reply to post by karen61057
The 3 M's that DO NOT mix.
You asked how could they have wild sex and not shed any dna? Because the whole sex angle was blown WAY out of proportion from the get go.
Did you know there was no evidence of rape or sexual assault? It was all media hype!
see this link
(...It's a view supported by a new postmortem ordered by the investigating magistrate, which this week concluded there is no evidence of rape or
violent sexual assault...) (From link)
Now, putting all that aside - you asked for my opinion.
What I have to go on is watching the thing from the get go. Being here. And - watching how tourists act when they’re here on vacation.
Especially young American tourists.
No, I'm not racists I'm using Amanda's peers as the group I base my opinion on. And these kids and adults - do things (here) they NEVER would have
do back home. It's like, well, it’s just like they treat 'here' like a theme park. Like nothing they do matters. Like there is no
My gawdddd what better evidence do I have to support my claim (above) than her own behavior! You find out your roommate has been stabbed to death and
what do you do? A few cartwheels followed by the splits at police (Caribinieri) headquarters?
Add to that all the behaviorism(s) of Amanda. Drunk. High. Acting like an out of control 'dolt' (to use your words).
All this adds up to me = she was there and that makes her responsible. What extent did she play in the murder? I don’t know. But I do not believe
either she, or her ‘ex’ are innocent.
Remember also it took Meredith over 2 hours to die. There were many ‘hesitation’ cuts on her body. Also marks of strangulation. To me that adds
up to a female attacker.
As for no dna and evidence? The forensics here screwed up the scene so bad (even on camera!) Big Foot could have killed Meredith and left not a hair
Best case scenario for Amanda? It’s my opinion she was there - at least at the beginning. She knew whatever was going on in there was turning bad.
She participated, and then got scarred and ran. And that’s the best case scenario I can come up with for her.
Worst case and what lays closer to my heart? She participated in killing her ‘friend’ Meredith.
So. It’s over. Very badly done all the way around. On all sides. But. It’s over.
edit on 3-10-2011 by silo13 because: (no reason given)