Should the US deport ALL dual Israel/US citizens ???

There are tons of data out there that suggest Israel
is manipulating the US Economy, Politics, Fed Reserve,
Foreign Policy, etc..... the list is endless.

There was even a pledge by over 300 congressmen
and women recently that signed a loyalty pledge to
Israel, yet they were elected to represent American
citizens. As you can tell, this country is in shambles
right now and on the verge of a mass revolution.

So my question to all ATS'ers out there.
Is this part of our problem???

Should the US deport ALL dual Israeli/US citizens
in an effort to stabilize and correct this condition ???

And/or should they be allowed to serve in a US
gov position or office ???

your thoughts ???

They shouldn't be allowed in government. Not only Israel/US citizens, but those of any other dual citizenship.

But deport them, no.

Originally posted by Vitchilo
They shouldn't be allowed in government. Not only Israel/US citizens, but those of any other dual citizenship.

But deport them, no.

if they are not deported
then they become covert spies
against US interest.

Still want to keep them ???

How would the U.S know what to pass into law if all the lobbyist's are gone?....

Originally posted by CanadianDream420
How would the U.S know what to pass into law if all the lobbyist's are gone?....

oh I don't know, maybe laws that work FOR
American citizens maybe ????

reply to post by boondock-saint

I can't help but think your argument leads to thinking such as... why not deport everyone who isn't "American"? They may all be spies.
... might just be a little overkill (and racist... how far away are you from making them wear the star of david to denote who they are? how far from keeping them all in the same fenced off controlled area?)

Divide and conquer... be divided and be conquered.

Just because there are a few bad apples in a bushel, do you throw out the entire bushel?

Originally posted by MikeyBones
Just because there are a few bad apples in a bushel, do you throw out the entire bushel?

I think u may be misinterpreting my question.

I am not against any people who want to come
here and be American Citizens.

However, what I am saying is, you need to
leave your other citizenship at the door when
you enter here. Being citizens of multiple
nations leads one to assume, they have
an agenda not loyal to the country they
are moving into.

Deporting people because they are from or support Israel is wrong. But anyone holding office that has sworn loyalty to Israel should be removed from office immediately.

Without the usual sources, proof and other items proving the point the answer is no. Well, I have to modify that. In order to complete the task, racism as a reason also has to be proven.

Originally posted by buster2010
Deporting people because they are from or support Israel is wrong. But anyone holding office that has sworn loyalty to Israel should be removed from office immediately.

lol, big job
there are over 300 US Gov employees
who have dual Israeli / US Citizenship
and encompass all 3 branches of gov
including Obama's last choice for the US
Supreme Court Elena Kagen.

www.viewzone.com...

this is no different than an invading army
breaching our shores.

Countries Which Allow Dual Citizenship:
Bangladesh, Brazil, Canada, Colombia, Cyprus, Egypt, El Salvador, Federal Republic of Yugoslavia, France, Greece, Hungary, Ireland, Israel, Italy, Jordan, Latvia, Lebanon, Lithuania, Macedonia, Malta, Mexico, New Zealand, Pakistan*, Portugal, Serbia and Montenegro, South Africa*, Spain (only in certain cases), Sweden, Switzerland, Syria, Tonga (only in certain cases), Turkey, United Kingdom, United States of America, Western Samoa.

Countries Which Prohibit Dual Citizenship:
Austria, Belgium, Brunei, Burma, Chile, China, Denmark, Ecuador, Fiji, Finland, Germany, Iceland, India, Indonesia, Iran*, Japan, Kenya, Kiribati, Korea, Malaysia, Mauritius, Nepal, Norway, Papua New Guinea, Peru, Philippines, Poland, Romania, Singapore, Solomon Islands, Thailand, Venezuela, Vietnam, Zimbabwe.

oops, sorry didn't know that domain was banned here

Originally posted by boondock-saint
I think u may be misinterpreting my question.

maybe, but your are really dancing along fine line. what of those that have family in both countries? your statement is too black and white for this very gray world. I think that many innocent and decent people would be affected (hence the apple analogy), and most likely would not have the result you are looking for (the bad guys will still get their hands into the US's business... money is probably more powerful than dual citizenship)

Originally posted by MikeyBones
maybe, but your are really dancing along fine line. what of those that have family in both countries? your statement is too black and white for this very gray world.

when you enter the US Military you take an oath
of loyalty to the US.

Why should immigrants that come here not be subjected
to the same loyalty question. Who do you serve?
Where does your loyalty lie ??? You cannot have
more than one.

Seems that the issue isn't so much dual citizenship but the failure of the US government to put US citizens first. The US is one of the few "modern" societies that refuses to let birth citizens become dual citizens but allows other citizens dual status and also allows non-citizens to invade unhindered.

The problem is with some of our laws being improperly biased in favor of noncitizens and the failure of our government to enforce any laws that protect the interests of US citizens within the US borders.

First off, theres no links in your post to back up any of your claims.........

Second that line of thinking leads to horrible horrible acts............

Wheres the proof that anyone in gov pledged anything to Israel?

Other then the fact that they are our allies, and Obama has shown without a doubt that he has NO idea what the hell that means.....look how hes treated britain........


I guess we could put them all in camps like we did with japanese americans during the war hmmm????

Holy crap. Would you want to put them on railcars, perhaps? This is not a way to solve a problem, only easy ammunition to use against people who have legitimate concerns over United States policy toward Israel in general.

Originally posted by daeoeste
Holy crap. Would you want to put them on railcars, perhaps?

This is not a way to solve a problem, only easy ammunition to use against people who have legitimate concerns over United States policy toward Israel in general.

whoa
u r taking this way out of context.
I said nothing about rail cars.
I am just asking a question,
would we be better off by
disallowing dual citizenships??

Clearly, Israel intended to send a message to Vice-president Biden and the United States, and that message was "We can do whatever we like, and there is nothing you can do about it!"

Former Israeli Prime Minister, Ariel Sharon, made that point even more clearly in October 2001, when he was quoted as saying "Don't worry about American pressure on Israel. We, the Jewish people, control America, and the Americans know it."

newsblaze.com...

doesn't sound too much like a free Republic
to me, does it you ???

food for thought

Originally posted by boondock-saint
Should the US deport ALL dual Israeli/US citizens
in an effort to stabilize and correct this condition ???

So easy to compare this idea to the holocaust, though considerably less violent in theory, one might interpret it as horribly anti-semetic/"racist" (despite Jews not being a race and the possibility that not all US/Israeli citizens are Jewish)

My verdict: not a politically sound idea.