In Memory of the late Col. Muammar Gaddafi - What History Books will NEVER tell your kids about, page 4
Pages: <<  1    2    3    4    5    6    7  >>
ATS Members have flagged this thread 201 times


reply posted on 21-10-2011 @ 11:07 PM by Americanist
reply to post by Datadayne



I got about 5 mins in. The fact here, and it's painfully obvious at this point...Gaddafi was looking out for himself and his position in life. If he was graciously accepting of his fellow Libyans, he would have negotiated a separate outcome where life wasn't needlessly lost, kept his mouth shut labeling people as rats, and allowed the infrastructure everyone else helped build to remain intact.


On a related note... I've seen G. Bush at Rangers games, and it makes me puke a little in my mouth.


reply posted on 22-10-2011 @ 12:04 AM by tenfly
Hi there OP. Good post. While I, generally, support your opinion, I'd like to add a few points based on some of the replies here:

1) Gadaffi was, indeed, no saint

He certainly had good intentions. I think what happened, though, was that after the earlier "revolution" he consistently was worried about counter revolutionaries trying to take the power back. I'm going to assume that in his frame of mind, he was worried of those trying to take the power away from "the people". Furthermore, I don't think Gadaffi ever truly trusted the people.

If ANY of you actually ever read the Green Book, you'd see that his ideas are actually quite strong and reasonable. In order to keep these ideas working, a certain form of control (or, dictatorship) is required

2) Why all the supporters of a dead Gadaffi??

My guess is that the majority of the 'supporters' are "youngsters" who never actually lived in Libya pre-Gadaffi. As one of the replies states, there are PLENTY of people who absolutely love Gadaffi. They are probably older though.

3) The Monarchists

Has anyone here noticed as of yet that all of the "rebels" are always waving the old Monarchist flags? Furthermore, is anyone aware that the beginning of the "protests" that started this whole rebellion, were launched from organizations based out of the UK and the US? The initial day of protests weren't even organized from those within Libya. That speaks a certain truth on it's own.

In Summary..

I don't think Gadaffi was a saint. He did some stupid things, and trampled the rights of some individuals. That being said, it's Libya - not North America. Things run differently there. I truly believe that he was looking out for Libyans, Africans, etc..Anyone with a basic knowledge of Libya would understand that Libya has ALWAYS been ruled and conquered by Western actors. Gadaffi was the one who 'apparently' was not.

The concept that the whole country is celebrating his death is complete propaganda and stupidity. Yes - I'm sure that there are those who indeed are celebrating. But please, stop pawning off that the whole country is like this. The whole country has practically never been united UNTIL Gaddafi - if that. Seeing as a country has never been unified for centuries, I find it VERY hard to believe that the whole country was against Gadaffi. The success of this operation is entirely due to Western influence aiding and arming a group of disenfranchised youngsters, Westerners, etc..

Thanks.


reply posted on 22-10-2011 @ 12:45 AM by Rigel Kent
Originally posted by Evolutionsend
reply to
post by CasiusIgnoranze



If he's such a great guy, then why did so many people participate in stringing him up? Were they all evil?

This is kind of ridiculous, the man was bad news.
edit on 21-10-2011 by Evolutionsend because: (no reason given)


Its kind of ridiculous how you come to that conclusion... Oh sorry.... you saw it on TV...

PEACE,
RK


reply posted on 22-10-2011 @ 01:10 AM by MikeNice81
Originally posted by IBelieveInMe
The op is right Gaddafi was a great leader for "his people" he did everything he possibly could to help those who blindly followed his lead. What the op fails to provide is details on what life was like for Libyans that questioned his almighty authority.




You mean the disapearances, torture, death penalties and other problems mentioned in the UN pdf the OP posted?

When Eygpt tells you that you should do more to make women equal citizens, there is an issue. When Thailand tells you that you need more laws to protect women from violence and discrimination you've have an issue.

When multiple countries are complaining that you need to at least make a legislation against human trafficking something is wrong.

The trafficking of women and children was a real concern in the country. There was also much international concern about the role women were allowed to play in society. From education to economic involvement women were being actively discriminated against.

A little note from Switzerland
Switzerland recalled that the right to freedom of expression was a fundamental right,
in particular article 19 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights and
article 9 of the African Charter. Switzerland noted that hundreds of peoples were under
administrative detention in the country, despite having been acquitted by the court or
having already served their sentence. Courts continued to pronounce death sentences and
inflict corporal punishment, including whipping and amputation. Switzerland made
recommendations.


Human Rights Watch reported on the death of 19men stuffed in shipping crates with little food and water. They were left to die from suffocation.

Libya: 19 Suffocated
Human Rights Watch interviewed two survivors of the incident and a third man who was detained and tortured in one of the 40-foot long metal containers prior to the incident. A video, apparently filmed by a Gaddafi soldier on his cell phone, viewed by Human Rights Watch, shows the third man and five other detainees getting kicked and whipped inside the container. Human Rights Watch also saw the 18 exhumed bodies, all of them in an advanced state of decomposition, when they were brought, on September 8, to the Tripoli Medical Center morgue.


Before anybody calls them a mouth piece Human Rights Watch has also attacked America on many issues. They have a link on their home page to issues and reports regarding the US. They have nothing to gain by fabricating stories against libya.

From a 2003 report by Human Rights Watch.
Over the past three decades, Libya’s human rights record has been appalling. It has included the abduction, forced disappearance or assassination of political opponents; torture and mistreatment of detainees; and long-term detention without charge or trial or after grossly unfair trials. Today hundreds of people remain arbitrarily detained, some for over a decade, and there are serious concerns about treatment in detention and the fairness of procedures in several on-going high profile trials before the Peoples’ Courts. Libya has been a closed country for United Nations and non-governmental human rights investigators.


edit on 22-10-2011 by MikeNice81 because: (no reason given)



reply posted on 22-10-2011 @ 01:13 AM by LightAssassin
reply to post by CasiusIgnoranze



You know my sentiments Casius.

Nice thread. Stars and flag all round.



reply posted on 22-10-2011 @ 01:24 AM by wcrockett
Google Great Man Made River

www.galenfrysinger.com...

the Gadhafi government completed a massive project to bring fresh water to the people of Libya
This proves that Gadhaffi was thinking of improving the lives of the Libyan people


he did this project without IMF money --this was his greatest sin

thumb your nose to the banksters and get a bullet

just ask John Kennedy, Jaime Roldos, Omar Torrijos

ask John Perkins author of Confessions of an Economic Hitman

www.youtube.com...


reply posted on 22-10-2011 @ 01:26 AM by FrontRunner
Originally posted by CasiusIgnoranze
I decided to make this thread in memory of a Leader who was greatly misunderstood, betrayed and eventually murdered. Whatever preconceived beliefs you may have of the dead man now, there is no denying about the fact about the overwhelming amount of evidence of the GOOD things Gaddafi did and was potentially going to do.

This is not some "communist", "socialistic" Propaganda that "I'm preaching". Most of it is the cold hard truth which I know is hard to swallow and in no way I'm saying Gaddafi was a complete saint. He was a revolutionary whose ideas posed a great threat to the mainstream Elite establishment - and that is something history will forget depending on who writes the history books.

I hope ya’ll don’t mind this thread being a bit long, as I intend to destroy EVERY LIE about Gaddafi told to you by the Mainstream Media, one by one.


LIE 1: “There were Human rights abuses in Libya and Gaddafi slaughtered his own people”

The primary justification for intervention in Libya by NATO was because "there were severe human rights abuses" under Gaddafi's rule. These claims were in reality, far fetched and laughable, because Libya probably had far better human rights than any other country in Africa. What YOU were told by those Mainstream Media fanatics including all those so called "human rights" groups like Amnesty International (which is no doubt another front controlled by the Elite), were all either fabricated lies or deliberately exaggerated for the justified NATO intervention.
This damning piece of evidence (dated 4th January 2011) from the UN Human Rights website which clearly shows undeniable proof that there was absolutely NO EVIDENCE of serious Human Right's abuses as accused by NATO and UN presently.
Libya Human Rights Report by UN - 4th January 2011

Whats more, SEVERAL countries even praised Libya's excellent Human rights Track Record but they still decided to topple Gaddafi! Hypocrisy or what?!

.


I am not sure if you are aware of this but there were videos of loyalists shooting protesters.


reply posted on 22-10-2011 @ 01:29 AM by pillock
Originally posted by Argyll
reply to
post by CasiusIgnoranze



Bull#

I have a couple of close friends who are Libyans.....according to them Gadaffi was an egotistical maniac who oppressed his people.and filled them with fear!......the fact one of his closest allies was Robert Mugabe should speak volumes, unless you consider him to also be a "misunderstood" soul


Speak to a Libyan.......you won't find many, if any, mourning "Mad dog" Gadaffi.


I agree with you 100% Gadaffi was an egotistical maniac who oppressed his people.and filled them with fear!

OP read this Gaddafi's $250 billion stash
www.nzherald.co.nz...


reply posted on 22-10-2011 @ 01:44 AM by kykweer
reply to post by CasiusIgnoranze



You continuously attack MSM outlets, yet you use some of them as sources.

My problem is, when do you decide MSM is truthful? Anything about Libya written in english on the internet could be an outright lie.

So again where do you draw the line? Or do you only believe what you want to believe and wright off what you don't like as propaganda and lies?


reply posted on 22-10-2011 @ 01:53 AM by kykweer
Originally posted by wcrockett



Google Great Man Made River

www.galenfrysinger.com...

the Gadhafi government completed a massive project to bring fresh water to the people of Libya
This proves that Gadhaffi was thinking of improving the lives of the Libyan people


he did this project without IMF money --this was his greatest sin

thumb your nose to the banksters and get a bullet

just ask John Kennedy, Jaime Roldos, Omar Torrijos

ask John Perkins author of Confessions of an Economic Hitman

www.youtube.com...



They have oil, any country with oil and proper management could be a utopia without ever looking in the direction of imf.


reply posted on 22-10-2011 @ 01:55 AM by ChaoticOrder
reply to post by spearhead




If the people of the country were all for outing their leader, why did it take 8 months and thousands of airstikes to dislodge him?
Exactly. And why did NATO even get involved? Why were hundreds of air strikes even necessary? They bombed Libya back into the dark ages. And the Rebels NEVER WOULD HAVE HAD A CHANCE were it not for Western help. There are videos showing the enormous support Gaddafi had, crowds of people cheering him as he drives through the city. What kind of person houses everyone else before their own parents? An evil dictator you think? If you believe that, GROW A BRAIN!!! Gaddafi transformed that country from the poorest nation in Africa to one of the wealthiest. Look what Libya has now. Their infrastructure has been bombed to hell, their new central bank will probably be owned by private shareholders instead of being stated owned, they wont have a debt free country, loans wont be interest free, and a lot of other things will change. It wont take long before they understand the consequences of this. Mark my words. Libya is now a puppet on strings.
edit on 22-10-2011 by ChaoticOrder because: (no reason given)

Pages: <<  1    2    3    4    5    6    7  >>    ^^TOP^^



‘Barcode everyone at birth’
  Posted 6 days ago with 20 member flags
Pentagon Source Alludes to Martial Law Around July 1st, 2012
  Posted 5 days ago with 19 member flags
FBI Seize Email server, then return it
  Posted 18 days ago with 16 member flags
Bilderberg Scheme To Save The Euro
  Posted 14 days ago with 9 member flags
Martial Law in Montreal
  Posted 6 days ago with 9 member flags