Originally posted by macman
reply to post by FallenWun
What personal attack?
I guess that would be this one.
Originally posted by macman
reply to post by FallenWun
Oh, so sorry. I guess you and some others don't get everything back.
Sounds like you and the others need to get better people doing your taxes.
I guess talking out of your ass is pretty common, as all of your retorts are basically the same anecdotal posts.
Where you not only suggest that I am ignorant about taxes because I do not benefit the way you claim you and EVERYONE making under that much should and then go on to try and label my posts as "the same anecdotal posts" when not one thing I posted was anecdotal. Nothing at all. The only person doing that is you in your backpedal from your original claim.
I was just trying to have an honest conversation. I am really sorry that was too much for you. Feel free to show me my anecdotes though and really make me look stupid.
Originally posted by macman
reply to post by FallenWun
Further more, no lies.
I went on further to state that yes, it was anecdotal on everyone I knew for the $45k a year. I also did reveal that I am not a CPA.
After posting your lie as a fact and after I asked you to back it up, THEN and only then did you change it to the personal anecdote it now is. You do know that when I asked, you had not shifted yet right? You were still claiming that EVERYONE making that little fit the bill. You made the claim twice. That is why I asked you to back it up.
Yes, since you have backpedaled. The problem is that that is the problem. How can anyone take a person seriously when they post something as a fact twice and then when asked to back it up, alter it a bit and instead of admitting the error getting rudely defensive? Would you take me seriously if I pulled a stunt like that?
All you had to do was admit you could not back it up because it was not a fact. It was just your personal experience which amounts to less than 0.000001% of the US population.
I also went on to read where you and mastahunta went on to provoke me on talking out of my ass statements.
Provoke you? Is that how you blame others for how you respond to them? I can read that too and at that point you are still claiming EVERYONE that makes under 45 grand gets everything back. Since you have since admitted in a round about backpedaling kind of way that is not true then how was it not talking out of your ass?
You stated something as a fact. You posted it as if it were true. You posted it twice. Upon questioning it was revealed you had no idea what you were talking about and even less reason to believe the thing you posted as a fact. What would you call that?
Even with being called a liar, Sunsetspawn has refrained from personal attacks (for the most part). And SmedleyBurlap even hashed our differences out.
Um good for them? Not sure how that matters to me.
I know childish taunting when I see them.
Do you really? My first post to you was simply asking you to back up your claim that you stated twice as an absolute fact. All I did was ask you to back up your claim. I did it politely too. Your response was to.....
You two can have it.
When you want to return to the topic at hand, I am ready. As for this jumped rail back and forth, I am done.
Enjoy.
I was trying to be on topic but part of that for me requires having the facts. I find it difficult to have a sincere discussion on any topic when lies, rumors, and let's say "mistakes" are posted as facts in the middle.
I get it. You were wrong. You cannot admit it so you backpedaled. That takes care of that. We now know that your statement that EVERYONE making under 45 grand gets all their taxes back is completely false and that is all I wanted to know. If you were looking for a sincere discussion the topic that would have taken no more than two posts to clear up.
