Giving Israel back in 1948 = Giving continental USA back to Native Americans in 2011?

How about if Native Americans ran the porn industry, the movie industry, the abortion industry, banking, half of the insurance industry, organized crime and bribed congress on a regular basis?

Would that help?

Originally posted by jondave
If native Americans slaughtered the White Americans, and when they fled they were denied living rights in other countries, then You could compare

reply to post by Terces_Pot_Evoba


1. I'm not sure logic is per se applicable re such justifications.

2. My cosmology is quite Biblical. God has all the gold and makes all the rules. Israel is His treasure.

3. One of my most respected Christian prophetic sources asserts that the Native Americans are going to be caused by God to rise again with greatly more clout in the not distant future. If I understand his impressions accurately, they will do so as the white culture is largely smoldering in ruins.

reply to post by Terces_Pot_Evoba


Personally i don't give a damn about whose land belongs to who. The truth of the matter all this land belongs to God and not a damned one of us owns the dirt he is buried in. You cannot claim to own something that existed long before you ever came into being. That is the equivalent of looking out the window in your house and anywhere you see you can go and stick a flag on it and claim it as your own, and anyone can take your stuff by seeing it too. Be happy with what you have for as long as you have it and quit your bitching. Thats 2 cents worth from a southerner.

I'd be ok with giving America back to Indians....I think we are too materialistic as a society in general.

Doesn't this boil down to the simple fact that Israel does not have a right to exist since ot is based on stolen land?