Originally posted by MegasAlexandros
Alright, I'm back. Just to let you guys know, I'm not Christian, and I'm not stating this as fact. I just thought it was very interesting that
the far Christian right, who ironically supported wars in the Middle East on religious pretenses, are now denouncing the Occupy Movement, although if
one were to read the Bible on their own, they would most likely conclude that Jesus would be among the protesters if he were currently alive.
If you were a big face(Church Leader, politician, ect), *some* people would have agreed and believed it. Or, if the point you were making included
some form of personal gain to be had for believing.
Ultimately, the trick you were trying to use does work. People follow that logic over a lot of things(Such as end times predictions.) However, since
they have no motivation to believe in this case, they won't follow the logic here.
If you would have given a pro or anti OWS spin on it. Such as concluded that the bible predicted it'd work, or fail, it would've been more likely to
get a believer or two. Those who already hold sentiments towards OWS would be more likely to believe logic that confirmed their already held beliefs.
Much more persuasive to have 'God' agree with your subjective feelings and make them objective, than for 'God' to make a neutral reference.
Imagine for example, someone saying that Armageddon will come in 2127. No matter how much evidence they will provide, they couldn't gain as much
support as Harold Camping got despite no evidence behind it. Why? People wanted the world to end, they had an incentive to believe. An appeal to
emotion.
There is psychology behind making people believe things. You're experiment false short. While I'm not saying that you could convince most christians
by making changes like such, you could convince some. Though most christians do succumb to some sort of similar illogical appeal for their beliefs,
it's more subtle than that. And not all do though, there are a genuine few who actually examine their beliefs in a scientific way, not so easily
persuaded. Those are the nice ones to talk to.