The Fat Man

Im in debate, and im sure some of you have heard this hypothetical situation.

ok...

If there was 10 people in a well, (including yourself), and water was filling the well rapidly, and you couldnt climb out because there was a fat man on top, (stuck), would you shoot the fat man (theory saying his muscles would relax and you could push him out) or would you sacrifice your life and the lives of the other people in the well, so the fat man could live?

Different responses mean different things I guess.

Technicly, if I shoot the fatman, theres good chance that he might p00p on us when he die. I refuse to have fatman p00p on me, I'd rather die and drag some people in with me lol...

[Edited on 8-9-2004 by m0rbid]

Ill shoot the fatman,
nothing against him, but he is killing me

Originally posted by JustAnIllusion
Im in debate, and im sure some of you have heard this hypothetical situation.

ok...

If there was 10 people in a well, (including yourself), and water was filling the well rapidly, and you couldnt climb out because there was a fat man on top, (stuck), would you shoot the fat man (theory saying his muscles would relax and you could push him out) or would you sacrifice your life and the lives of the other people in the well, so the fat man could live?

Different responses mean different things I guess.

first i'd question whatever possesed me to jump down a well and let a fat man block the exit

but i'd shoot him

many before the few that's my motto

LOL...
When I read heading I first thinked about this:
www.childrenofthemanhattanproject.org...
nuclearweaponarchive.org...