just a simple question on elenin

please dont ridicule me here im just the messenger
i just want to know does this video have any credible info?
the pics are taken on the 2nd september.

remember im just the messenger whos not an astronomer with a simple question

www.youtube.com...

reply to post by GezinhoKiko


take a look at this thread.

might answer your questions

credits go to Chadwickus for an awesome thread, to be found here:
Elenin did not survive perihelion

reply to post by kn0wh0w


read it and it seems its one amateur astronomer vs another
no OFFICIAL statements from NASA.
im not for or against but we need official confirmation full stop.
Phage can you give me your views please?

reply to post by GezinhoKiko


have you even looked at the thread i've given you a link to?

NASA says Elenin is no threat

reply to post by kn0wh0w


i have just read it and also read the Q&A section on elenin but no mention of it breaking up
seems NASA last update was 16th August

Here is an article explaining the breakup of the comet.

Article

reply to post by watchitburn


thank you for the link but they are using the same amateur astronomer for their source
im not a doomsayer in anyway but during my time on ATS ive learned to not readily accept just one source

reply to post by GezinhoKiko


Agreed,
But NASA seams determined to avoid discussing Elenin any further. So we will just have to wait and see.

Originally posted by GezinhoKiko
reply to post by kn0wh0w

 

read it and it seems its one amateur astronomer vs another
no OFFICIAL statements from NASA.
im not for or against but we need official confirmation full stop.
Phage can you give me your views please?

Thank for sharing your concern with this....
I for one don't see any harm in You being skeptical considering there Are still unanswered questions....And Even More suspiscious activity....example....
www.abovetopsecret.com...
S to the OP
Star 4 asking the questions

reply to post by GezinhoKiko


That can't be Elenin. Having checked on Stellarium one can see that Elenin was still far below the horizon on 4 AM on September 2. In fact it didn't rise until about 8 AM.

reply to post by Xcalibur254


ok cool
so is elenin still showing on stellarium?
im on a ps3 and cant access it

reply to post by GezinhoKiko


We've actually been discussing this on another thread. It turns out he was using a rent-a-scope in Australia, so this could be Elenin. However, the scope he is using does not have an anti-blooming gate. This means he can't really make any conclusions about the condition of Elenin as at that size pixels are going to bleed into one another.

reply to post by Xcalibur254


very interesting
can you link me to the thread?

reply to post by GezinhoKiko


Here you go.

Elenin Has Not Survived Perihelion...Or Has It?

reply to post by Xcalibur254


appreciated
2nd

I saw a comet yesterday. look at this pic


another sunset pic