This does look very interesting, I think its genuine.

The camera shake looks right, and look how clear it is!!!!!

Also it seems to either turn on to its side, or change shape, its hard to tell as the view looks away a couple times.

But great find, size of a tractor wheel, either a probe or tiny aliens

Fake as a 3 dollar bill!!!

If you pause it at the :58 second mark, you will see it is flipped on its side. Looks like they tried to pan away real quick but instead caught it flipping. Good try though.

Great video! There must be a way to make the Elite stop this hush-hush nonsense!

come on!!!
it is obviously something being thrown into the air...then it takes a nose dive when it loses momentum!!

This video isnt very convincing. With the GCI technology we have these days, this video could have been made by a middle school class.

Originally posted by TheOilTruth
This video isnt very convincing. With the GCI technology we have these days, this video could have been made by a middle school class.

Did you mean CGI??

I don't know... to me it looks pretty convincing because of the way it is rotating, although the last part when it leaves really seems as someone is pulling it away with a string. Then again if it is a hoax, why leave that part on the footage?

Old video .. saw it on the history channel like a year & 1/2 ago ..

can't remember what the outcome of the video was

Originally posted by TheOilTruth
This video isnt very convincing. With the GCI technology we have these days, this video could have been made by a middle school class.

This simply has to stop. With the CGI technology we have these days, any single video you could possibly watch anywhere ever could at least be manipulated with CGI, if not completely artificially generated using CGI.

Take a moment to think about that - every single video you will ever see could be CGI. Therefore the 'we can do this with CGI so it must be fake' argument goes right out the window.

Maybe it's CGI - break the video down and show us the different elements that you feel were composited to create the final comped shot. Show us how we can see that they didn't use a garbage matte. Show us an incorrectly aligned horizon or incorrect shadows. Then I'll consider that the clip might be CGI. But people need to stop saying 'we can do this with CGI so it must be CGI'. We can do everything with CGI!!

I don't really feel like this is a particularly compelling video either - but I agree with the other posters that it is hoaxed with a physical effect rather than a visual effect.

And think before you scream 'CGI'! If a poster claims a video is real they need to provide evidence for that claim. Likewise, if a poster claims a video is CGI they too need to provide evidence for that claim. 'We have the technology' is not evidence.

Originally posted by Soapusmaximus
and look how clear it is!!!!!

Are we watching the same crappy video?