Originally posted by nyk537
I'm not for banning anything anywhere....but in this case it really is up to the school. If the kids want to read these books nobody can stop them.
They could still get them from the local library or the internet...just not at the school library.
I guess you're right, but this also means that no teachers at the school can put the books into a curriculum. And potentially could get in trouble
for even suggesting it, I think? But I'm not sure about that bit...
And the fact that a litigious society can lead to this kind of thing... Well, that might be even worse. If people could sue a school for perceived
harm by literary classics, and thus control what can be taught to any of the students... That's just plain messed up.
Originally posted by TechVampyre
Books won't stay banned. They won't burn. Ideas won't go to jail. In the long run of history, the censor and the inquisitor have always lost.
The only weapon against bad ideas is better ideas. ~Alfred Whitney Griswold, New York Times, 24 February 1959
In general, that's true, especially in modern days... But I hate to say, that hasn't really been borne out by history... How much knowledge did we
lose forever throughout history, with the repeated sacking & burning of the Library of Alexandria? sure, that wasn't an active attempt to censor,
but it happened... And other books, that weren't intentionally lost, but have slipped away from us?
I seem to be doing this more and more, but Cracked has a couple good articles about those books...
www.cracked.com...
www.cracked.com...
Originally posted by HenryTwoTimes
To even suggest that any book be banned should be an arrestable offense.
I know that was hyperbole, and I agree basically, but
man that would be ironic! Censoring discussion of censorship!