It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by muzzleflash
Originally posted by Misterlondon
If you never had People debunking threads this site would be ridiculous..
Why cannot you think for yourself ?
Forming a cult around someone and believing everything they say is well, equally as bad as not believing anything someone says because they lied in the past.
Everyone has lied in the past, including Phage. No human is perfect. I guess no one has any credibility anymore.
I guess that means debating things is pointless now. Since we all have lied at least once before.
This website is not ridiculous, but some of the absolutist absurd claims made here sure as heck are ridiculous.
Originally posted by schrodingers dog
"Belief is the death of intelligence." - RAW
Belief is merely personal vanity/ego needing to possess thoughts, it has nothing to do with the truth.
...
... but consider looking into who it was that said it, and take into consideration the fact that he was one of the great truth seekers and conspiratorial minds of the 20th century. He was both those things precisely because he understood that belief not only is not required in the pursuit of truth, but might in fact be the greatest hurdle to it. And he didn't mind debunkers any more than he minded believers ... like most intelligent people he let them play their little self validating games, watched them entrench themselves in the insignificant, and went on his way uncovering truths without their distractions.
Originally posted by BrokenCircles
Originally posted by CasiusIgnoranze
I have noticed a small minority of debunkers who have only one intention - to debunk every single conspiracy on ATS.
How can you be so sure that this is their [color=B1FB17]ONLY intention??
Originally posted by eMachine
Originally posted by schrodingers dog
Belief is merely personal vanity/ego needing to possess thoughts, it has nothing to do with the truth.
...
... but consider looking into who it was that said it, and take into consideration the fact that he was one of the great truth seekers and conspiratorial minds of the 20th century. He was both those things precisely because he understood that belief not only is not required in the pursuit of truth, but might in fact be the greatest hurdle to it. And he didn't mind debunkers any more than he minded believers ... like most intelligent people he let them play their little self validating games, watched them entrench themselves in the insignificant, and went on his way uncovering truths without their distractions.
So, from this I guess I can assume that you want to possess the extraordinary essence of this gentleman. You believe in his reputation, enough to use it as an appeal to authority as far as this topic is concerned. One who believes in a philosophy that aims to create discord just for the sake of doing so is not one that I would give authority over myself.
Like anything else, the concept of logical fallacy can be misunderstood and misused, and can even become a source of fallacious reasoning. To say that an argument is fallacious is to claim that there is no sufficiently strong logical connection between the premisses and the conclusion. This says nothing about the truth-value of the conclusion, so it is unwarranted to conclude that a proposition is false simply because some argument for it is fallacious.
Thanks for inciting a bit of research and a good deal of contemplation, I just can't agree on this matter. I think a complete lack of belief in anything whatsoever would only empower those who aim to manipulate me.
Originally posted by InnerPeace2012
Are we not all for seeking the truth??? If you've joined ATS with nothing other than habitual debunking, than you got get your act straight, your not helping the course.
Originally posted by eMachine
So, when I see someone holding up another person's reputation as a reason for me to admire and look up to that person, I do feel that it is an attempt to put that person above myself. Others can choose idols for themselves if they need someone to emulate, but their idols won't be imposed upon me.
You mean to say the one-liner you posted, which included a quote and no explanation, was not relevant to the topic of the thread you posted it in? Sorry if that caused me to misunderstand.
i think he ment that just because somebody(a professional/expert) understands the subject being discussed better than the guy proposing the theory(OP) and instantly debunks the theory it does not mean the guy debunking has set out to "do some debunkin" they just grasp the matter better. nothing can be done in that situation "someone just understands better" maybe thay explain maybe they don't
Originally posted by muzzleflash
Saying someone doesn't understand something is a cop out.
Explain it to them than, clearly and concisely, if you are so enlightened.
But just simply saying "You just don't understand, hahahaha" is lame to the max.
I have noticed a small minority of debunkers (not naming any names) who have only one intention - to debunk every single conspiracy on ATS. This small minority of "elite" debunkers have thousands of stars and posts, all of which are dedicated to debunking at whatever cost (having checked their history of posts and threads).
It just doesn't make sense to why they would join a conspiracy site to debunk conspiracies when the only reason behind it is that they have an agenda or are paid agents by The Powers That Be (TPTB).
These elite debunkers are so perfectly well adapted to ATS and have gathered huge support from ATS users that if they were named, this thread would no doubt be attacked and ridiculed!
Just to clear things up, I don't have a problem with debunkers. But those that make it a mission to debunk/ridicule every conspiracy discussed on ATS since they have joined, is my cause for concern.
Originally posted by silent thunder
Deny ignorance.
Sometimes denying ignorance means accepting conspiracy, sometimes debunking.
While kneekjerk debunkery is just as blind as kneejerk "i wanna believe," ultimately a good skeptic adds real value to the community by pushing everyone to refine their position and bring it closer to the truth.
Originally posted by schrodingers dog
Well yeah, that's the other consequence of personal beliefs, they lead to an awful lot of "feelings."
Passive aggressive Saturdays are fun.
Originally posted by schrodingers dog
"Belief is the death of intelligence." - RAW
Originally posted by eMachine
Originally posted by schrodingers dog
Well yeah, that's the other consequence of personal beliefs, they lead to an awful lot of "feelings."
Right. Those pesky feelings. We should get rid of them, nature didn't have a clue what it was doing.
Originally posted by AzazeI
These elite members you speak of have all earned those stars.
Originally posted by CasiusIgnoranze
reply to post by Misterlondon
Like I said, I don't mind people debunking the odd conspiracy. But those who try to debunk/ridicule every single conspiracy since they have joined whether as a troll or paid agent, is my cause for concern.