply to post by JibbyJedi



In other words they are rescinding portions of the 6th. That won't stand up in the US Supreme Court. Like you said though, "until then". What happens? Constitutional rights violations that will tear how many families apart? They think they're saving money? Wait until the law suits start pouring in.


reply posted on 5-2-2012 @ 11:59 AM by JibbyJedi
reply to post by intrepid



Who will be able to afford to pursue lawsuits when all is said and done? After their lives are destroyed, PTSD sets in, substance abuse soon follows, and then comes time to pursue JUSTICE for wrongful actions by the state... lol.

If they are lucky, and can scratch up a few bucks for a lawyer, they'll get a settlement by the time their children have children of their own..... maybe.


reply posted on 5-2-2012 @ 12:10 PM by intrepid
Originally posted by JibbyJedi
reply to
post by intrepid



Who will be able to afford to pursue lawsuits when all is said and done?


That's just it though. They can't afford a criminal attorney but civil lawyers will be salivating after the big pay's that will come from civil suits. Stupid isn't it?


reply posted on 5-2-2012 @ 04:33 PM by JibbyJedi
reply to post by stirling



Good to see others are paying attention. I don't know how else to get the reality of the situation out there. We do all we can as it is, my girlfriend took in 100s of foster kids in the past 10 years, she's trying to be an advocate for these parents who can't get legal aid, and I'm trying to help by doing whatever I can.

Seems like a futile battle, like trying to catch all of the rain drops from the sky, but someone has to do something.

edit on 5-2-2012 by JibbyJedi because: tyop

Pages:     ^^TOP^^



The Zombie Apocalypse is Real! And it\'s Here Now!
  Posted 17 days ago with 87 member flags
While Americans keep arguing about Trayvon-Zimmerman
  Posted 11 days ago with 79 member flags
Faked Moon Landing - Amazing Documentary
  Posted 12 days ago with 59 member flags
This is scary!
  Posted 17 days ago with 57 member flags