Originally posted by THE_PROFESSIONAL
reply to post by OccamsRazor04
Here is your problem, if someone gets a warrant, what are they looking for? Do they already have evidence? You can get a warrant for the key for the lock but not the combination.
You make a good point. Is the password a key, or a combination. It actually fits both descriptions I think, but is neither. I believe much like a persons private dwelling, the court has the right to compel, so long as evidence for the search is provided, a person to provide access.
They may not be entitled to the password (removing any testimonial information), but they are entitled to access (which is what the key provides). I do not have the right to deny access to my personal home to law enforcement officers in possession of the proper warrant, and I should not be able to deny them access to my computer, so long as they provide the proper warrant.


